The map insulting snape is one of the funniest Moments of the series😂😂😂😂😂

Lupin knows all the same hidden passageways and is also withholding the fact that Sirius is an animagus. Harry is 13 and understandably lacks judgement. Lupin has no excuse.

Snape tells Harry it's an "odd place to meet" because he proabably has seen the Marauders gathering there countless times, since he was always trying to figure out what hey were up to. He must be going insane over Harry doing the same mischiefs as James lol

Dumbledore probably told the ghosts to perpetuate the rumor about the shrieking shack being haunted

J’s mustache is getting so big it might need a footrest.   😂😂😂

the way J described how he imagined Snape is pretty much how i imagined Filch

Harry is basically anti stealth.  The marauders seemed to be able to wonder the castle all they pleased, yet Harry gets caught constantly with the same exact tools.

Draco doesn't have to be faster than Ron because there was no way to immediately know where Harry was. Ron probably went to his Common Room first, waited there, then realized Harry must have been caught.

8:15 I mean none of the portraits managed to see a huge snake roaming the school last year (even if it was in the pipes it came out to attack) soooo.....

For me, it's a case of Harry not really comprehending risk. He fought Voldemort twice, believed that he was going to die on both occasions, but still prevailed. He simply isn't afraid anymore. That doesn't really hit him again until he sees Voldemort's resurrection.

Maybe Dumbledore enchanted the Shack to shriek even when Lupin is not there, so people couldn't calculate it's always on the full moon, and thus a werewolf, and maybe he had reasons to leave that up after Lupin left school?

It's just not Sunday morning until the episode drops

If Dumbledore had seen the map insult Snape, he would 100% have given Snap shampoo for Christmas

I always thought Hagrid booked 2 seats on the knight bus, because there is no way he would fit in a single one. Not that he is bringing buck beak with him 😂

say what  you will about a teenager choosing their freedom they enjoy outside of the rules over being murdered, but Lupin was a teacher and also knew about the passage through the one eyed witch.

I will never agree with the idea that Hermione is right. Sure all of them are being really stubborn and childish, but just imagine that you have a pet, someone elses bigger, stronger pet, keeps trying to kill it, and then when you tell them about it, they just get angry at you. I think it's pretty absurd to act like this didn't start with Hermione

I feel like Hermione is not being blamed for Crookshanks supposedly killing Scabbers because we know it’s Peter. However, if Crookshanks killed any other pet or if Scabbers was actually a very old, senile rat, I don’t think people would so easily excuse her actions. From Ron’s point of view, her actions and her negligence directly led to his pet dying, and he is 100% right in blaming her for it. If a friend of mine, after being repeatedly asked to control their animal, caused my pet to die, they would probably never be my friend again. She is definitely the guilty one here and is being a terrible friend.

At about 1:10:00 Lupin seeing the map. It's possible he was already looking for it. When he says to Harry that he found a boggart in Filch's office, he may have been in there looking for the map as he knew it was confiscated by Filch years ago, and the boggart was just lucky chance.

Well, the Marauders are being treated like heroes, but really, just being kids makes sense. Kids stuck in an old man's war is how it always goes.

Hermione isn't the good guy here, but certainly not the bad guy either. She acted selfish and irresponsible where it would have mattered that she was dilligent and thoughtful, but acted that way when she should have been okay with her friends just having fun.

It feels like Hermione simultainiously is both as highly concerned about Sirius as she should be, but also utterly unconcerned about what her responsibilities in pet ownership are.

Checking the broom and ratting them out is bad, but only due to Sirius not actually being a murderer. Thats the only thing that makes Hermiones behavior bad in this regard. Because if he actually was out to stab Harry, ratted his parents out to Voldemort, killed his former best friend and a good couple of muggles, he'd surely be a very real threat that is taken way less seriously than it should be.

But as for the Scabbers thing: The only thing that makes Hermiones behavior acceptable, is that Scabbers is Peter and she doesn't know that yet. So she literally doesn't care that her pet ate Rons pet and doesn't feel bad about it, even though Ron told her on multiple occasions that she should keep her Crookshanks under close watch. If you had a dog, and your neighbor gets a big aggressive dog, you'll tell them to watch it. If that dog than mauls your dog, I'm pretty sure you'd be very angry at them. Even if you didn't love your dog as much as you should have, that dog was still a living being. Scabbers, is a rat, a living Rat many of the people in Rons family loved. He was with them, for a very long time. Yes, Peter is bad, but Hermione is not being a dick about it because she knows its Peter. She just doesn't take responsibility for her actions.