OpenTube

The Emperor Built Lorgar to DESTROY Chaos (And It Doomed the Imperium) | Warhammer 40K Lore

Ordo Illuminati

11,588 views

What if the Word Bearers were never meant to fall? What if Lorgar Aurelian
was not the Emperor's greatest failure — but His most carefully engineered
weapon against Chaos itself?

The orthodox account is clean. Lorgar worshipped the Emperor as a god. The
Emperor punished him. Kor Phaeron and Erebus corrupted a pious but deluded
Primarch. The XVIIth Legion fell. The Horus Heresy followed.

That account does not explain the scale of what happened at Monarchia. A being
who planned across millennia does not respond to a theological dispute with a
personal appearance, the deliberate destruction of the finest city the Word
Bearers had ever built, and the public humiliation of a Primarch before his
entire Legion. That is not a disappointed father's rebuke. That is a containment
protocol failing in real time.

The Ordo Illuminati's position: Lorgar's gifts — what this treatise designates
sovereign resonance — were designed to make the Word Bearers metaphysically
impervious to Chaos corruption. His soul-level attunement was the mechanism by
which his Legion's loyalty would be anchored below the reach of daemonic
whispers. The Emperor's prohibition on religion was the recognition that any
faith structure, including Emperor-worship, could be suborned by the Chaos Gods
to redirect that same loyalty.

The Burning of Monarchia was a containment operation. It failed. And when it
failed, the anti-daemon weapon became the vector — a Legion-wide soul-event that
produced the most committed Chaos worshippers in the Heresy before any other
traitor Legion had fully committed.

This is the Sovereign Paradox.

Topics covered in this video:
— The nature of Lorgar's sovereign resonance and how it differed from any other
Primarch's psychic gift
— Why the Emperor's prohibition on religion was a strategic weapon, not wounded pride
— Why Emperor-worship specifically threatened to create a fifth Ruinous Power
— The Burning of Monarchia reread as a psychic containment protocol
— Why the Emperor chose Guilliman to carry out the destruction
— Kor Phaeron and Erebus as accelerants, not architects
— Argel Tal and the Gal Vorbak as evidence the mechanism was literal
— The suppressed pre-Heresy records and what their absence reveals
— Lorgar on Sicarus and the broadcast that still runs

#Warhammer40K #WordBearers #HorusHeresy #Lorgar #40KLore #WH40K #Primarch
#ChaosSpaceMarines #WH40KLore #OrdoIlluminati

20 Comments

@blankeon6613 1 month ago

This is why Lorgar is the Emperor's biggest mistake.
The Emperor wanted the Word Bearers to spread his Imperial Truth ideology, but he was unwilling to explain his understanding of the ideology to Lorgar. He just forced him to spread it and was unwilling to tell him about the Warp and it's dangers.

@jamesgordley5000 1 month ago

This “sovereign resonance”, implanted to instill a resistance to Chaos, may still be doing that very same job and thereby allowing Word Bearers to worship those powers without being consumed.

Any other legion so deeply devoted to Chaos may have mutated into spawn or become fully possessed (not as partnership like Argel Tal, but as puppets like Fulgrim), which Lorgar himself abhors.

In following the specific doctrine of “man above demons” (a unique teaching among Chaos cults) the legion may actually be preserving the exercise of this resonance. This makes Lorgar himself more than a high priest, being also a living lifeline by which the congregation can safely approach the gods.

@AlexanderForsman 1 month ago (edited)

Lorgar is the Leto II to the Emperor's Paul.

Because Lorgar truly understand their universe

@Noreb 1 month ago

"bunch of emperor botherers" - caiphus cain.

@0nan-Son-of-Juda-Brother-of-Er 1 month ago

Lorgar was essentially the Soul Stone of the infinity Gauntlet or the Power of Heart in Captain Planet

@fixedG 1 month ago (edited)

Before the Heresy, if he needed zealous crusaders against heretical outsiders not made in the image of the Emperor's grand plan, Lorgar and his boys should have been the Emperor's first port of call. Faith is a powerful thing. A lot of time and thought is given to Primarchs who have characteristics that make them opposite sides of the same coin, or redundant in some way. Sometimes one went to chaos and one stayed loyal. I don't think Lorgar and Leman Russ are often considered in that way but maybe they should be. Leman Russ represents obedience of a loyal kind. Lorgar represents obedience of a faithful kind. And Lorgar's predilection for holding and inspiring faith doesn't mean that's limited to religious faith. Replace Lorgar's faith in the divine with faith in mankind and he's the greatest anti-chaos crusader imaginable. Sanguinius was inspirational for soldiers to believe in something greater. Lorgar could have been a beacon of inspirational belief in themselves.

@krob5375 1 month ago

Pretty much everything that went wrong with the Primarchs could have been avoided had the Emperor just been transparent and forthright with them about everything. Well except Angron, he was probably screwed either way. But by withholding info about the warp, the webway and everything about Chaos in general, he left too much to chance. And specifically for Lorgar, had he made a more obvious distinction between faith and loyalty, he may have stayed true. All this is to say, the Emperor for all his gifts, still made critical mistakes, because he's human at his core.

@jeffFromthecoolguysisland 1 month ago (edited)

There really only is one single event that changes the entirety of the story/big e’s plan, that being Magnus and his hubris to think that his father couldn’t deal with Horus at any point in time

@benjohnson1986 1 month ago

I appreciate the fact that you're using your actual voice for this. You got me 👍

@TAInsiderTony 1 month ago

Great video, the Aurelian would be proud!

@AnotherWombat8888 1 month ago

the problem with the entire concept of Chaos and the Emperor's plans is that everything creates that energy. Everyone is guilty, no one can escape. That creates bigger questions about the future of mankind and what the answer to Chaos is.

@fixedG 1 month ago

I have a suggestion: The Dauntless Few conspired to spark the Heresy. Guilleman really wanted his own Empire. Dorn humiliated Perturabo on purpose, goading him to the point that he'd be ready to join Horus when prompted. Leman Russ intentionally misinterpreted the order to arrest Magnus, sowing seeds of distrust and marginalizing one of the 3 most powerful Psykers in the entire Imperium and created a rift between Magnus and the Emperor which eventually resulted in the War in the Webway, taking the Emperor off of the battlefield at the most crucial moment. Sanguinius sowed the seeds of jealousy and betrayal as early as when he spent years with Horus and Abaddon before even being reunited with his own legion. He showed the Luna Wolves and Horus up by pledging himself to his legion and taking control, sparking in Horus a higher sense of competition and pride for his own legion instead of for all of humanity. It wasn't a perfect conspiracy without cost. Manus died. They thought they could sit the remainder of the war out, or at least establish a new base to build from after they founded Imperium Secundus but they were drawn back into the fray. The chaos they prompted grew out of their control. Guilleman was injured, his hubris almost broken, but now he's resurrected. Sanguinius wasn't supposed to die as part of the charade, but Horus was never in on the conspiracy that made him a traitor, and he had a role to play after they couldn't hide in Imperium Secundus anymore. Guilleman betrayed Dorn with the Codex Astartes and the breakup of the Legions to Chapters, costing Dorn his control, at least politically. There's a secretly heretical spin to both Dorn and Russ disappearing and what Ferrus Manus got up to as well, I'm sure.

@MegaKlc123 1 month ago

Ya sick? Why ya whispering at me? 😂

@paladin765 1 month ago

My favorite Primarch, favorite legion.
Now imagine if they rejected chaos and served Nagash?
even the gods can die...

@Reddotzebra 1 month ago

Human souls are warp-connected, even if they are not psykers. What the Emperor did with Lorgar almost sounds similar to the Orks, not entirely, but still something more like a closed-loop system that needs filling from time to time.
Lorgar basically working as an anchor for all the souls around him, shielding from the warp by feeding all the power they need to survive and function through himself.

@Groeningathletics 1 month ago

Could have been one of his best tools had he not screwed up so badly 🤷‍♂️

@PreposterousJellyfish 1 month ago

Still at the beginning so don't know yet if you mention it, but if word bearers are essentially soul bound to lorgar, how are erebus' ambitions for power able to prevail and lead him to essentially manipulate his gene sire

@RepublicofGilead-br4uv 1 month ago

:: comes running for new content ::

@thatotherguy8138 1 month ago

I had this kind of thought as well - Lorgar was created as a conductor for Worship. If the Emperor had simply taking Lorgar aside and said "Look, there are these four major beings who APPEAR to be Gods, and who gain strength by stealing the worship of Mortals - we need to find a way to starve them of that worship."... Lorgar might have been the most potent anti-Chaos being in all of the Universe.

Alas, Warhammer as a setting cannot exist unless the smartest and most powerful beings, at the time they have the power to alter the universe (both on the large and small scale)... make the SECOND worst decision they could possibly make. The WORST decision destroys the Setting. The second worst decision allows the setting to continue, in a lesser form. This isn't simply for the Emperor, but for all powerful beings - the Eldar, the Krorks, the Old Ones, the DAoT Humans, the Emperor, the Primarchs, right down to normal inquisitors or even just normal people. When given the chance to make the universe Better or Worse, the setting requires that they make the setting Worse. So the Emperor couldn't tell Lorgar what was going on, couldn't bring him on board, had to treat him as if he was no different than Angron or Dorn or Fulgrim, that they were all the same just wearing different coloured armour.

@BongBong6983-x3d 1 month ago

Actually Guilliman didn't feel nothing when he destroyed Lorgar's planet. Infact he was felt the Emperor had gone too far for ordering him to do it. He can't do nothing but to obey as all the other Primarchs would even Lorgar too if the table were turned.