Applejack being a liar; despite being the element of honesty, and that being CRUCIAL to your theory is hilarious😭

In the Hebrew dub of the series, Applejack said that Pinky is planning her parents' 500th wedding anniversary.

"it could last even 5, 6, or... more years"
you narrowly avoided it.

Is it a continuity error or Applejack being in denial about her own age, like a lot of people over 30.

Your theory seems very logical, but I have a question: Since ponies can control the seasons how are we sure that counting the numbers of winters is a good way to measure time? What if in their world they change season every month or sometimes Princess Celestia is in Christmas mood and just decides to have winter three times that year?

My personal theory is very much similar to yours, EXEPT that time in Equestria passes 2 times faster, not 3

That makes the mane six to be around 34. It also fixes plotholes such as baby cakes and Pinkie's parents while mantaining the diffrent passage of time. Also RD's cake having 35 candles also lines up nicely

being earlier than the dinosaurs is insane

17:25 and our $2 coin is called a toonie... because it's 2 loonies...

Just a side note, another thing to prove that they have 7 days in a week is in FIM S2 E5 “Sisterhooves Social” when Rarity’s parents say they’re gone for a week. Rarity then asks, “As in 7 whole days?”

12:53 I have an answer! We have to consider that Equestria’s legal system may be different from ours. The legal minimum age for marriage in Equestria could be a lot lower than Earth’s.

That's just a theory, a pony theory

Wait... what if a Day in the Pony World is only 8 Human World Hours?

So basically being 50 is equivalent to being like 20 or something so being 50 is really young for them

About the portal, Twilight permanently opened it in Rainbow Rocks
About pinkie’s parents, it’s likely equestrians don’t perceive themselves to be in their 50s. According to the human world’s speed, the mane 6 are 51 and 52, but to them, their time is moving at a speed we would perceive our world to be moving and they would be/describing themselves as being something less than 50.
And for Sweetie Belle, either they physically age slower near the start of their lives or DHX didn’t want to make more character rigs than they had to

And about why your deadly mane 6 video did better, at least for me it was much more rewatchable. Yeah I already knew the abilities of them after I watched it once, but it’s fun just listening to how powerful they are, and it’s a good bg video for when I’m playing a game or something

@5:22-.-My theory either way is that there's a sort of reincarnation thing going on with the human counterpart. So Celestia technically have multiple human counterparts over the years, with each one have you been born and then died one after the other. Until we get more clarification on how the two worlds are connected, that's the best I can think of.

@1:24-.-So during the event of the actual show, they would be more like 45? That sounds slightly more reasonable.

15:39 dodged a bullet there

Star Strike pls take a nap buddy we are worried about you

17:44 as a short person this logic bugs me so much. the amount of times people have treated me as younger than i am 🤦 i'm still a minor but i am a teenager and i still get asked if i want a kids menu at restaurants
the most egregious offense was when i was going to see a musical with my mom and a woman asked me if i needed a booster seat 😭 WILD
anyway yeah height ≠ age this is stupid

3:47 Hey, that's you! :D