For 0:22 I definitely should’ve clarified that I was making an assumption. I’ve got a lot of heat for that, and it’s completely justified. Just want to let anyone watching know that this has never been outright confirmed. Pretty bad to have my biggest mistake in the video be right at the start. Sorry!

Obviously the knight is Noelle's secret cousin, Rory Nyte.

Obviously the knight is heats flamesman.  That's why Toby wanted us to remember the name.

guys the knight is totally jockington, kris confirmed it in ch4

Meanwhile Tobey is laughing his @ss of knowing he is going to make the knight burgerpants

imagine the roaring knight is literally just the roaring knight and nobody else

The knight is clearly star
                                            walker.

2:54 I love how burghley was only a couple seconds away from summoning a fucking titan here LMAO

If the Knight turns out to NOT be Dess then all the Dessriel fanart will age incredibly poorly

8:32 the idea of the knight, whoever they are, hiding in closets after or before making dark fountains is TERRIFYING ngl

Rudy is the knight, and, asgore is opening fountains, and carol has the codes, they’re all working together

Its Tricky Tonys insane brother, Terrifying Tobias

let’s be fair the possibility of accidentally killing one child asgore is much less flawed then the asgore who intentionally killed 6 kids

27:13 it should also be noted that every fuckin computer in the game has a left-handed setup... Kris's and Noelle's are the same way

24:47 carol is DEFINITELY strong enough. We know that the dogs got locked up again because at night they tried to break into the holiday residence and got absolutely solo'd by carol so bad that they locked themselves up in jail. People also say that with carol as the mayor, people are too intimidated to commit crime. The fact that even with undyne as police chief people still fear carol more seems to allude to the fact that shes at least stronger than undyne in the light and dark world and maybe stronger than asgore

34:57 another con for dess is that, if she were trapped in the dark world, how come she just leaves it at the end of chapter 3? What’s her motivation for being the knight? If dess is the knight she HAS to be under the control of someone else, similar to kris, otherwise it just makes no sense

Also, I dont like "its too obvious" bejng used against Dess Knight because it implies that its more important for a twist to shock the player than to actually be well written.

20:37 Rudy could absolutely (if he is the knight) be playing along because he knows that we, the player, can hear him

i like how you actually presented all the issues/inconsistencies with every candidate instead of just ignoring the problems with the one you think is true.
a lot of these videos don’t really address how complicated and ambiguous the story really is at this point

13:37 another con for papyrus is he and sans only recently moved to hometown and couldn't of known or have any sort of connection to Gerson who died a while ago to create the special type of darkness needed to make the old man