One-Day-Old Babies Deserve Hell" — Christian Debater's Own Source Backfires
Savage Wisdom
1,633 views
"I would say that one-day-old babies deserve to go to hell." That's a real line from this debate.
Jake Brancatella (The Muslim Metaphysician) debates a Christian apologist on "Is the Bible Evil?" — starting as a close Hebrew word study of Deuteronomy 22:25-29 (is the word "seize," implying rape, or closer to consensual seduction?) before Jake produces a direct quote from the early church father Tertullian that appears to contradict his opponent's claim that "no Christian has ever read it that way."
From there it pivots to 1 Samuel 15 and the Amalekite infants — and a real philosophical clash: are humans born sinners deserving judgment, or born innocent? What sin, exactly, does a one-day-old commit?
⏱️ Topics covered: Deuteronomy 22:25-29 Hebrew word study · Tertullian cited live · 1 Samuel 15 & the Amalekite infants · Original sin vs. innate innocence · Are babies morally guilty?
#ChristianVsMuslim #IsTheBibleEvil #Apologetics #JakeBrancatella #MuslimMetaphysician #OriginalSin #Tertullian #ComparativeReligion
2 Comments
One-Day-Old Babies Deserve Hell" — Christian Debater's Own Source Backfires
Savage Wisdom
1,633 views
"I would say that one-day-old babies deserve to go to hell." That's a real line from this debate.
Jake Brancatella (The Muslim Metaphysician) debates a Christian apologist on "Is the Bible Evil?" — starting as a close Hebrew word study of Deuteronomy 22:25-29 (is the word "seize," implying rape, or closer to consensual seduction?) before Jake produces a direct quote from the early church father Tertullian that appears to contradict his opponent's claim that "no Christian has ever read it that way."
From there it pivots to 1 Samuel 15 and the Amalekite infants — and a real philosophical clash: are humans born sinners deserving judgment, or born innocent? What sin, exactly, does a one-day-old commit?
⏱️ Topics covered: Deuteronomy 22:25-29 Hebrew word study · Tertullian cited live · 1 Samuel 15 & the Amalekite infants · Original sin vs. innate innocence · Are babies morally guilty?
#ChristianVsMuslim #IsTheBibleEvil #Apologetics #JakeBrancatella #MuslimMetaphysician #OriginalSin #Tertullian #ComparativeReligion