What it gets right?
It makes you FEEL like Spider-Man.

Yuri was perfect as spidey

If I flip the pizzas Mr Aziz will flip out

"The man and the superhero are the exact same person"

There, that is precisely why this game turned me into a Spider-man fan. Also, Silver Sable is now my ultimate waifu.

I like the part where you swing on a web.

1:52 Ultimate Spider-Man: Total Mayhem throws me back

Remember Arkham Knight? Where there were all these different villain side quests and they all ended so unsatisfying? For Marvel Spiderman 2 PS4(TM), gimme the opposite of that. Gimme a side quest where I need to mess with a bunch of water valves and end up in a dramatic boss fight against Hydro Man. This guy has some of the best villains ever, they deserve good, fun set piece boss battles. Also... Having old bosses break out and mess with the open world? Just be a swinging and suddenly: BOOM, DOPPELGANGER SWINGS IN AND YOU HAVE THIS ARIAL, SWINGING BOSS ENCOUNTER.

But for hardline spoilers.

I think they should prelude the Venom arc with the Goblin arc first. Have Norman and Peter’s relationship turn into a complex bittersweet fallout which will give rise and reason to Harry becoming Venom and hating Spider-Man further down the line.

While introducing the rest of Spidey’s rogues in non sinister six fashion like sidequests like fighting Hydro-Man, being hunted by Kraven, neutralizing Sandman. While making Otto, a more mentally complex villain in the process

4:05 "And Venom becomes a Kaiji"
Venom becomes the Ultimate Gambler?

This game along with Spectacular Spider-Man are what I believe to be the best adaptations of Spider-Man in any media outside the comics.

I think the sequel should have Miles and Peter be a sort of gta 5 type thing where it switches you for the story the first few times then you can switch between the two and each have their own side missions and collectables. Someone else in the comments mentioned different seasons and I think swinging around new York in a massive blizzard would be amazing.

I was pretty blown away at how good this ended up being, like I knew it was likely going to be a good game, but to be the best version of Spider-Man in entertainment right now is incredibly impressive and what they are hinting at with the sequel could very well lead to that game being better than the first, so I'm pretty excited.

"PS4-Man" is a nicely layered joke. It's great.

17:00 Okay. So, Mary Jane doing some L. A. Noire interviews in a Spider-Man game?

Insomniac is the best thing to happen to spider-man in a long time!

MJ should have LA Noire style interviews in the sequel

I still like web of shadows but you are right about it

Imagine if the PS4 Spiderman games made the clone saga good. That would be amazing, Peter parker the spectacular

But when are they finaĺly going to let us fight "The Spot"?!?

Insomniac deserves the praise here not sony.