OpenTube

Why Captured Canadian Privates Unsettled German Interrogators

Canadian War Stories

93,211 views

🎧 Now on Spotify! Listen here: https://open.spotify.com/show/033A4VW...

German interrogators had broken British commandos, American pilots, and Soviet officers. They had protocols for every type of prisoner. But in August 1942, nearly two thousand Canadian privates walked into their interrogation rooms after Dieppe — and the system stopped working.

These weren't officers. They weren't intelligence operatives. They were farmers from Saskatchewan, lumberjacks from British Columbia, fishermen from Nova Scotia. Men who had volunteered from a country of eleven million people. And when they sat across the table from the best interrogators in Europe, something happened that German intelligence had never encountered before.

The privates didn't break. But that wasn't what unsettled the Germans. Tough men, they understood. What they didn't understand was why these men — the lowest rank in the army — behaved as though they knew everything. Why they deflected questions with the precision of trained officers. Why they looked their captors in the eye without deference, without fear, as equals.

The answer traces back twenty-five years, to a frozen ridge in France, where a decision was made that no army in the British Empire had ever made before.

Sources:
The Dieppe Raid, Veterans Affairs Canada: https://veterans.gc.ca/en/remembrance...
Normandy Massacres, The Canadian Encyclopedia: https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.c...
Howard Margolian, Conduct Unbecoming: The Story of the Murder of Canadian Prisoners of War in Normandy (1998): https://archive.org/details/conductun...
C.P. Stacey, Six Years of War, Official History of the Canadian Army in the Second World War, Vol. I (1955): https://www.canada.ca/en/department-n...
Archival photos and footage are public domain (Library and Archives Canada, U.S. National Archives) or used under Creative Commons licenses.

#canadianwarstories #ww2 #canadianarmy #militaryhistory #canadianhistory #worldwar2

20 Comments

@MrGrumblier 2 months ago

In the Canadian army, a private was not just a a body to carry a rifle. He was literally the last in the chain of command and therefore fully briefed on the mission.

@doversoul 2 months ago

At 24:45, in left centre of the picture at the back looking directly at the camera is my father, He was from Kirkland Lake, Ontario. He enlisted when he was 17. Royal Hamilton Engineers, Sapper. He spent the rest of the war in prison camp but escaped in April '45 when prisoners were on a forced march and were strafed by allied planes. The Guards disappeared and he made his way back through Holland to England and home.
He never talked much about it, but in his later years it all came out.
He got back to Dieppe a few years before he passed away for a reunion.
We have no way of understanding what they went through.

@norcodaev 2 months ago (edited)

As a Canadian, it assumes me to think there’s people out there going “what’s a Saskatchewan?”🤣

@Karen-p9t5g 2 months ago

Canada also sent volunteer university graduates, no one shirked the call. My father was in university civil engineering, blind in one eye. He wept when his friends went overseas. He did train officers. He Tried 5 times to sign up and refused 5 times.
Women signed up to go drive ambulances and deal with the pain. No community didn’t give their finest.

@user-w9f2q 2 months ago

Could've been good, but I can't handle the repetitiveness.

@mitril6962 2 months ago

I'm Canadian and I never learned any of this at school. We should be proud of our history.

@blazunlimited 2 months ago

At least edit what the AI churns out. The same thing said over and over in only slightly different ways.

@JamesWHarman 2 months ago

Canadian here. During WW1, a fairly distant uncle of mine was a messenger. Actually had to run around the field taking messages from one place to another. What an insane position. Not sure if any family was part of WW2, but my grandma lived near Englehart, Ontario and watched trains go by with German POWs. She said they were cheering and happy, probably because we treated them better here than fighting a war. Her words.

Great video!

@NathanGask 2 months ago

This video could have been 10 minutes long without the narrator repeating 50 times the same things in different ways.

@MEGreig 1 month ago

Watching from Nova Scotia. Shedding tears for brave young men who faced death like gentlemen.

@benkonopetski2894 2 months ago

These men had volunteered as opposed to being conscripted.

They had decided before any task was given to them that the task at hand already mattered.

That and the incorporating and adapting of every mans civilian skillset, made each and every Canadian soldier tactically equilavent to a German officer, battlefield engineer or commander.

I am so proud to be Canadian.

@IronSikh44 2 months ago

A good friend of mine was a NCO in the RCR in the late 80’s to early 90’s. He told me each member of a unit was trained in radio procedures, as a medic, and being a leader. The rationale was if someone couldn’t continue - the next soldier was ready to fill the void.

@731winter 2 months ago

22:50 and thats the true difference between a volunteer and a conscript, no real volunteer would be afraid because they chose that room as a potential endpoint unlike a conscript who was forced

@shroomkaboom75 2 months ago (edited)

26:47 the man with a gun in his hand and a smoke in his other hand is David Vivian Currie, VC VD (left side, speaking to man in white shirt).

This is a rare moment of a soldier still actively on duty for the mission he is receiving news that he's earned a VC (Victoria Cross).

@cameronhamer9432 2 months ago

Canadian Military training is still a unique system
After a briefing on an operation , the troops are ask if they have any input , and suggestion to improve the task .
The lowest man in the room is allowed to speak 🇨🇦

@nancymilawski1048 2 months ago

Tuning in from Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.

There is a memorial for the Dieppe action on the beach on Lake Ontario.

They have services on November 11 but also on the day of the attack

@chrismartin934 2 months ago (edited)

My dad served on The HMCS Buctouche, a corvette sent out to throw depth charges at Nazi submarines. They covered from the mouth of the St. Lawrence into the North Atlantic. He had fond memories of serving with many of the crew being ‘Spud Islanders.’ (An early nickname of those from the province of PEI.) However, he was reluctant to discuss what kind of life he had as a young Canadian sailor. I wished I was braver and asked for stories from his experience with the Canadian Navy in WW2. He really never wanted to discuss it at all. 😔🇨🇦

@regtaylor1163 2 months ago

Americans didn't enter WW I &II until late. 1917 for WW I, 1941 for WWII.
There was no early in the war for them. Cdns 1914, & 1939.

@SuperS05 2 months ago

My mother's father fought in Italy. My father's father fought in Normandy. He carried a 50 cal. His wife worked at one of the Avro plants. Both of my grandfathers were injured and medically discharged. I miss them.