I will sing at your funeral...

Silver is like a G rated Deadpool. He's super talkative, full of himself, and can't be killed.

So if Silver Quill dies, it will of course be very sad.

On the other hand, we'll get to hear Doctor Wolf sing again...

Geez, that's a toss-up.

In response to Lightning Bliss at around 21 minutes and how she felt those things were overdoing it and not worth thinking as scary, I agree that they aren't scary in the way you expect from Halloween but they are in a different way.

Things like that are terrifying for someone like myself who has social anxiety and watching that scene I just imagined Fluttershy taking from personal past experiences and my heart really went out to her.

Out of sugar? That's terrifying because it's not having something everyone would think was obviously needed. It's scary because it paints a bad picture of yourself as one who is either too stupid to realize they needed said thing or too inconsiderate to care.

Having guests that you weren't expecting is having your plans mixed up. I just recently went through something similar to this where I did what i always do, mentally prepare myself before going out of my comfort zone as someone with social anxiety. Having that ripped from under you by having your plans changed is like setting the safety net below your trapeze act on fire. Not only is your original safety measure gone, but now everything is worse because you don't know how to handle the situation. Going through something like this has literally put me through an anxiety attack where my dad and to drive to where I was and pray with me to calm me down.

I understand where you're coming from, especially when Fluttershy admitted herself that she wasn't trying her best but I got something else out of that.

The way I saw it, Fluttershy was taking full responsibility in that she understood too late that these kinds of scares were not the ones her friends were looking for. According to this episode's continuity, Fluttershy NEVER partakes in Nightmare Night and her only understanding of the holiday is that scaring is what people want. She doesn't do haunted houses or mazes because it's never appealed to her.

So when she hears "scare your friends" I think her mind, the mind of someone with Social Anxiety, defaulted to the most terrifying and traumatizing experiences she's had. She defaulted to "you weren't prepared already but now it's even worse cause your plans are changed anyways". When she realized this isn't what the group was looking for, she was disappointed in herself and recognized that she went with the default assumption instead of thinking further. Hence the "I didn't try hard enough"= "I didn't think hard enough".

At least, that's what I got out of it.

That bit you said after being guillotine'd reminds me of a quote from Robert A. Heinlein.

"Don't ever become a pessimist... a pessimist is correct oftener than an optimist, but an optimist has more fun, and neither can stop the march of events."

huh, well thats explains how silver escaped over every single near death experience, he's like deadpool, unkillable, now that's hilarious. am i right folks?

11:10 sounds like her costume is getting to Keyframe - never have truer words been spoken about the pointlessness of recaps. But as always the audience is not happy being confronted with wisdom and reason -_-

I would actually like to chime in on Fluttershy's fear in this episode. I think it actually is understandable from a season standpoint. Afraid something might actually attack her, that may be due to a certain Purple Unicorn in this season not being completely dealt with in the first 2 episodes of the season. Said Purple Unicorn could want revenge for the events that transpired especially towards the one who foiled her plan in the first place. Starlight was still a problem and this episode is only a few episodes away from the season finale. (I still see this episode as episode 21 of this season no matter how early it leaked.)

The fifty points form Gryffindor had me dying!!

Aw, come on! No one even mentioned best background pony's costume! :( Derpy was dressed as Twilight, and it was hilarious to see. XD

A 40 Minute Silver-Quill Video? Grabs Large Popcorn Bucket

Baron: The game is over! You all fail, I'm great, you're all losers, GET OUT!!!

Keyframe: Call me?

Baron: NEIGH!!!!

Finally Silver, you got them all.  Now go for the bonus round to get the princesses and the family members of the heroes.

Finn was dressed as Fix It Felix Jr. from Wreck It Ralph

(stands up clapping)

I found Fluttershy's fears completely understandable, if a little exaggerated for comedic effect. I personally can't handle horror movies or haunted houses and find it hard to understand the enjoyment some people get from being scared. Also, while Halloween doesn't frighten me, Fluttershy's alternative use of time is frankly just as (if not more) appealing to me as celebrating the holiday normally (and remarkably similar to what I ended up doing this year). So good on ya Flutters, for trying something new and then having the courage to admit you don't like it, even if it's popular.

18:40 This is actually perfectly plausible. I have anxiety problems and my mind immediately goes to the worst possible scenario, which stops me from doing stuff

Even as a zombie, Key still has a great voice.

"Call me?" Keyframe stole the show, 100%!

Silver really nailed it with his analysis of Fluttershy's fear, and the dark side of fandom conflict. Great review everyone!

"I thought you were just ToonKritic having another identity crisis."

Oh my god LOL!