B on the Tier List! Also, check out my Patreon if you'd like to support the channel:

https://www.patreon.com/harbowholmes

This episode actually got my friend to watch Doctor Who. He told me "There's no way The Doctor turns into a Goblin, T-Poses, floats towards the enemy, and wins."

Everyone: thinks the word doctor*
Some random pediatrician: unlimited POWER!!!

I actually really disagree with the idea that her leaving because she was in love with the doctor devalues her journey. it's exactly what shows how much she has grown. she's choosing to leave to be with her family and because she has realised that she deserves better than someone who will never love her back. she doesn't need to his validation anymore. she has always been brilliant without him but in that moment she finally sees it.

Nah bro, he didn't become Space Jesus. That looks nothing like Ewan McGregor.

I get why you said that about Martha's goodbye but I kind of liked that she stood up and essentially said "i'm not gonna keep being second best" cos even without the love arc, the doctor did constantly put Martha down cos of Rose.  If you were friends with someone imagine how hurtful it would be to constantly be compared to another friend they used to have? I liked that she called him out on his behaviour cos she didn't deserve it. She was worth more than being the doctor's "rebound". And I'm glad she saw her self worth.

Harbo analyses Doctor Who more than English teachers analyse a single line of a poem

My own counterpoint to the space Jesus thing. As mentioned, humans are supposed to have great, if generally untapped, psychic power - it's restated and reinforced time and again throughout the show. So Martha isn't just tapping into that to break archangel, she's manipulating the collective psychic might of the entire human race to give the Doctor an edge. Because it's not just the word "Doctor" that all those people would have been thinking about. There's also the image that comes with it, the image that Martha herself put in their heads to convince everyone to go along with that plan: the image of a deific, unstoppable figure that can turn any situation around no matter how bleak it seems, that doesn't stop until it saves the day, that can do anything . And for just a single moment, humanity turns that vision into reality and transforms the Doctor into an avatar of their image of him.
Call me sappy, call it Power Of Friendship BS, I say it's the show counterpart to all the times we're told how much psychic potential humans have; the ultimate expression of the power of humanity and the payoff for the doctor's praise of humanity's tenacity and will to survive in Utopia.

I'm OK with the reset, because it does still have consequences. Martha's family are the only ones on earth who remember that year, so they have nobody else to help them through that trauma. That's probably part of the reason Martha leaves the doctor. We know it was to be there for her family, but it could be because she's the only one who could be

I've always interpreted the bit with Martha talking about her and the Doctor's relationship as her finally calling the Doctor out for how horribly he's treated her all season. I guess I can see how you could read it as devaluing her character, but I've always read it as a strength and it's one of my favorite moments in the show

I love and miss John Simm's Master immensely. He captured the insanity, desperation, and ego of the character so perfectly.

Man, Martha really was (and is) criminally underrated as a companion!

I like the final part of Jack trying to get into the Tardis. You don't see it on screen, but it strongly implies that the Toclafane killed him over and over and over again as he edged closer each time, only eventually reaching the goal.

The Toclafane reveal is one of the best twists in the series imo. Chilling.

Martha's 2nd departure was necessary for her to be honest with the Doctor and with herself. She recognized her 'love' for the Doctor would never be returned, and so she makes the decision to leave, but not with out sharing her heart. She is braver than the Doctor, because she doesn't run away, as the Doctor tends to do, but confronts her feelings and the Doctor's lack of them, and does so with her head held high, and her heart able to recover, rather than holding on her true feelings.

The issue with the space jesus bit is that the archangel network hadn't really been established very well beforehand other than saying it caused everyone to vote for the Master, which made it feel like it de-aging the doctor came out of left-field. They could've fixed this by having the Master use the psychic network to age the Doctor initially instead of using a laser screwdriver, or even maybe just by throwing in a dumb line about the laser screwdriver harnessing the power of the network.

I just love watching David Tennant T-Possng menacingly at John Simms. Without context it is hilarious. With context it's even more hilarious.

With regards to Martha's leaving, I actually think it was genuinely necessary for her to come back and tell the Doctor how she felt about him. It's not just her telling him she fancied him, it's her calling out his bad treatment of her (having spent the entire series essentially trying to use her as "Rose 2.0") and also demonstrating for the first time that she's no longer dependant on his validation. The guilty look on the Doctor's face after her comment about her friend's crush "never looking at her twice" heavily implies that he is on some level aware of what he's been doing and it's really the first moment that Martha is able to truly obtain the high ground in their relationship (since the rest of her actions in this episode were dictated by the Doctor telling her what to do at the end of the previous episode before she teleported off the Valiant). If you think about it, the Doctor has spent the entire series either genuinely unaware or else (more likely) pretending not to notice how Martha felt about him simply because it didn't suit him to acknowledge it; Martha makes the reality of their relationship explicit and points out just how unhealthy their dynamic was for her. It's hardly a bad thing. Plus I don't think it's a coincidence that the Doctor very rarely brings up Rose going forward from this point or that he is subsequently very open with Donna with regards to the type of relationship he needs/wants - it allows him the chance to realise how his obsession with Rose is hindering his ability to move on and to at least begin to get over her.

Only 15 minutes through but the mention of Martha not looking like a killer made me think about how that flips in s4, with Martha being the one threatening to use the Oster Hagen key.

I really disagree about the Martha ending. It definitely makes sense that she leaves to look after her family (as you mentioned!) but I think if she'd have left without addressing her love for The Doctor, it wouldn't have done justice to her character. The reason she comes back is to call out his behaviour towards her, make him see how hes disregarded her feelings and she does that for herself. She's leaving because she doesn't need Ten's approval or validation anymore, she has earnt it herself and she finally sees that she deserves a better life than one he can offer her. She is brave for telling him the truth and accepting the man she loves will never love her back but braver still for deciding that she is worth more and leaving him.
I just wish we'd have had an insight into how she'd met Mickey. I think the two companions that were in unrequited love with the other two main characters could've had a really interesting dynamic and a really lovely story told on screen.