Silahlı Okul Saldırılarının Sebebi Ne?
Evrim Ağacı
746,038 views
We lost some bright, young kids in the school shootings in Kahramanmaraş and Şanlıurfa. First and foremost, my deepest condolences go out to the families of the children who lost their lives. I wish I could say, "I hope we never see this kind of brutality again," but... we're scientists. We're science enthusiasts. We know that when certain conditions are met, the natural consequences of those conditions are inevitable. Given enough time, even highly improbable events become almost a certainty—they will happen over and over again. That's why today, I want to talk to you about the underlying conditions that pave the way for these kinds of massacres. Because right now, everyone on social media is throwing out a different theory: video games, TV series, toy guns, economic problems, ignorance, genetics, a lack of police in schools, gun ownership, kids being pushed into crime, psychological issues, bad parenting, careless teachers and school administrators, the new generation "losing its way," government policies, capitalism, and hundreds of other reasons you could think of... Also, as someone who has spent over 13 years living in the U.S.—the epicenter of these kinds of shootings—and specifically in Texas, the capital of gun ownership, surrounded by rural folks with very deeply rooted opinions on this issue, while also closely following the scientific research on the topic, I think I can offer you some real perspective here. Gather 'round, let's talk.
00:00 Intro: What Causes Mass Shootings?
01:44 The Individual vs. The Environment: Can We Solve the Problem by Looking at Just One?
04:16 Mass Killings and School Shootings: Is There a Common Age, Sexual Orientation, Race, or Ethnicity?
05:20 Male Rage: What Does It Mean That Most Shooters Are Men?
06:40 The Phrenology Fallacy: Can We Stop Shooters by Looking at Genetics and Physical Traits?
08:40 Moral Panic: Has the New Generation Lost Its Way?
11:28 Do Video Games Drive Teens to Violence?
14:11 Do Toy Guns Turn Kids Into Killers?
14:56 Actors vs. Games: Do TV Shows and Movies Lead to Brutality?
18:21 The Prohibitionist Mindset: Is a Total Ban the Solution?
19:32 Guns: What's the Link Between Gun Ownership and Massacres?
20:25 Does Increased Access to Guns Cause More Deaths?
22:09 Where Do Shooters Get Their Guns?
22:49 Does It Make Sense to Put Police in Schools and Arm Teachers?
25:13 Bullying: What Is the Most Common Motivation for Shooters?
26:12 Social Isolation: The Critical Disconnection That Drives Shooters to Massacre!
27:30 The Desire for Infamy: Shooters Feel Like Nobody Is Listening to Them!
28:15 Extreme Ideologies: Many Shooters Are Drawn to Hitler, Fascism, and Misogyny!
28:51 Echo Chambers: 20% of Shooters Are Radicalized on Online Forums!
29:40 Conflict with Authority: Most Shooters Have a Criminal Record!
31:00 Copycat Killers and the Spotlight: Why the Media Needs to Be Careful!
32:05 The Psychology of Shooters: Most of Them Are Not Healthy Individuals!
32:52 Domestic Violence and Neighborhood Environment: How Surroundings Create Killers!
34:53 Who and What Creates All These Conditions?
37:54 Outro: If We Want to Solve This Problem, We Must Remember These Things!
***
📽️ Videography & Post-Production: Çınar Ege Bakırcı
Evrim Ağacı's science communication work in Turkey is entirely funded by its readers and viewers. If you find what we do valuable and want to help us do more:
💪 You can join our Patreon or Kreosus supporters: Patreon: evrimagaci | https://kreosus.com/evrimagaci
📹 If you'd like, you can also support us using YouTube's "JOIN" feature: @evrimagaci
🎪 To buy science t-shirts, books, and our other merch: https://pazar.evrimagaci.org/
🎈 To support us via IBAN, cryptocurrency, or PayPal: https://evrimagaci.org/destekol
📕 You can find more info about why we need your support right here: https://evrimagaci.org/destekol
Thank you so much for standing with us! ❤
***
SOME USEFUL LINKS:
• To watch our latest video: https://dar.vin/SonVideo
• To watch our most popular video: https://dar.vin/EnPopuler
• To subscribe to our channel: https://dar.vin/EAYouTube
20 Comments
Silahlı Okul Saldırılarının Sebebi Ne?
Evrim Ağacı
746,038 views
We lost some bright, young kids in the school shootings in Kahramanmaraş and Şanlıurfa. First and foremost, my deepest condolences go out to the families of the children who lost their lives. I wish I could say, "I hope we never see this kind of brutality again," but... we're scientists. We're science enthusiasts. We know that when certain conditions are met, the natural consequences of those conditions are inevitable. Given enough time, even highly improbable events become almost a certainty—they will happen over and over again. That's why today, I want to talk to you about the underlying conditions that pave the way for these kinds of massacres. Because right now, everyone on social media is throwing out a different theory: video games, TV series, toy guns, economic problems, ignorance, genetics, a lack of police in schools, gun ownership, kids being pushed into crime, psychological issues, bad parenting, careless teachers and school administrators, the new generation "losing its way," government policies, capitalism, and hundreds of other reasons you could think of... Also, as someone who has spent over 13 years living in the U.S.—the epicenter of these kinds of shootings—and specifically in Texas, the capital of gun ownership, surrounded by rural folks with very deeply rooted opinions on this issue, while also closely following the scientific research on the topic, I think I can offer you some real perspective here. Gather 'round, let's talk.
00:00 Intro: What Causes Mass Shootings?
01:44 The Individual vs. The Environment: Can We Solve the Problem by Looking at Just One?
04:16 Mass Killings and School Shootings: Is There a Common Age, Sexual Orientation, Race, or Ethnicity?
05:20 Male Rage: What Does It Mean That Most Shooters Are Men?
06:40 The Phrenology Fallacy: Can We Stop Shooters by Looking at Genetics and Physical Traits?
08:40 Moral Panic: Has the New Generation Lost Its Way?
11:28 Do Video Games Drive Teens to Violence?
14:11 Do Toy Guns Turn Kids Into Killers?
14:56 Actors vs. Games: Do TV Shows and Movies Lead to Brutality?
18:21 The Prohibitionist Mindset: Is a Total Ban the Solution?
19:32 Guns: What's the Link Between Gun Ownership and Massacres?
20:25 Does Increased Access to Guns Cause More Deaths?
22:09 Where Do Shooters Get Their Guns?
22:49 Does It Make Sense to Put Police in Schools and Arm Teachers?
25:13 Bullying: What Is the Most Common Motivation for Shooters?
26:12 Social Isolation: The Critical Disconnection That Drives Shooters to Massacre!
27:30 The Desire for Infamy: Shooters Feel Like Nobody Is Listening to Them!
28:15 Extreme Ideologies: Many Shooters Are Drawn to Hitler, Fascism, and Misogyny!
28:51 Echo Chambers: 20% of Shooters Are Radicalized on Online Forums!
29:40 Conflict with Authority: Most Shooters Have a Criminal Record!
31:00 Copycat Killers and the Spotlight: Why the Media Needs to Be Careful!
32:05 The Psychology of Shooters: Most of Them Are Not Healthy Individuals!
32:52 Domestic Violence and Neighborhood Environment: How Surroundings Create Killers!
34:53 Who and What Creates All These Conditions?
37:54 Outro: If We Want to Solve This Problem, We Must Remember These Things!
***
📽️ Videography & Post-Production: Çınar Ege Bakırcı
Evrim Ağacı's science communication work in Turkey is entirely funded by its readers and viewers. If you find what we do valuable and want to help us do more:
💪 You can join our Patreon or Kreosus supporters: Patreon: evrimagaci | https://kreosus.com/evrimagaci
📹 If you'd like, you can also support us using YouTube's "JOIN" feature: @evrimagaci
🎪 To buy science t-shirts, books, and our other merch: https://pazar.evrimagaci.org/
🎈 To support us via IBAN, cryptocurrency, or PayPal: https://evrimagaci.org/destekol
📕 You can find more info about why we need your support right here: https://evrimagaci.org/destekol
Thank you so much for standing with us! ❤
***
SOME USEFUL LINKS:
• To watch our latest video: https://dar.vin/SonVideo
• To watch our most popular video: https://dar.vin/EnPopuler
• To subscribe to our channel: https://dar.vin/EAYouTube
:_evoElektrik:Videoyu tekrar izlerken, vermek istediğimiz ana mesajlardan birini atladığımızı fark ettik; "zor problemler" videosunda ele alırız ama buraya da not düşmüş olalım: Bu tarz meselelerde herkes kendi çözümünü "haklı" görüyor, çünkü videodan da görebileceğiniz gibi bazı istisnalar hariç herkesin çözümü bir miktar haklı! Dolayısıyla önemli olan, kendi öncelediğimiz görüşte doğruluk payı olup olmamasından ziyade, video sonunda bahsettiğimiz gibi bu çözüm önerisinin harekete geçilebilir, sorun üzerinde gerçekten de yeterince büyük etkiye sahip (yani vakaların çoğunu izah edebilen), nedenselliği gösterilebilir bir çözüm önerisi olup olmadığını tespit etmekte. Bunu yaptığımızda, tekil bir önerinin evrensel olmadığını, çok başlı probleme çok başlı bir çözüm önerisi getirmek gerektiğini görüyoruz. Bu, bilimsel anlamda çözümü anlamadığımız anlamına gelmiyor. Tam tersine, onu aklımıza gelen ilk açıklamaya nazaran çok daha başarılı karakterize edebildiğimiz anlamına geliyor.
👕 Videolardaki tişörtleri satın almak ve diğer bilim ürünlerimizi görmek için Agora Bilim Pazarımıza uğrayabilirsiniz: https://pazar.evrimagaci.org/
💗 Evrim Ağacı, okur ve izleyen destekleriyle yola devam ediyor. Bize destek olan bilimseverlere katılın: https://kreosus.com/evrimagaci | https://youtube.com/@evrimagaci/join
💪🏼 Daha fazla destek yöntemi görmek için: https://evrimagaci.org/youtube