Any person being 100% truthful would not need to be evasive, as this EMT is being. What smells fishiest is her not remembering hanging out at a beach with another girl you've known for years. Also, not remembering her own bathing suit... what's up with that? I live at the beach and own over a dozen bathing suits. You know your own bathing suit. That she would be evasive on such a simple question, is just plain strange. The judge is a piece of work, she needs to check the photo... after the witness has already confirmed she's in the picture. She is so clearly partial to the prosecution it's embarrassing.
How tf did Johns phone survive a night out in below freezing temps and with all that moisture too? Iphones are designed to shut down when they get too cold or hot, it was still on when it was found.