カツの悪行をまとめてみた＆カツの正体は“おまえら”！？（セリフと演出から読み解く機動戦士ガンダム解説・Z第2回）
セリフと演出から読み解く機動戦士ガンダム解説
142,869 views
In this video, I'll explain Mobile Suit Gundam using dialogue and direction as clues. I'm open to misinterpretations and misinterpretations, so please let me know in the comments if you have any alternative interpretations or point out any errors. My goal is to create videos that convey the fun of Gundam to first-time viewers while also allowing fellow Gundam enthusiasts to have lively discussions. Updated every Monday and Friday!
=====================================================
A Summary of Katsu's Misdeeds & Is Katsu's True Identity "You Guys"?! (Mobile Suit Gundam: Z: Part 2: Deciphering Dialogue and Direction)
Table of Contents
01:27 Point 1. Looking Back at Katsu in the First Season
02:28 Point 2. A Summary of Katsu's Misdeeds in Z
07:28 Point 3. Proof of the "second Amuro" contained in Katsu
09:45 Point 4. Katsu as a symbol of the unfortunate "you guys" who want to be like Amuro but can't
11:53 Point 5. The meaning of "a mobile suit hidden underground"
16:11 Point 6. Katsu's punishment
18:51 Summary This is what it's like to be 15 years old
#MobileSuitGundam #Gundam #YoshiyukiTomino #VOICEVOXCommentary #YukkuriCommentary #ShikokuMetan #Zundamon
============ ============ =========== =========== ==========
Starring: Zundamon, ShikokuMetan, Ryusei Aoyama (portrait: Ahiru Sakamoto)
Video: Yukkuri Movie Maker 4
Music: Noru "Sunny Side Up", Ryo Lion "Woodgrain Line", Keido Honda "Napping around the Fireplace", Nico Nico Commons, DOVA-SYNDROME, YouTube Audio Library
Font: Yasashisa Gothic, Noto Serif JP Black
Reference Materials:
Novel versions of "Mobile Suit Gundam," "Mobile Suit Z Gundam," "Gundam Records Complete Collection 1-5," and "Complete Script Records" (Sunrise Japan), "Gundam Archive" (MediaWorks), Roman Album Extra "Mobile Suit Gundam" (Tokuma Shoten), "Mobile Suit Gundam Encyclopedia: One Year War Arc Reprint Edition," "Tomino's Quotations," "Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam Encyclopedia" (Laporte Deluxe), Yoshiyuki Tomino's "Principles of Visuals," "The World of Yoshiyuki Tomino," "The Complete Works of Yoshiyuki Tomino," "From the Gundam Studio: A Collection of Yoshiyuki Tomino's Quotes" (Kinema Junpo), "That's Why I Am...," "The Healing of Turn A," "Newtype 100% Collection Z Gundam 1-3" (Kadokawa), Tsunehiro Uno's "Motherhood's Dystopia" (Shueisha), "Data Collection Mobile Suit Z Gundam" "Gundam Gundam: The Movie Volumes 1 and 2" (Dengeki Comics), "Let's Talk Z Gundam!" (Rekka Publishing), various back issues of Newtype, Animage, and Animec, and more.
@mechabu
アニメロボットコクピット の歴史！
=====================================================
Mobile Suit Gundam: An Interpretation of Dialogue and Direction - Official Website
https://sites.google.com/view/gundam-...
Sign up for membership here!
@limo_hrih
20 Comments
周りと衝突して凹まされながら大人になってくんだけど、大人になる前に死んでしまった。
そうした少年キャラは視聴者たる同年代少年からはよく思われない、というのがありました。
主人公が悲劇的な運命とか苛烈な特訓で主人公の地位を得たのに、知人少年は「知人」というだけでその輪に入ってしまう。
そこに向けられる感情って「羨ましい」「俺ならもっとうまくやる」だけでなく「神の視点で主人公の背景を知っているからこそのもどかしさ」もあったかと。
カツへの感情って「アムロの苦労も知らないで、浮かれて好き勝手やってんなよ」みたいな反発だったんじゃないのかな？
ただ、年取ってZ見ると、軍隊経験もないガキを訓練もなしに前線送りにするエゥーゴの方が気になって、カツヘイトはやや減退しましたね（ないとは言ってない）
というかカツはゼータだけでは無くあらゆるロボット物に影響を受けた子供に刺さるキャラクターなのかもしれません、思ったより深いキャラだなぁと思いました
やはり、どうしても「カツじゃなくても、いいじゃん、他に新キャラ出して、そいつにやらせればいいじゃん、カツを残念なヤツに落とさないでくれよぉぉぉ」
って思ってしまうのですよ・・・・。
一方、何かと依存傾向がみられるカミーユと比べると、曲りなりに健全さが見える辺り、ハヤトとフラウは若いなりに誠実さを持って子育てをしてきたんだろうなと。
実際、上官であるエマの対応も、カミーユとカツとでは明らかに違っていましたし、サラへの恋心も、戦場そして敵でなければ年相応の青さを帯びた健全なモノだった訳で。
そしていわば「アムロへの憧れが転じて増長してしまった子供」という意味で共通しながら、「想い人を自分の手で殺してしまった衝撃から間もなく自分も逝け、曲がりなりにも死後すぐに通じ合えたカツ」と、「想い人の死が（間違いなく自分を守ろうとしてくれた）他者によるもので、脊髄反射的な憎悪でその相手を殺害してしまったことで、想い人による心の傷と裁かれなかった殺人への罪悪感から二重の苦しみを受けることになり鬱になりながらも生き続けてるハサウェイ（劇場版閃ハサ）」は、ある意味真逆の地獄を味わってるんですね…
ちなみにカツ叩き正義論の人が多いのには、アンソロジー作家吉田創氏の影響もでかいと思う（当人はあくまで本気で漫画のネタとして描いているため、ガチに染まる人の多さにドン引きしたそうですが）
だから自分を観ている様な気がして嫌いだったんだろうなぁ
今ではカツの言動、行動ともに、あの年頃ならそうだよねって深くわかります！
カツの悪行をまとめてみた＆カツの正体は“おまえら”！？（セリフと演出から読み解く機動戦士ガンダム解説・Z第2回）
セリフと演出から読み解く機動戦士ガンダム解説
142,869 views
In this video, I'll explain Mobile Suit Gundam using dialogue and direction as clues. I'm open to misinterpretations and misinterpretations, so please let me know in the comments if you have any alternative interpretations or point out any errors. My goal is to create videos that convey the fun of Gundam to first-time viewers while also allowing fellow Gundam enthusiasts to have lively discussions. Updated every Monday and Friday!
=====================================================
A Summary of Katsu's Misdeeds & Is Katsu's True Identity "You Guys"?! (Mobile Suit Gundam: Z: Part 2: Deciphering Dialogue and Direction)
Table of Contents
01:27 Point 1. Looking Back at Katsu in the First Season
02:28 Point 2. A Summary of Katsu's Misdeeds in Z
07:28 Point 3. Proof of the "second Amuro" contained in Katsu
09:45 Point 4. Katsu as a symbol of the unfortunate "you guys" who want to be like Amuro but can't
11:53 Point 5. The meaning of "a mobile suit hidden underground"
16:11 Point 6. Katsu's punishment
18:51 Summary This is what it's like to be 15 years old
#MobileSuitGundam #Gundam #YoshiyukiTomino #VOICEVOXCommentary #YukkuriCommentary #ShikokuMetan #Zundamon
============ ============ =========== =========== ==========
Starring: Zundamon, ShikokuMetan, Ryusei Aoyama (portrait: Ahiru Sakamoto)
Video: Yukkuri Movie Maker 4
Music: Noru "Sunny Side Up", Ryo Lion "Woodgrain Line", Keido Honda "Napping around the Fireplace", Nico Nico Commons, DOVA-SYNDROME, YouTube Audio Library
Font: Yasashisa Gothic, Noto Serif JP Black
Reference Materials:
Novel versions of "Mobile Suit Gundam," "Mobile Suit Z Gundam," "Gundam Records Complete Collection 1-5," and "Complete Script Records" (Sunrise Japan), "Gundam Archive" (MediaWorks), Roman Album Extra "Mobile Suit Gundam" (Tokuma Shoten), "Mobile Suit Gundam Encyclopedia: One Year War Arc Reprint Edition," "Tomino's Quotations," "Mobile Suit Zeta Gundam Encyclopedia" (Laporte Deluxe), Yoshiyuki Tomino's "Principles of Visuals," "The World of Yoshiyuki Tomino," "The Complete Works of Yoshiyuki Tomino," "From the Gundam Studio: A Collection of Yoshiyuki Tomino's Quotes" (Kinema Junpo), "That's Why I Am...," "The Healing of Turn A," "Newtype 100% Collection Z Gundam 1-3" (Kadokawa), Tsunehiro Uno's "Motherhood's Dystopia" (Shueisha), "Data Collection Mobile Suit Z Gundam" "Gundam Gundam: The Movie Volumes 1 and 2" (Dengeki Comics), "Let's Talk Z Gundam!" (Rekka Publishing), various back issues of Newtype, Animage, and Animec, and more.
@mechabu
アニメロボットコクピット の歴史！
=====================================================
Mobile Suit Gundam: An Interpretation of Dialogue and Direction - Official Website
https://sites.google.com/view/gundam-...
Sign up for membership here!
@limo_hrih
すみませんでした