MENGAPA CHINA BISA SEKAYA ITU? DAN KENAPA INDONESIA TIDAK ?
Ruang Makro
312,855 views
If you want to support us, you can do so here: https://saweria.co/ruangmakroreal
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 1978, China was still poorer than Indonesia—its average income was only a third of ours. Today, the order is completely reversed: China is the world's second-largest economy, and its products are in every shop. How is that possible in a single human lifetime?
This video traces China's story from the famine of the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution, through Deng Xiaoping's reforms, the Shenzhen special economic zone, and China's entry into the WTO. We debunk the myth of 'large population, low wages, authoritarian government,' considering meritocracy and its dark side, the property crisis, an aging population, and the tech war with America. Finally, we draw it all back to Indonesia: Sulawesi nickel, high-speed trains, and the wave of cheap imports that are stifling our industry. Watch until the end to see the true price behind China's economic miracle—and who is paying for it.
— Chapter —
0:00 Opening
1:07 The Dark Zero
3:13 Deng's Cat
4:24 Four Steps of Reform
10:08 The Machine and Its Cracks
13:16 Meritocracy and Its Holes
20:59 Five-Year Wounds
26:23 The Price for Indonesia
31:18 Footage Sources
— Sources:
• Ezra Vogel — 'Deng Xiaoping and the Transformation of China,' a biography of the architect of China's economic reforms
• Yuen Yuen Ang — 'How China Escaped the Poverty Trap,' about directed adjustments in China's development
• Ronald Coase & Ning Wang — 'How China Became Capitalist,' about reforms that grew from below
• Daniel A. Bell — 'The China Model,' about political meritocracy as an alternative to democracy
• Elizabeth Economy — 'The Third Revolution,' about tightening state control in the Xi Jinping era
• Bill Hayton — 'The 'Invention of China', about how modern Chinese identity and history were constructed
• Thomas Orlik — 'China: The Bubble That Never Pops', about China's debt management and financial risk
• Joe Studwell — 'How Asia Works', about the development recipes of Japan, South Korea, and China
#CHINA
20 Comments
Singapura merdeka 1965. Malaysia merdeka 1957. China 1970 masih negara miskin. Vietnam 1974 Masih perang. Hong Kong 1998 baru serah terima dari Inggris.
Indonesia malah jalan ditempat, masalah nya penduduk Indonesia pilih pemimpin yang seiman, tetapi masalahnya IMAN pejabat terpilih tidak kuat akan godaan kalau sudah jadi pejabat. Test aja polisi atau pejabat di Indonesia jual beli kebijaksanaan dengan uang, kegoda ngak imannya. Ini tidak belaku dinegara tetangga kita Singapura. Meskipun tidak seiman, tetapi imannya kuat. Coba tawarin uang ke polisi disana, kegoda ngak? Bagus kalau kamu ngak langsung diborgol.
Ada presiden yang sibuk ngurusin anak yang belum cukup umur supaya jadi wapres dengan cara merubah undang undang. Ada president yang sibuk dibagi bagi proyek buat pendukungnya dan partainya, beli suara rakyat untuk keperluan pemilu 2029. kaya MBG, kopdes Dan export satu pintu. Proyek Korupsi dimana mana. Dari 100 orang terkaya di Indonesia yang seiman sedikit, alasannya, maju sedikit sudah foya foya. Gimana mau maju, kalau IMANNYA lemah. Makanya memilih pemimpin alasan KINERJA lebih masuk akal dari pada seiman. 😂😂😂.
Bukti pemerintah tidak perlu mengontrol sepenuhnya kehidupan masyarakat, cukup di berikan ruang untuk bangkit dengan sendirinya tanpa ketergantungan, menjadikan masyarakat mandiri.
Dari ribuan tahun lalu sampai sekarang zaman modern ,identitas budaya peradaban mereka tidak berganti,mau dijajah siapapun identitas mreka tetap bertahan tidak tergantikan.
Jadi boleh dibilang negara china itu bukan negara yg baru lahir puluhan tahun ini,tapi uda ada ribuan tahun lalu.
MENGAPA CHINA BISA SEKAYA ITU? DAN KENAPA INDONESIA TIDAK ?
Ruang Makro
312,855 views
If you want to support us, you can do so here: https://saweria.co/ruangmakroreal
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
In 1978, China was still poorer than Indonesia—its average income was only a third of ours. Today, the order is completely reversed: China is the world's second-largest economy, and its products are in every shop. How is that possible in a single human lifetime?
This video traces China's story from the famine of the Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution, through Deng Xiaoping's reforms, the Shenzhen special economic zone, and China's entry into the WTO. We debunk the myth of 'large population, low wages, authoritarian government,' considering meritocracy and its dark side, the property crisis, an aging population, and the tech war with America. Finally, we draw it all back to Indonesia: Sulawesi nickel, high-speed trains, and the wave of cheap imports that are stifling our industry. Watch until the end to see the true price behind China's economic miracle—and who is paying for it.
— Chapter —
0:00 Opening
1:07 The Dark Zero
3:13 Deng's Cat
4:24 Four Steps of Reform
10:08 The Machine and Its Cracks
13:16 Meritocracy and Its Holes
20:59 Five-Year Wounds
26:23 The Price for Indonesia
31:18 Footage Sources
— Sources:
• Ezra Vogel — 'Deng Xiaoping and the Transformation of China,' a biography of the architect of China's economic reforms
• Yuen Yuen Ang — 'How China Escaped the Poverty Trap,' about directed adjustments in China's development
• Ronald Coase & Ning Wang — 'How China Became Capitalist,' about reforms that grew from below
• Daniel A. Bell — 'The China Model,' about political meritocracy as an alternative to democracy
• Elizabeth Economy — 'The Third Revolution,' about tightening state control in the Xi Jinping era
• Bill Hayton — 'The 'Invention of China', about how modern Chinese identity and history were constructed
• Thomas Orlik — 'China: The Bubble That Never Pops', about China's debt management and financial risk
• Joe Studwell — 'How Asia Works', about the development recipes of Japan, South Korea, and China
#CHINA