Based on the comments I’d say Freddie and the UnHerd audience are at diametrically opposite ends of this “debate”.

Camus observed that replacement was happening, and wrote about it. It was not a theory. It was an observation. How can Mr. Sayers not know this?

Going into any European city, especially larger cities, would leave NO doubt that this man is correct. I always ask myself why politicians are ignoring such an obvious issue. Sadly, Here is your answer. They simply worked against their citizens ' well-being.

Funny how Camus is expected to take responsibility for fpur shootings, but the purveyors of other ideologies aren't held to the same standard.

Freddie is not being entirely honest. We don’t have to accept that previous decolonisation was ethical or even mass movements of Greeks/Turks and Germans/Poles or even movements within India. However, the suggestion that recent mass movement in Europe or America are normal and trivial is clearly false. The suggestion that previous decolonisation was ethical but discussing decolonisation in Europe is unethical has not been clearly argued.

Stop worrying about foreign young men who are more than capable of looking after themselves and start worrying about British women and children.

Suggestion for an episode of Unherd. Freddie goes walkabout around majority immigrant UK cities being shown the impact of mass migration.

Luckily Freddie is young enough that he will probably be alive to see the endgame in Europe. Perhaps then he will see the downside of wholesale population replacement...

I’m confused.   Is Freddy for open unlimited immigration and ok with Islam dominance of the UK in two generations because of the Normans?   Or is his  nuance strictly regarding deportation ?

Freddie, no one was telling the Franks or the Anglo Saxons that it was ‘racist’ to object to invasion by the Normans.

Why is giving native Britons of the UK demographic & cultural security so offensive to all these people?
& why do they feel so entitled to deny people that when they clearly haven't the right?

These non proposed, demographic & cultural policies of increasingly marginalising & minoritising Native Britons, that were never openly proposed or voted for, but in fact voted against have been a disaster & need to be stopped & reversed.

School student body demographic reporting have the children of English families becoming a minority in the English school system in around 10 years.
By the trends of the official voluntarily provided census figures, along with official immigration ones since, the English nation will be a minority in their homeland in a mere few decades & all Britons (in the Isles not just the UK) will be some short years after that, & who knows what the reality on the ground means for how much sooner crossing each of these demographic thresholds will occur.

Still no mention of this on tv, or most of the supposedly independent & dissident online media, the omerta remains unbroken & the slow walk ethnic cleansing into dissolution continues.

We want, have appealed for & are entitled to demographic & cultural security in our homeland from our institutions who are denying us it.

It IS an existential issue & we are rapidly approaching a point when self defence calculus applies.

The invasion of the  “Sea Peoples” brought about the Bronze Age Collapse. Nobody in those days was concerned about the getting the correct noun for the invasion as the most important thing!

There is no comparison for the scale, speed and foreign-ness of the migration we in the West are experiencing. You have to go back to late Rome for anything comparable and guess what? That was a highly unstable and chaotic time. You can't compare the Norman invasion or a Hanoverian king to what's happening in Britain right now.

Only when Freddies hometown is completely unrecognisable will he realise what is being lost.

Freddie, come to Manchester and tell me we are not being colonised.

Many of the people tell you that they are actually doing just that.

Fred, you can not hide your arrogance, and attempt to hide it by saying that you don’t understand.

It isn't a conspiracy theory. It's happening plebs.

Freddie Sayers at his most thick-headed and obnoxious. The condescension is revolting.
And then there's the editing, which is obtrusive and so clearly intended to cut Camus off so Freddie could come up with another one of his inane objections.
The post by @cynthiamartini8982 says it all: "How strange to pretend not to know what your guest is talking about."

As an American who has a much more established history of being the world’s melting pot with the Statue of Liberty as a symbol given to us by France - I still very much understand and agree with what the guest is saying and what the host is seemingly trying hard NOT to understand.   What he is saying is a truth - that there are powers that be - way above any one so-called elected nation that have helped orchestrate the mass migration of ethnic peoples across the globe from the Middle East and Africa via the strategic infliction of war and violence as regeme change with the express but unadmitted goal of deliberately homogenizing the global population- ending nationalism and national distinctiveness.  

This is plainly opinions and yet so many people are seemingly willfully blind to it.  

This man is suggesting that people groups ought not to be displaced and they ought to remain where they were - in general.  

Individuals who have skills and want some limited opportunities who are in need in a country could be allowed a visa to work and perhaps emigrate and become naturalized citizens - but only if the host country needs and wants them.   French masons to build the English cathedrals, Chineese laborers to build the American railroads, whatever.  

The point is the native population has new invaded by a wave of people who were deliberately displaced.    Itgebprovkems of their homelands should not have been caused and should be remedied and not have them become human pawns and wrecking balls to satisfy the goals of globalists and then be used to serve as argument points between well meaning country men and women who simply don’t want to see their heritage and national identities shifted so much and so dramatically.  

That is all he is saying and he is correct.  

Hungary was one of the few sane nations that refused to accept immigrants in this recent flow of human population.   They are not having this argument today and are not suffering the violence and defeating of their home country that most of the poor other European nations are suffering.

By far the worst interview I've ever seen Feddie handle. He pre judged, defamed, attacted, editorialised, and proclaimed his own very standard views bias. Didn't listen to the guest and used the whole spectical to denouce reality while being rude and dismissive. Reminded me of a channel 4 take down. 0 out of 10. The guest used the word colonisation correctly, the "linguistic trick" is in fact to call it immigration. I speak as someone born in the UK from immigrant parents and even I can see this.

I went to school here, I was insulated from my origin cultures to a large extent, which, btw, is no longewr at all the case for those who arriveved since smart phones became a thing. Therefore, I am not Echnically British but I am also not even 100% culturally british, thought everyone would think I was including British people. In a sense, judging by this interview at least, I'm more in tune with Britain & reality than Freddie here is though.