إبراهيم عيسى.. الإمام الشافعي أخ/طر من ابن تيمية لماذا؟
إبراهيم عيسى
57,224 views
#Ibrahim_Eissa
#Egypt #Al-Shafi'i #Ibn_Taymiyyah #Sheikh_of_Islam
Was Imam Al-Shafi'i a reformist thinker or a scholar who served the authorities?
In this video, Ibrahim Eissa presents an episode about understanding the person behind the symbol. We deconstruct the sacred image that has been painted around one of the greatest imams in Islamic history, Imam Muhammad ibn Idris Al-Shafi'i, from Gaza to Baghdad and then to Egypt. Al-Shafi'i's complex intellectual, political, and religious journey unfolded amidst persecution, excommunication, and sanctification. He was a victim of the fanaticism of his time, and his thought itself became a tool in the hands of the fanatics against all dissenters.
Was Al-Shafi'i truly a champion of the Sunnah, as is often claimed, or did he transform toward the end of his life into one of the theorists of the official thought of the Abbasid state? Is Al-Shafi'i different from Ibn Taymiyyah, who was described as the Sheikh of Islam?
Who was Imam Al-Shafi'i really? How did he begin his life? Why was he accused of Shi'ism? And how did he become the most prominent founder of the science of the principles of jurisprudence in Islamic history?
The strange irony is that the imam who introduced the concept of consensus later became a victim of the same concept, and was killed by a fanatic who claimed he had contradicted the group!
Videos by Ibrahim Issa You Must Watch
إبراهيم عيسى.. لن أتبرع إلى غزة
إبراهيم عيسى.. مدد يا بدوي…هل الصوفية هي ا...
إبراهيم عيسى..المرضى النفسيون من تل أبيب إ...
Ibrahim Issa boldly discusses how schools of jurisprudence transformed from spaces for ijtihad into tools of intellectual repression, and how the idea of "no ijtihad with a text", introduced by al-Shafi'i, contributed to the closure of reason and ijtihad for centuries.
Did al-Shafi'i seek to restrict religious thought? Or was he misunderstood? Were his views on women and slavery the ijtihad of his time, or ideas that had become obsolete? When does a learned imam become a sacred symbol that cannot be criticized?
The episode also presents the intellectual struggle between the proponents of the text and the proponents of reason during the Abbasid era, and how al-Shafi'i became the missing link used by Caliph Harun al-Rashid to consolidate political and religious authority. Together, we discover how al-Shafi'i elevated the status of the Prophetic Sunnah to a level comparable to the Holy Qur'an, thus legitimizing the rule of the Quraysh and the Abbasid Caliphate. This deepened the connection between religion and the state, the effects of which remain to this day.
The video also discusses the doctrinal and intellectual transformations al-Shafi'i underwent, from his initial affiliation with the Zaidi Mu'tazilite movement to his conversion to the founder of the textual Shafi'i school. What were the reasons that led him to shift his thinking from one extreme to the other? Was the shift stemming from intellectual conviction or political affinity with the authorities? Can he truly be described as a thinker of authority, as some recent studies suggest?
In this video, you'll learn the story of al-Shafi'i's arrest in Yemen, his trial before Harun al-Rashid, and the moment when his eloquence and intelligence saved him from death. He went from being accused of Shi'ism to a scholar close to the Caliph, and then to a shining star in Baghdad and Egypt.
We also recount the story of his tragic murder at the hands of a Maliki fanatic in Egypt, a scene that epitomizes the conflict between sects and religious fanaticism that continues to this day. The video attempts to open a debate about the idea of sanctity in religious thought. Should the opinions of imams remain above criticism, or does respect for scholars not conflict with our right to disagree with them?
How can we read al-Shafi'i's legacy today with a new lens that respects history without sanctifying it? Do we need a new jurisprudence that restores consideration for reason, independent reasoning, and freedom?
Watch the episode to discover another side of Imam al-Shafi'i... the human imam before he was the imam of the school of thought, and the thinker who lived between rebellion and authority, between freedom and text, and between reason and consensus.
#al-Shafi'i_and_Harun_al-Rashid #al-Shafi'i_and_Ibn_Hanbal #al-Shafi'i_Quotes #Let_Days_Do_What_They_Wish #al-Shafi'i_and_the_Mu'tazila
#Imam_al-Shafi'i #al-Shafi'i_Thought #The_Life_of_Imam_al-Shafi'i #Al-Shafi'i_School #Usul_al-Fiqh #al-Shafi'i #Harun_al-Rashid #Disagreement_Between_Schools #Ijtihad_with_Text #Women_according_to_al-Shafi'i #The_Story_of_the_Murder_of_Imam_al-Shafi'i #Al-Mu'tazila_and_the_Abbasids #The_Quran_and_Religious_Authority #al-Shafi'i_the_Thinker_of_Authority #Ibn_Taymiyyah #Sheikh_of_Islam #Islam
#Egypt_America #Saudi_Arabia #UAE #Kuwait #Qatar #Mustafa_Madbouly #Religious_Stories #Palestinian_Factions #Algeria #America #Morocco #Iraq #Syria
20 Comments
إبراهيم عيسى.. الإمام الشافعي أخ/طر من ابن تيمية لماذا؟
إبراهيم عيسى
57,224 views
#Ibrahim_Eissa
#Egypt #Al-Shafi'i #Ibn_Taymiyyah #Sheikh_of_Islam
Was Imam Al-Shafi'i a reformist thinker or a scholar who served the authorities?
In this video, Ibrahim Eissa presents an episode about understanding the person behind the symbol. We deconstruct the sacred image that has been painted around one of the greatest imams in Islamic history, Imam Muhammad ibn Idris Al-Shafi'i, from Gaza to Baghdad and then to Egypt. Al-Shafi'i's complex intellectual, political, and religious journey unfolded amidst persecution, excommunication, and sanctification. He was a victim of the fanaticism of his time, and his thought itself became a tool in the hands of the fanatics against all dissenters.
Was Al-Shafi'i truly a champion of the Sunnah, as is often claimed, or did he transform toward the end of his life into one of the theorists of the official thought of the Abbasid state? Is Al-Shafi'i different from Ibn Taymiyyah, who was described as the Sheikh of Islam?
Who was Imam Al-Shafi'i really? How did he begin his life? Why was he accused of Shi'ism? And how did he become the most prominent founder of the science of the principles of jurisprudence in Islamic history?
The strange irony is that the imam who introduced the concept of consensus later became a victim of the same concept, and was killed by a fanatic who claimed he had contradicted the group!
Videos by Ibrahim Issa You Must Watch
إبراهيم عيسى.. لن أتبرع إلى غزة
إبراهيم عيسى.. مدد يا بدوي…هل الصوفية هي ا...
إبراهيم عيسى..المرضى النفسيون من تل أبيب إ...
Ibrahim Issa boldly discusses how schools of jurisprudence transformed from spaces for ijtihad into tools of intellectual repression, and how the idea of "no ijtihad with a text", introduced by al-Shafi'i, contributed to the closure of reason and ijtihad for centuries.
Did al-Shafi'i seek to restrict religious thought? Or was he misunderstood? Were his views on women and slavery the ijtihad of his time, or ideas that had become obsolete? When does a learned imam become a sacred symbol that cannot be criticized?
The episode also presents the intellectual struggle between the proponents of the text and the proponents of reason during the Abbasid era, and how al-Shafi'i became the missing link used by Caliph Harun al-Rashid to consolidate political and religious authority. Together, we discover how al-Shafi'i elevated the status of the Prophetic Sunnah to a level comparable to the Holy Qur'an, thus legitimizing the rule of the Quraysh and the Abbasid Caliphate. This deepened the connection between religion and the state, the effects of which remain to this day.
The video also discusses the doctrinal and intellectual transformations al-Shafi'i underwent, from his initial affiliation with the Zaidi Mu'tazilite movement to his conversion to the founder of the textual Shafi'i school. What were the reasons that led him to shift his thinking from one extreme to the other? Was the shift stemming from intellectual conviction or political affinity with the authorities? Can he truly be described as a thinker of authority, as some recent studies suggest?
In this video, you'll learn the story of al-Shafi'i's arrest in Yemen, his trial before Harun al-Rashid, and the moment when his eloquence and intelligence saved him from death. He went from being accused of Shi'ism to a scholar close to the Caliph, and then to a shining star in Baghdad and Egypt.
We also recount the story of his tragic murder at the hands of a Maliki fanatic in Egypt, a scene that epitomizes the conflict between sects and religious fanaticism that continues to this day. The video attempts to open a debate about the idea of sanctity in religious thought. Should the opinions of imams remain above criticism, or does respect for scholars not conflict with our right to disagree with them?
How can we read al-Shafi'i's legacy today with a new lens that respects history without sanctifying it? Do we need a new jurisprudence that restores consideration for reason, independent reasoning, and freedom?
Watch the episode to discover another side of Imam al-Shafi'i... the human imam before he was the imam of the school of thought, and the thinker who lived between rebellion and authority, between freedom and text, and between reason and consensus.
#al-Shafi'i_and_Harun_al-Rashid #al-Shafi'i_and_Ibn_Hanbal #al-Shafi'i_Quotes #Let_Days_Do_What_They_Wish #al-Shafi'i_and_the_Mu'tazila
#Imam_al-Shafi'i #al-Shafi'i_Thought #The_Life_of_Imam_al-Shafi'i #Al-Shafi'i_School #Usul_al-Fiqh #al-Shafi'i #Harun_al-Rashid #Disagreement_Between_Schools #Ijtihad_with_Text #Women_according_to_al-Shafi'i #The_Story_of_the_Murder_of_Imam_al-Shafi'i #Al-Mu'tazila_and_the_Abbasids #The_Quran_and_Religious_Authority #al-Shafi'i_the_Thinker_of_Authority #Ibn_Taymiyyah #Sheikh_of_Islam #Islam
#Egypt_America #Saudi_Arabia #UAE #Kuwait #Qatar #Mustafa_Madbouly #Religious_Stories #Palestinian_Factions #Algeria #America #Morocco #Iraq #Syria