Since there's so many multiplayer games, I was thinking of doing it as a separate vid if people like it enough :0

In the reading material, it's made clear that the band in Sweeper Star isn't even on a real beam, it's essentially CGI. So even a fear of heights wouldn't make it harder. Also, I imagine A for Effort is just like... a kindergarten spelling bee

Wdym you’re not wearing a dog fursuit and jumping yourself on the 7th beat to catch the disk?

2:56 counterpoint! While bubbles or balls ow whatever don’t take much force to pop, the perfect comic reveals that the balls are extremely hot, hot enough to cause pretty painful blisters. I’d rank that game much higher in that case since it’s very hard for a human to pop scorching hot balls consistently

Not gonna mention the lasers in Yum Bot? I'm not sure you could install a laser powerful enough to instantly vaporize the flans in a robot, and if you could it would be a lot bulkier.

Ok, i have A LOT to disagree with.
I think high-five fever should be in easy, as the triple clap would be pretty tricky and it would get a bit exhausting. I would know, i've done it myself.
Soda hop might just be jump roping, but it has to be done to the beat, so i'd say easy because that adds a bit more challenge.
There's zero way disc dog is possible, the disc flies in the air FOR. EIGHT. SECONDS. No human could make a disc fly for that long.
Reminder for hoop trundling: THE HOOP MOVES. Backup spotlight is another minigame that could get a bit exhausting with all of the movements, and soccer dreams is just NOT POSSIBLE. The girl stays in the air for like almost a second before kicking, that's literally not possible.
Slice N Dice Kitchen would be at least hard, because you need to both CATCH veggies and slice them up, which would require very good multitasking.
I would also move quick hands into very easy, as catching the sticks is not hard, and i actually think the bigger issue is that they sometimes make you catch shovels & pickaxes. Those can be a little heavy...
Finally, i'd say A for Effort is VERY easy.
You just need someone with a keyboard and ability to speak, a group of other people to say the A, and stock images. Very easy!

I think you should add a "Depends" tier

Now this is the one I’ve been waiting for!!! CHO PAW 🌂☂️

If we're factoring in sequels alongside their prequels as proven by Soccer Dreams, then we presume the really fast section in Hop N Slide is by design. This'd probably bump it up by at least one tier, as although the base speed seems to be something like a speedwalk the fast section is full sprint.
Actually, Factoring in sequels at the same time changes quite a few rankings I think.

For Hoop Trundling, how are humans going to turn into bubbles? Even if we assume they just have to be suspended midair... How do we do that? If done with wires it'd knock over the hoop.

For Brolly Good Show, it doesn't change that much but the audience would have to know when to say "Allez!"

Unrelated to sequels, but for Disc Dog the human would have to throw the frisbee in the exact same way every time, like 25 times at least (I will not bother to actually count.) That is not happening

For Pop, Don't Drop, the hard bubbles have to at least be difficult to pop. Enough so that, as seen in the Perfect Comic, it can injure your fingers. I'd say that bumps it up a tier

For Can Do, just look at the animation bruh that hammer is HEAVY.

For Soda Hop, assuming it's to scale like you did with Wiper Bosses, You'd have to have some sort of giant jumprope machine. Given, that's probably not THAT hard to make, but that also makes it harder than just jump roping. Plus the sequel has you going pretty fast, for the average person it'd probably be at least difficult.

For High Five Fever, the "Here we GO!" triple high-five maneuver definitely makes it at least a little harder.

For Space Sentry, the statue is not "throwing rocks" to destroy the meteors, it's MATERIALIZING BOOMERANGS OUT OF YELLOW ENERGY. This is some sort of magic, and definitely impossible.

Slice n dice kitchen is impossible cause you need a partner😢 (look at the superb ranking screen)

I would put A For Effort in Really Easy, the way I see, it's a screen video game type thing where you just press a button to put the As at the ends of the words, so in a way, the same reasoning for Hop N Slide (the only time ever you can compare A For Effort and Hop N Slide), this was even the reasoning I went with for my personal "How Dangerous Would It Be To Do The Rhythm Heaven Minigames" tier list when I recently updated it for Groove

The guys in Hoop Trundling are called  Trundlorbs

I think people are underestimating how hard it would be to catch spinning sticks consistently without fumbling

Feeding the Beast is impossible because dinosaurs are dead

idk about quick hands...catching the sticks would be easy but trying to catch fast spinning hammers, shovels and pickaxes flying towards you without getting hurt is a lot harder then it sounds. Especially if you are only allowed to catch them by the handle. I think it more so belongs in the possible or hard category.

i am baffled you didnt question the logistics of backup dancer


its extremely complicated and hard dance to do with 4 people without injuring someone with their elbow😭. the synchronicity of such an act is pretty damn hard

its just funny how they made the dancing like the most challenging dance to pull off irl ^^"

According to Grok (lol) A CO2 laser is powerful enough to cut a flan , though no one has attempted to explode a falling flan with lasers. So perhaps its possible?

I thought sweeper stars takes place on a set with a grey screen and the skyscraper background was just added for effects

I think you should add a “theoretically possible” tier for games that are theoretically possible like in fever Karate man would go to that tier because it could happen but it can’t happen in real life


Also A for effort would be possible to do in real life because it’s just a screen shown in the sequel which you could do A hop n slide tech and program the whole game onto a screen to do in real life

My opinions on the things that weren't ranked:
Rhythm Toybox:
Bouncy Pufferfish: possible, but very mean. You will have animal control called on you, you will more than likely get hurt, and you will have to live with the knowledge that you killed a pufferfish.
Who's got rhythm: doable with humans no question, but not with rabbits.
All 3 soundboards are literally just soundboards. Crazy easy.
Swing: Okay feasibly you could yeet your shoe at the height of a swing's orbit, but sending it 5 miles out? No, you ain't doing that.
Owls: Owls cannot shrink on command. Empossible.

Score Attack:
Can you clap it: I mean it'd be crazy boring to watch and probably crazy boring to be a part of, but you could do it. Much less likely that you'd be playing against a demon like the minigame itself though.
Sensei Sparring: Crazy hard, you'd need martial arts knowledge, but you could do it.
Skateboarding: Obviously the sport itself is doable, save for the aliens. A normal human could pop an olly over eggs or cookies no question.
Firing Frenzy: If it's a video game, crazy easy. If it's a real life pew pew space battle? Empossible.
Multiplayer:
Rhythm Tweezers: I mean if onions grew hair I guess you could do it.
Pet & Parcel: same  for firing frenzy. Ain't no way.
Ninja Bodyguards: No, not happening. It's just not.
Archer Angels: This is a video game. Very easy.
Tennis Quest: empossible. Killing anything with a tennis ball is a no go, but doing it in a group with precise rhythm is just out of the question entirely.
Volley Ballish: Possible, but very hard. The Harlem Globetrotters have done weirder.
Wrestle Sprint: If it's staged like WWE, very doable. If this is wrestlers dodging lasers and lightning, not so much. I'm enclined to believe however that it's staged, as the game's reference material features Heel Turner explaining to his son that he's playing a character.
Cake Wait: Genuinely might be the easiest thing in the game. Just about anyone can count to ten.
Memo-rising: Three year olds play this game. Not with rhythm, but basic matching games for sure. You could probably play it on a mole hill if you really wanted to be authentic.
Sick Beats: While things would've been so much easier if we could stab viruses with a tiny fork, we unfortunately cannot. Empossible.
Group Toybox:
Knock Knock Quartet: Doable if it's just four dudes with a xylophone, but if you're going  for authenticity, you're also going for a concussion.
Rock Smashers: Crazy empossible. Four people in one room could not carve rocks flying at them in unison.
Building Blocks: It's reverse Jenga. If you're good at Jenga, you could probably play this too.
Mine Cart: Empossible. I highly doubt mines are spacious enough to let you zoom around on a mine cart, though the twisty paths and constant fear of death would be accurate.
Rocket Sibs: If it's actual rockets, that's probably gonna be several airspace violations, but people shoot off fireworks in rhythm all the time, so you can take it either way.
Drum Lessons: You're pretty chill until otherworldly skill, at which point you'd best be crazy skilled indeed.