It might me Caleb's Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day, but Liam's having the time of his life.

Nott: Caleb, are you okay?
Caleb: So good, so good
Nott: HE'S MIND CONTROLLED!! CALEB WOULD NEVER SAY HE'S OKAY, LET ALONE 'SO GOOD'!!!

I love that Matt says "Oh you prepared Revivify? Good!" As he thinks to himself 'good, that means I'm free to kill someone'

Just imagine how much worse Caleb's PTSD would be if he had killed one of the Nein, or even just Nugget

oh my god you can see caleb's expression change at 3:00 as breaks himself from the charm for a split second at the mention of astrid and then revert back... liam's acting never ceases to amaze me

4:55 I love that little moment, Beau running over and making an emotional plea to Caleb, and he just looks her dead in the eye and coldly remarks:

"And that's the end of your turn."

Matt: Can I see your spell list real fast?
Marisha: grabs Liam and Travis so she doesn't fall out of her chair

Travis is the hype man. He gets hype even when Caleb is forced to kill his friends. Totally get it though, this was honestly such an awesome moment, and super heavy hitting emotionally, since Caleb's already been through the whole "kill someone you love while manipulated" deal.

8:52 Travis' unbridled excitement hoots give me life.

Nott: your puny and weak
Caleb: decimates the entire party in one shot

i love travis' reaction to Liam helping Matt: "this is great"

Matt and Liam were having so much fun here. Caleb? Not so much.

Poor Caleb has some serious PTSD.

This fight with caleb.... Everything just seemed to line up perfectly. He got amazing rolls because he was inspired by the fact his friends were attacking him. He resisted the control water and everything

Look at that eager DM smile on Matt when he asks for Caleb's spell list

Awesome xD

‘light them up pretty’ DAMN DAMN DAMN

I'm going to have to steal that mannerism from Liam, that with only a hand gesture you knew exactly what spell he was casting. Obviously it's not necessary for every spell (And obviously you should say what you're casting) but having it around for the big ones adds something for those moments you want to be particularly dramatic.

The Mighty Nein and the Quest to Get Caleb to A Therapist

The fact that Caleb almost single handedly killed his entire party is something that should have been exploited the shit out of. Imagine how shitty he feels after this, he was controlled again, "is this the day we've feared? Do I have to kill you?" which confirms that the nein doesn't trust him, he gave his friends terrible burns.

8:52 I have NEVER heard Travis make those sounds before in all my time watching CR.