I used to have back in the early 80’s a aluminium neck Kramer Flying V bass , the neck dive took you to hell but it was totally indestructible, so many guitars out there are so fragile
Back in the 1970s, I used to work on brass(wind) instruments. Something people who are criticising you are maybe missing is "what the customer wanted". Yes, there are other ways you could have done the job, but at a price. Whether the customer was prepared to meet the bill to rebuild the whole dovetail, then use hide glue to secure it is something you obviously had to consider. Incidentally, it was Gretsch who used to put a long screw to secure the neck joint. Hofners mostly have a sort-of lazy tenon that comes apart over the years. At least they're easy to fix, though.
Dudes they all eventually need a neck reset they fold up like a lawn chair because there's nothing to keep them from slipping the kneck mounting block anytime the glue gets hot.
Wow!! I have just finished a BUILD with neck recycled from a MIJ EPiPHONE bolt on acoustic!! Rebuilt the heel and tenon Purchased an Epiphone/Gibson style body in the white out of Asia and made and EPIPHONE 'Century' Model replica no cutaway I might share a Christmas greeting just uploaded https://www.youtube.com/shorts/LcXre9VvwawP
I can't believe people knocking your dialogs! I specifically watch your channel almost exclusively to hear your breakdowns on guitar and guitar-related subjects! I can't stand guitar repair videos that don't have the explanations of whatever is being remedied!
I love that videos like this exist. My customers become lifers after seeing stuff like this. 😬
Proper repair would’ve included restoring the tenon with fresh wood FIRST…..and epoxy would’ve been completely acceptable in the restoration of the tenon itself. THEN shape that new tenon to fit the guitar perfectly. THEN use proper wood glue to install the neck.
You’ve essentially created a neck joint that will be unserviceable FOR LIFE.
I'm a far worse tech than you. I eyeball everything and take way too long to set up my guitars. It took me about a week to set up my SE and close to a month to set up a Floyd Rose.
Not a luthier nor do I work on guitars, just curious and learning. Why would you not flatten the tenon on both sides and glue new wood and then clean up the neck joint and fit it properly? Did the client not have the budget for all that? Thanks for all the vids