When Arthur is such a jerk, That even Micah has to come stop him

"NOBODY CARES" -Arthur, 1899

This is  why nobody mentions Arthur in the first game

“That’s a fine horse.”
“Thank you.”
“How long you been married?”

"Leave her alone, Arthur"
"You like bullying women, do ya"
Is there something you ain't telling us, John?

22:57
Arthur: Hey mister!
Stranger: Hola
Arthur: Oh i forgot to say.... gimme all your money

1:55 tilly insulted him better

Arthur: Bullies John

Tilly: “Just leave her alone, will you?”

Arthur: Bullied John again

John: “Can’t you see I’m ignoring you? Like bullying women, do ya?”

🤔🤔🤔

22:41 "if you're gonna shoot someone I got a recommendation" wtf hahahah

i like how Arthur innocently asks "so how long you been married" and the guy's immediate response is to try to fucking kill him

"Good mornin' Arthur."

" L I T T L E  J O H N N Y  M A R S T O N "

Kid:*bullies arthur*
Arthur: bullies them back
Kid: wHy Are yOU bUllyInG me????

5:28

Arthur: some husband you are – were.

Widower: And you! You just stand and watch?!?

Arthur: she weren't my wife.

Damn, Milton was right. Arthur does venerate savagery.

16:14
Arthur: (intentionally rush himself into poor man)
Also Arthur: Relax, my friend. Nevermind.

I remember one time in Saint Denis I greeted someone, Arthur said “Hello” and the stranger didn’t say anything. then I decided to antagonize and then Arthur said “I said, hello”  sounding irritated and it was like Arthur read my mind about how that dude just ignored me.

Arthur: disses John

Tilly: "just leave her alone Arthur"

Me: Wait... What?

28:57 Dutch screaming we still need MUNEH! In the background

Even jerk Arthur wouldn’t antagonize Hosea

8:09 that line was delivered perfectly with the dynamite toss, that quite literally is a badass moment

26:04

There's something about Arthur telling "YOU WANT A PROBLEM, BOAH?!" to a lawman that just made me lose it.