台灣從未獨立過？｜#黃澎孝 #矢板明夫 #汪浩｜@華視三國演議｜20260823
華視新聞 CH52
38,204 views
Is Taiwan truly a country? Kuomintang (KMT) Chairperson Cheng Li-wen stated, "Taiwan has never been independent, and Taiwan has never been a country." Is this statement historically valid? Did Taiwan ever have a political entity with state-like characteristics during Zheng Chenggong's regime's "Dongning" in 1661? Can "Dongning" be considered a country in Taiwanese history?
Was the "Republic of Formosa," established on May 25, 1895, a true country? What elements of a modern nation-state did it possess? Hu Shih, in his autobiography, mentions that his father, Hu Chuan, was responsible for the defense of the rear mountains after the establishment of the Republic of Formosa, even calling Hu Chuan "the first victim of the first democracy in East Asia." What is the significance of this historical material for understanding Taiwan in 1895? After the establishment of the Republic of Formosa, the Sino-Japanese War broke out, with Taiwanese resistance against Japan lasting for several months. Should this war be called the "War of Resistance against Japan," local armed resistance, or a war for Taiwanese independence? Some argue that "Taiwan has never been independent" because it has historically been ruled by the Netherlands, Spain, the Zheng regime, the Qing Dynasty, Japan, and the Republic of China. But are "having been ruled by other regimes" and "Taiwan never forming a country" the same thing? From the perspective of international law and state structure, Taiwan today has its own government, people, territory, and the power to operate externally. So, is Taiwan a "de facto country"? If we separate "historical country," "de facto country," and "internationally recognized country," how should we answer the question "Is Taiwan a country?" today? What is the biggest problem with Cheng Li-wen's statement? For a fascinating interview, stay tuned to @CTSThreeKingdomsDiscussion!
Guests: #HuangPengxiao #YaitaAkio
Host: #WangHao
The above opinions do not represent the station's stance.
#ChengLiwen #Independence #Taiwan #China
TV Broadcast Schedule
📺CTS Main Channel 12
Premiere: Monday & Tuesday 06:00
📡CTS News Channel 52
Premiere: Saturday & Sunday 15:00
📱YouTube Three Kingdoms Discussion Channel
Premiere: Saturday & Sunday 15:00
Please tune in to @CTSThreeKingdomsDiscussion
Dedicated YouTube Channel: https://pse.is/cts3scompany_YT
Fan Page: Facebook: cts3scompany
APPLE Podcast: https://pse.is/3Talks_AP
Google Podcast: https://pse.is/3Talks_GP
20 Comments
1：效仿🇮🇱不遺餘力遊說引入美國政府，美軍的介入，全面倒向美國，必要時可全民公投加入成為美國第五十一州或者 海外領地（這一點其實不用擔心，未來想獨立自主 仍然可以全民公投脫離美國即可）；
2：由於修昔底德陷阱，因而中美必有一戰， 有可能像美蘇一樣的冷戰，也可能是熱戰；一切想脫離中共控制的勢力（臺灣，香港，澳門，新疆，西藏，其他各個省）可以成為美國的內應，幫助美國勝利；
3：美國徹底擊敗中共之後；臺灣 ，香港，澳門，新疆，西藏等一切民主勢力即可 收復大陸淪陷區，在美國的幫助下 徹底改造大陸，各民主勢力可以選擇建立民主聯邦新新中國，也可自由選擇獨立或者 直接加入美國；
台灣從未獨立過？｜#黃澎孝 #矢板明夫 #汪浩｜@華視三國演議｜20260823
華視新聞 CH52
38,204 views
Is Taiwan truly a country? Kuomintang (KMT) Chairperson Cheng Li-wen stated, "Taiwan has never been independent, and Taiwan has never been a country." Is this statement historically valid? Did Taiwan ever have a political entity with state-like characteristics during Zheng Chenggong's regime's "Dongning" in 1661? Can "Dongning" be considered a country in Taiwanese history?
Was the "Republic of Formosa," established on May 25, 1895, a true country? What elements of a modern nation-state did it possess? Hu Shih, in his autobiography, mentions that his father, Hu Chuan, was responsible for the defense of the rear mountains after the establishment of the Republic of Formosa, even calling Hu Chuan "the first victim of the first democracy in East Asia." What is the significance of this historical material for understanding Taiwan in 1895? After the establishment of the Republic of Formosa, the Sino-Japanese War broke out, with Taiwanese resistance against Japan lasting for several months. Should this war be called the "War of Resistance against Japan," local armed resistance, or a war for Taiwanese independence? Some argue that "Taiwan has never been independent" because it has historically been ruled by the Netherlands, Spain, the Zheng regime, the Qing Dynasty, Japan, and the Republic of China. But are "having been ruled by other regimes" and "Taiwan never forming a country" the same thing? From the perspective of international law and state structure, Taiwan today has its own government, people, territory, and the power to operate externally. So, is Taiwan a "de facto country"? If we separate "historical country," "de facto country," and "internationally recognized country," how should we answer the question "Is Taiwan a country?" today? What is the biggest problem with Cheng Li-wen's statement? For a fascinating interview, stay tuned to @CTSThreeKingdomsDiscussion!
Guests: #HuangPengxiao #YaitaAkio
Host: #WangHao
The above opinions do not represent the station's stance.
#ChengLiwen #Independence #Taiwan #China
TV Broadcast Schedule
📺CTS Main Channel 12
Premiere: Monday & Tuesday 06:00
📡CTS News Channel 52
Premiere: Saturday & Sunday 15:00
📱YouTube Three Kingdoms Discussion Channel
Premiere: Saturday & Sunday 15:00
Please tune in to @CTSThreeKingdomsDiscussion
Dedicated YouTube Channel: https://pse.is/cts3scompany_YT
Fan Page: Facebook: cts3scompany
APPLE Podcast: https://pse.is/3Talks_AP
Google Podcast: https://pse.is/3Talks_GP