The Route 29 Stalker remains one of the most haunting mysteries in Virginia history. We examine the evidence surrounding the disappearance of Alicia Showalter Reynolds.

On March 2, 1996, Alicia Showalter Reynolds vanished while driving to Charlottesville, leaving behind an abandoned car and a trail of questions. This investigation reviews the facts of the case, detailing how witnesses observed her stopped beside a dark pickup truck in Culpeper. We analyze the connections law enforcement made to a string of roadside tricks, where women were lured by claims of vehicle trouble, and why the Route 29 Stalker was never officially identified.

Despite decades of inquiry, the case remains an active unsolved homicide. By reviewing the details of the investigation, viewers gain insight into the legal hurdles faced by the Virginia State Police and the tragic circumstances that defined this case. We aim to present the timeline of events clearly, focusing on the evidence gathered during the search for answers in this long-standing mystery.

Subscribe for weekly true crime breakdowns, and let us know in the comments what other cold cases you want to see covered next.