Ugh, I got excited to post the video and didn't fully explain why I liked the first ranked AP as much as I did:

The first book is so completely open world and sandboxy and there's threats that are above your level that can kill you... but also losing a fight is not actually a TPK because of the rules which allows the GM to go ham wild on their players.. and even if you ran the first book like 3 times each group would do it differently and would effectively run a different game every time.

I will say there's a LOT of combat though, most of our sessions have been tough combats. But, it's been a blast and I think it merits the #1 position.

I should have put this in the video. Whatever, you can read it now!

Pathfinder APs and casting aside the "hook" after the first book or two:  Name a more iconic duo.

It too me forever to realize, that the subtitles are not from Youtube but that you made and edited them in yourself. Now I speak fluent English but I absolutely love subtitles and they help me a lot in understanding everything in a video, and stay concentrated. So I absolutely appreciate these. Thank you so much!

On top of, thank you so much for this ranking and overview, as I was considering buying one of these to help with learning to DM! ♥

Paizo’s more recent adventures have been banger after banger. Season of Ghosts is my favourite, with Curtain Call and Sky King’s Tomb close behind.

Excellent list with some good insight.  I just started running Strength of Thousands and agree, there is NOT a lot of school related content.  My group's first question was, "When are we going to start classes?"  So, I am working on a full class curriculum which offers a year-by-year list of classes and electives using locations in and around Magaambya while offering some class-related, side quest opportunities.  I also home-brewed my own system for students getting behind and skill challenges they need to pass each class.  Thanks again!

'Join the discord to talk to like minded gamers?" more like "join the Discord to dunk on Pablo all day everyday!"

Currently running Season of Ghosts and we’re having a blast. It’s definitely worthy of its spot on this list

We're just about to finish Season of Ghosts and I have to say its by far my favorite campaign I've run. The story, the characters, the location -- the writers were passionate about Tian Xia and it really shows, its probably one of their strongest (if not their strongest) regions on the world map atp.

We're going to do Blood Lords next, excited for it but realizing it'll be a big tone shift.

Great job, thanks for sharing. I appreciate that your position is different from many reviews as you are looking at it from the perspective of someone who runs often, rather than the only adventure someone might run for 2 years. Some of them play/feel a lot differently than expected if you run them again. Subbed after this and your foundry videos.

Thanks for the work producing this video. It's fantastic!

Hey man, a big thank you for the subtitles - I’m hearing impaired so I really appreciate them!

As a GM, I prefer homebrew adventures over Adventure Paths(not that I"m doing anywhere near as many as you ofc). Sometimes I will take a peak at adventures if a friend has one. I can say I absolutely LOVE that Fist of the Ruby Phoenix has an encounter that offers what I'd call, to minimize spoilers, a "unique perspective" on how an encounter can be run.

Wow everybody's talking great stuff about Season of Ghosts all of sudden! Also your alert about how long Kingmaker lasts was a little scary since my party plays it twice monthly. We have been at it for 8 months and just hit level 5

I've just started DMing a campaign for the first time in 30 years (career, kids, etc). Running Agents of Edgewatch.  We're halfway through book 2. More than anything, your videos keep me enthusiastic about PF2e and Foundry. "Motivational", if you will.  Thanks!

Cool video man, I love how Paizo does put in more efforts into their Modules than 5e, tried reading a couple of them and I can certainly agree while Paizo's isn't perfect, they do provide enough content and base ground to make homebrewing or fixing things easier, compared to the other.

Session Zero with my players for Season of Ghosts is this Saturday and I couldn't be more excited!  I fell in love after reading the story and I'm glad to hear from multiple sources it's as good as it reads.

Great content.  Keep up the great work.

The Glass Cannon Network is running Gatewalkers.  I'm enjoying it so much that I catch the weekly live premieres and rewatch episodes.  They just started the 2nd book.  Live premieres are Thursday nights at 8 pm Eastern, 90-ish minute games.

Love the DRG reference. Rock and Stone! To the Bone!

Nice to see Fists of the Riby Phoenix love! Ive run it foe two groups. Both had a blast. They also approached it very differently: one group was heroic heroes being role models. The other would cheat and lie if they thought they could get away with it.

Its got exploration, combat, a surprising amount of RP in book 2, and is very open for a GM to improvise. I added a new team foe each group that was tailored for them (one was our group from Curse of the Crimson Throne, minus my Bard who was performing duding the tournament so couldn't participate).

Kingmaker is one I'm having a harder time with. Because yeah, its really long, and thr kingdom rules are a mess. Having the deck stacked so hard against you after a few levels is just not fun when you are supposed to be building a kingdom. Its hard not to knock it down in the rankings when a core part of the premise is such a mess, but i also fond the story over rated somewhat as its so long that sometimes it foesnt feel like we actually have any stoey going on and are just out looking for something to do.

Maybe its just not suited to my group. (Meanwhile i rate Extinction Curse quite highly as i ran that and my players loved it. So I guess we could just be odd.)

Prepping a Kingmaker campaign right now so this is cool.