Что скрывается за обаянием клиента? Психотерапевтический анализ интервью Эстер-Трубицыной.
Александр Еремеев
58,974 views
Oh, my colleagues and guests of my channel!
As a psychiatrist and psychotherapist, I explore the most complex and painful aspects of human nature, especially in the context of personality disorders. My goal is analysis and the search for ways to help.
In this video, I examine the clinical thinking of a diagnostician using the example of Ksenia Sobchak's public interview with Esther Trubitsyna.
Let me clarify right away: I do not make a diagnosis based on the interview. I am not her therapist, I have not conducted a clinical diagnosis, and I can only rely on what has been publicly shown.
I am interested in showing you how to look at this material through the eyes of a psychotherapist.
If you work with difficult clients or want to better understand the diagnosis of personality disorders, there is plenty of material here for observation and reflection.
And if you want to learn this systematically, in our programs we separately cover diagnosis, the degree of personality disorder, complex cases, and therapeutic strategies for working with them.
Timestamps:
00:00 What's in today's video
02:47 Why you can't make a diagnosis from an interview
06:49 Where I begin a clinical observation
07:35 Charm, eroticism, and strong emotional affect
11:48 What fuels behavior?
13:30 Expressive and instrumental communication
16:48 The struggle for influence between the interviewer and the heroine
18:36 Contradictions in the story: what questions would I ask the client?
20:33 Sexuality as diagnostic material
24:38 Aggression, self-destructiveness, and the severity of the case
27:20 Exploitativeness: when the other becomes a means to an end
28:08 BPD, histrionics, or antisocial dynamics? Differential Hypotheses
35:42 Values, the Ability to Care, and Therapy Prognosis
Lera's Channel: @kish_lera
Video about the Tovsikis: Почему психоразборы вредят? Кейс Товстик-Д...
Request Supervision: https://teletype.in/@eremeev.ebn/supe...
Weekly Workshop "Introduction to Personality Disorders": https://aeremeev.tilda.ws/?utm_source...
3-Month Course "Diagnostics and Basic Skills for the Treatment of Personality Disorders": https://eremeevalexander.tilda.ws/?ut...
Follow me on social media:
Alexander Eremeev's Telegram:
https://t.me/eremeevalexandr/
Telegram Ebаlogy:
https://t.me/eremeev_ebn/
Instagram (the social network is owned by Meta, a company recognized as extremist in the Russian Federation).
Instagram: alexandreremeev
Disclaimer
This video is for educational, professional, and original purposes and is intended primarily for psychologists, psychotherapists, and other helping professionals.
This analysis is based solely on a publicly available interview. I am not Maria Esther-Trubitsyna's treating physician, psychotherapist, or diagnostician. I have not conducted a clinical interview, psychiatric examination, or psychological testing with her, and I do not have access to her medical records.
Therefore, the video does not establish or endorse any psychiatric or psychological diagnosis.
References to borderline, histrionic, antisocial, and other personality traits are purely educational differential hypotheses: examples of what a specialist might examine during a full in-person assessment.
It is impossible to reliably determine the presence or absence of a mental disorder, substance use, intellectual disabilities, eating disorders, sexual behavioral patterns, or other medical or psychological conditions from a publicly available video recording.
Statements about motives, internal experiences, behavioral functions, and communication patterns represent my professional interpretation of the observed public material, and are not assertions of reliable facts about a person's inner life.
Individual events and circumstances mentioned by the participants in the public interviews have not been independently verified by me and are provided only in the context of the analysis of the published material.
The video is not intended for self-diagnosis or for diagnosing others. Individual traits, behavioral, sexual, emotional, or communication characteristics alone are not sufficient grounds for diagnosing a personality disorder.
The purpose of this analysis is to teach clinical observation, differential thinking, and a compassionate diagnostic stance, not to discredit, condemn, or publicly expose any individual.
#psychotherapy #psychology #diagnostics #differentialdiagnosis #personalitydisorders #BPD #histrionics #antisocialdisorder #countertransference #difficultclients #clinicalpsychology #clinicalthinking #sexuality #aggression #psychotherapist #psychologist #psychologisttraining #supervision #AlexanderEremeev
20 Comments
Я заметила когнитивные искажения, я спросила бы про детско -родительские отношения. У меня от нее впечатление пограничницы. Но хочется отметит много потенциала, жизненной энергии и амбиций чтобы жить счастливо.
Но если мы предполагаем всё таки , гистрионную динамику, то возможно, она сама от себя заводилась, а воду пила так активно, только потомучто много и энергично говорила, практически без пауз.
А на счёт захвата власти, все таки у них разные "весовые категории". Собчак очень прозорлива и более интеллектуально сложна, чем героиня.
Спасибо, за интереснейший разбор!
Она со рвением спортсмена несется куда-то туда, где круто, и не тормозит для того, чтобы задуматься...
Возможно, там есть история о том, что я не хуже этой Елены..!!! И какого черта я их семью обслужила, а они меня попользовали, щас ка я им задам!
Что скрывается за обаянием клиента? Психотерапевтический анализ интервью Эстер-Трубицыной.
Александр Еремеев
58,974 views
Oh, my colleagues and guests of my channel!
As a psychiatrist and psychotherapist, I explore the most complex and painful aspects of human nature, especially in the context of personality disorders. My goal is analysis and the search for ways to help.
In this video, I examine the clinical thinking of a diagnostician using the example of Ksenia Sobchak's public interview with Esther Trubitsyna.
Let me clarify right away: I do not make a diagnosis based on the interview. I am not her therapist, I have not conducted a clinical diagnosis, and I can only rely on what has been publicly shown.
I am interested in showing you how to look at this material through the eyes of a psychotherapist.
If you work with difficult clients or want to better understand the diagnosis of personality disorders, there is plenty of material here for observation and reflection.
And if you want to learn this systematically, in our programs we separately cover diagnosis, the degree of personality disorder, complex cases, and therapeutic strategies for working with them.
Timestamps:
00:00 What's in today's video
02:47 Why you can't make a diagnosis from an interview
06:49 Where I begin a clinical observation
07:35 Charm, eroticism, and strong emotional affect
11:48 What fuels behavior?
13:30 Expressive and instrumental communication
16:48 The struggle for influence between the interviewer and the heroine
18:36 Contradictions in the story: what questions would I ask the client?
20:33 Sexuality as diagnostic material
24:38 Aggression, self-destructiveness, and the severity of the case
27:20 Exploitativeness: when the other becomes a means to an end
28:08 BPD, histrionics, or antisocial dynamics? Differential Hypotheses
35:42 Values, the Ability to Care, and Therapy Prognosis
Lera's Channel: @kish_lera
Video about the Tovsikis: Почему психоразборы вредят? Кейс Товстик-Д...
Request Supervision: https://teletype.in/@eremeev.ebn/supe...
Weekly Workshop "Introduction to Personality Disorders": https://aeremeev.tilda.ws/?utm_source...
3-Month Course "Diagnostics and Basic Skills for the Treatment of Personality Disorders": https://eremeevalexander.tilda.ws/?ut...
Follow me on social media:
Alexander Eremeev's Telegram:
https://t.me/eremeevalexandr/
Telegram Ebаlogy:
https://t.me/eremeev_ebn/
Instagram (the social network is owned by Meta, a company recognized as extremist in the Russian Federation).
Instagram: alexandreremeev
Disclaimer
This video is for educational, professional, and original purposes and is intended primarily for psychologists, psychotherapists, and other helping professionals.
This analysis is based solely on a publicly available interview. I am not Maria Esther-Trubitsyna's treating physician, psychotherapist, or diagnostician. I have not conducted a clinical interview, psychiatric examination, or psychological testing with her, and I do not have access to her medical records.
Therefore, the video does not establish or endorse any psychiatric or psychological diagnosis.
References to borderline, histrionic, antisocial, and other personality traits are purely educational differential hypotheses: examples of what a specialist might examine during a full in-person assessment.
It is impossible to reliably determine the presence or absence of a mental disorder, substance use, intellectual disabilities, eating disorders, sexual behavioral patterns, or other medical or psychological conditions from a publicly available video recording.
Statements about motives, internal experiences, behavioral functions, and communication patterns represent my professional interpretation of the observed public material, and are not assertions of reliable facts about a person's inner life.
Individual events and circumstances mentioned by the participants in the public interviews have not been independently verified by me and are provided only in the context of the analysis of the published material.
The video is not intended for self-diagnosis or for diagnosing others. Individual traits, behavioral, sexual, emotional, or communication characteristics alone are not sufficient grounds for diagnosing a personality disorder.
The purpose of this analysis is to teach clinical observation, differential thinking, and a compassionate diagnostic stance, not to discredit, condemn, or publicly expose any individual.
#psychotherapy #psychology #diagnostics #differentialdiagnosis #personalitydisorders #BPD #histrionics #antisocialdisorder #countertransference #difficultclients #clinicalpsychology #clinicalthinking #sexuality #aggression #psychotherapist #psychologist #psychologisttraining #supervision #AlexanderEremeev