OpenTube

FULL TESTIMONY | Caleb Flynn's Sister-In-Law Kayla Keyt testifies in his murder trial

East Idaho News

294,677 views

#calebflynn #trial #courtroominsider #americanidol

Caleb Flynn's Sister-In-Law Kayla Keyt testified in his murder trial on day 3 of the Caleb Flynn murder trial in Ohio.

The 40-year-old is charged with aggravated murder, murder, felonious assault, tampering with evidence and intimidation of witness, attorney or victim in a criminal case in the death of his wife, Ashley.

Flynn is a youth pastor and is known as being a contestant on season 12 of the reality show, "American Idol."

In an early-morning call to 911 on February 16th, 2026, Flynn tells dispatchers that intruders entered his home and shot his wife. He has pleaded not guilty to all charges.

Join Nate Eaton on "Courtroom Insider" as he breaks down all the developments from the trial each day at 7 p.m. MDT on the East Idaho News and Courtroom Insider YouTube channels.

► Support East Idaho News: https://www.eastidahonews.com/donate/
► Subscribe to East Idaho News: https://www.youtube.com/c/Eastidahone...
► Subscribe to Courtroom Insider: @courtroom.insider
► Get merch: https://www.eastidahonews.com/shop/
► Download our free app: http://marketplace-redirect.doapps.co...
► Like East Idaho News on Facebook: Facebook: EastIdahoNews
► Like Courtroom Insider on Facebook: Facebook: courtinsider
► Follow East Idaho News on X: Twitter: EastIDNews
► Follow Courtroom Insider on X: https://x.com/courtroominside
► Follow us on Instagram: Instagram: eastidahonews
► Subscribe to our free newsletter: https://www.eastidahonews.com/newslet...

20 Comments

@sdp-y2p 9 days ago

Pulling $200k because he married into the right family and then turns out to pay them back by murdering their daughter. What a slimeball.

@JenMitchell-f9f 9 days ago

Boy he really screwed his life up. Had a life only others dream of. What a sick selfish monster. He's guilty!!! I hope her family and children heal from this evil.

@CJAmara 9 days ago

It’s very easy to not have an affair. And it’s even easier to not kill your spouse. This guy fumbled a life he didn’t deserve in the first place.

@susanqueen4628 9 days ago

Her sister is a class act!! Bless her.

@ericafine5373 9 days ago

I love that she's raising her sister's children.

@critterscute3642 9 days ago

This narcissistic psychopath had a life many of us can only dream of. A loving wife, children, great extended and supportive family, a nice house, part of the family business, a supportive church congregation. The list goes on. But it wasn’t enough. His narcissistic self wanted all that with a mistress and was going to stop at nothing to get it. He used everyone around him to accomplish his personal “perfect life.” What an evil and disgusting excuse of a human being, let alone a “Christian.”

@jilldinkins2746 9 days ago

What a wonderful sister. I’m so sorry for all the pain your entire family has been through.

@Mom99004 9 days ago

He is so guilty he cant even look at her

@StarlynWilcox 9 days ago

Unbelievable that he isn’t man enough to confess and is willing to put her family through this after all he has done already

@MillieKay 6 days ago

Such a beautiful, sweet sister. She held up so well on the stand even with a broken heart. 💔

@FungusAmungus-fl8iy 9 days ago

I cant even stand to look at his sorry ass face.

@PrayingforIsrael 6 days ago

Caleb wasn't a hard worker... He was only texting his mistress all day...

@raqueladauto7309 8 days ago

How sad, Ashley’s daughters, sister and family having all doors locked because they’re scared to death, not knowing the monster was locked right inside with them basically!

@micheleshertenlieb4856 9 days ago

These girls are so beautiful inside and out and he is a disgusting creature. He never deserved her or her beautiful family.

@ScorpioSun213 6 days ago

Ashley and Kayla are stunning. 🤍 I can’t imagine how bittersweet it is to be raising your nieces while mourning your sister every day.

@Tonino1865 9 days ago (edited)

What an absolute sweetheart I’m positive Her sister was as well. What a delightful family.

@jessicavance5058 8 days ago

She kept the nieces’ dog in her home 😓❤️‍🩹 such a loving family

@AnneMarieMoyer 9 days ago

Wow what he gave up. Huge job, wonderful wife, two kids, two dogs, and an important job at his church. Such a shame.

@TenTenSevenSeven 9 days ago

He is a monster! How could be do that to her family and their children????? 😭😭😭😭😭😭 Makes me so sick!!!! I feel so bad for Ashley's family having to get on the stand and have to go through this. They are the strongest people I know. And the defense needs to leave her family alone!