#DeathValley #SailingStones #HistoryOfScience
Why do the moving stones of Death Valley move? There are no footprints, yet long trails stretch out behind the stones. Isn't that strange?
This video follows a mystery no one could witness for about 65 years after the first report in 1948, from the first two answers and their problems to a 7-year watch, a kitchen experiment and stones fitted with GPS in December 2013, in the same order the researchers saw the evidence.
What surprised me most: even after naming 30 stones and watching them for 7 years, no one ever saw one move.
▼Chapters
0:00 Death Valley's moving stones: about 65 years, never seen moving
0:30 1948: the two men who first reported the trails
1:00 No slope, no footprints: a height difference of only centimeters
1:44 The first two answers
2:27 1968: naming 30 stones and watching them
3:12 A stone fenced in by stakes, and Karen, who did not move for 7 years
3:57 1995 and 1996: two ideas that would not go away
4:36 2011: an experiment you can do in the kitchen
5:20 15 stones fitted with GPS, and cameras that kept rolling
6:09 December 2013
7:09 What the sound was
8:01 The paper's photo: the day more than 60 stones moved
8:30 One reason no one saw them move for so long
8:55 Were the first two answers wrong? And what we still don't know
▼Notes
The visuals are schematic. Numbers are approximate and vary by source.
“About 65 years” counts from the first report (1948) to 2013, when the stones were first seen moving.
The GPS stones recorded movement on December 4 and December 20, 2013. The moment of movement was seen on site on December 20.
The wind speed once thought necessary (33-45 m/s in the video's chart) is Sharp's estimate as cited by Norris et al. (2014). Other estimates include over 40 m/s (Bacon et al. 1996) and up to 80 m/s (Reid et al. 1995).
Sources describe the north end of the lake bed as only slightly higher than the south; the video says “a few centimeters.”
There is more than one reason the movement went unseen for so long; the video shows one of them.
Some research suggests the stones may move less often than before, but the reason is not yet clear.
Both the gust idea and the large ice sheet idea were reasonable answers based on the observations and calculations of their time.
Death Valley National Park asks visitors not to move or take the stones, not to walk on the lake bed when it is wet, and not to drive off the roads.
▼References
Norris R.D., Norris J.M., Lorenz R.D., Ray J., Jackson B. (2014) PLOS ONE 9(8): e105948 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone....
Scripps Institution of Oceanography (2014) news release (including remarks by Richard Norris)
NPS, “Death Valley's Moving Rocks” / “The Racetrack”
USGS, “racetrack playa 1 / 10 / 11”
McAllister J.F., Agnew A.F. (1948) GSA Bulletin / Stanley G.M. (1955) GSA Bulletin
Sharp R.P., Carey D.L. (1976) GSA Bulletin 87
Reid J.B. et al. (1995) Geology / Bacon D. et al. (1996) J. Geology 104
Lorenz R.D. et al. (2011) Am. J. Phys. 79 / Lorenz R.D., Jackson B.K. (2014)
▼Materials and audio
Photo: a stone and its trail. USGS (Geology and Ecology of National Parks, published 2003). Public domain. Cropped
Photo: aerial view of Racetrack Playa with 1940s mapping marks. USGS (Geology and Ecology of National Parks). Public domain. Cropped; one version grayscaled and darkened
Photo: the stone “Karen.” USGS (Geology and Ecology of National Parks, published 2003). Public domain. Cropped
Photo: the lake bed on December 20, 2013. Norris R.D. et al. (2014) PLOS ONE 9(8): e105948, Fig 2. CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/.... Cropped to the upper photo
Sharp and Carey's (1976) figures are not used; their records are redrawn in original diagrams
Narration is synthetic speech by Google Gemini TTS (Orus). BGM was also generated with AI (ElevenLabs). Sound effects made in-house
3D, animation and diagrams are original. Still images of places and scenes were made with generative AI. No faces of real people were generated (backs, hands and silhouettes only)
Part of the series “Unraveling - Until Humanity Grasped the Truth” (Japanese narration).
Top 10 solved mysteries, ranked by how long they took: 解明された謎ランキングTOP10。1位は、解けるまで約2,200年かかった
The Tunguska explosion that left no crater: ツングースカ大爆発は、クレーターを一つも残さなかった。【1908年 シベリア、倒れた...
#DeathValley #SailingStones #HistoryOfScience
Why do the moving stones of Death Valley move? There are no footprints, yet long trails stretch out behind the stones. Isn't that strange?
This video follows a mystery no one could witness for about 65 years after the first report in 1948, from the first two answers and their problems to a 7-year watch, a kitchen experiment and stones fitted with GPS in December 2013, in the same order the researchers saw the evidence.
What surprised me most: even after naming 30 stones and watching them for 7 years, no one ever saw one move.
▼Chapters
0:00 Death Valley's moving stones: about 65 years, never seen moving
0:30 1948: the two men who first reported the trails
1:00 No slope, no footprints: a height difference of only centimeters
1:44 The first two answers
2:27 1968: naming 30 stones and watching them
3:12 A stone fenced in by stakes, and Karen, who did not move for 7 years
3:57 1995 and 1996: two ideas that would not go away
4:36 2011: an experiment you can do in the kitchen
5:20 15 stones fitted with GPS, and cameras that kept rolling
6:09 December 2013
7:09 What the sound was
8:01 The paper's photo: the day more than 60 stones moved
8:30 One reason no one saw them move for so long
8:55 Were the first two answers wrong? And what we still don't know
▼Notes
The visuals are schematic. Numbers are approximate and vary by source.
“About 65 years” counts from the first report (1948) to 2013, when the stones were first seen moving.
The GPS stones recorded movement on December 4 and December 20, 2013. The moment of movement was seen on site on December 20.
The wind speed once thought necessary (33-45 m/s in the video's chart) is Sharp's estimate as cited by Norris et al. (2014). Other estimates include over 40 m/s (Bacon et al. 1996) and up to 80 m/s (Reid et al. 1995).
Sources describe the north end of the lake bed as only slightly higher than the south; the video says “a few centimeters.”
There is more than one reason the movement went unseen for so long; the video shows one of them.
Some research suggests the stones may move less often than before, but the reason is not yet clear.
Both the gust idea and the large ice sheet idea were reasonable answers based on the observations and calculations of their time.
Death Valley National Park asks visitors not to move or take the stones, not to walk on the lake bed when it is wet, and not to drive off the roads.
▼References
Norris R.D., Norris J.M., Lorenz R.D., Ray J., Jackson B. (2014) PLOS ONE 9(8): e105948 https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone....
Scripps Institution of Oceanography (2014) news release (including remarks by Richard Norris)
NPS, “Death Valley's Moving Rocks” / “The Racetrack”
USGS, “racetrack playa 1 / 10 / 11”
McAllister J.F., Agnew A.F. (1948) GSA Bulletin / Stanley G.M. (1955) GSA Bulletin
Sharp R.P., Carey D.L. (1976) GSA Bulletin 87
Reid J.B. et al. (1995) Geology / Bacon D. et al. (1996) J. Geology 104
Lorenz R.D. et al. (2011) Am. J. Phys. 79 / Lorenz R.D., Jackson B.K. (2014)
▼Materials and audio
Photo: a stone and its trail. USGS (Geology and Ecology of National Parks, published 2003). Public domain. Cropped
Photo: aerial view of Racetrack Playa with 1940s mapping marks. USGS (Geology and Ecology of National Parks). Public domain. Cropped; one version grayscaled and darkened
Photo: the stone “Karen.” USGS (Geology and Ecology of National Parks, published 2003). Public domain. Cropped
Photo: the lake bed on December 20, 2013. Norris R.D. et al. (2014) PLOS ONE 9(8): e105948, Fig 2. CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/.... Cropped to the upper photo
Sharp and Carey's (1976) figures are not used; their records are redrawn in original diagrams
Narration is synthetic speech by Google Gemini TTS (Orus). BGM was also generated with AI (ElevenLabs). Sound effects made in-house
3D, animation and diagrams are original. Still images of places and scenes were made with generative AI. No faces of real people were generated (backs, hands and silhouettes only)
Part of the series “Unraveling - Until Humanity Grasped the Truth” (Japanese narration).
Top 10 solved mysteries, ranked by how long they took: 解明された謎ランキングTOP10。1位は、解けるまで約2,200年かかった
The Tunguska explosion that left no crater: ツングースカ大爆発は、クレーターを一つも残さなかった。【1908年 シベリア、倒れた...
ほかの謎も、よければどうぞ。
・クレーターを一つも残さなかった大爆発(ツングースカ) https://youtu.be/P3lsGuc6orA
・氷河期は、10万年ごとにくり返し来ている https://youtu.be/Lb5EhqkOQnA
・炭になった2000年前の巻物を、開かずに読む https://youtu.be/lblihm3lGSE