Here’s notes AND counter arguments:

THESIS:

- What if Judaism is a “constructed” religion?

- There was a Jewish community in Elephantine, Egypt in 400BC that was practicing a “pagan” version of Judaism

- At this stage they should have been following “Mose’s Torah” and Jerusalem should have been enforcing standard Judaism - but they don’t mention the Torah and Jerusalem was supportive of this group?

- “They were likely a result of Judean refugees fleeing into Egypt during the Babylonian invasions. They seem to have had no knowledge of a written Torah or the narratives described therein”

- Quite a big thing to forget! The Torah is the foundation of the religion?

- It seems a lot of the Torah was only written AFTER this? This is bizzare… was it “constructed”?

- Platonism was hugely popular at the time in Egypt, as Plato was only brand new and had spread through Alexander the Great as the “great philosopher of the World”

- The thesis is that as the Hellenic Empire founded by Alexander the Great was collapsing - Judas Maccabee led a revolt to seize the old territory of Judea

- This Judea was only ever a pagan nation, like any other, that had been consumed by great Babylon

- Judas and his lineage wanted to create a “National myth” to unite this people - so he employed the best thinkers of the time to build a religion - like a propaganda team

- These thinkers took the old pagan customs of Judea and used Plato’s ideas in the Republic to reformulate them into “Judaism” - so not “fake” but much more “constructed” than we may think

- The problem here is how much this undermines the validity of the Torah and as a consequence all three major Abrahamic religions

- Moses, the Torah, and the mighty history of the one true God might be a Platonic “noble lie” put together out of Jewish paganism in 170 BC

—-

COUNTER ARGUMENTS:

- There’s very old Egyptian Steele’s etc. apparently mentioning “Israel” granting validity to an ancient past

- The Hyksos masters of Egypt look an awful lot like “the Israelites” granting validity to the Torah

- The Dead Sea scrolls found in the 20th century revealed works like Isaiah were indeed very old!

—-

Please check out all the evidence and try to understand the subject matter!

why are all my weird separate youtube niches merging these last weeks

“Let me say something on that real quick”- gnostic informant

To hear Netenyahu in Congress and at the UN citing Moses and the Bible as Israel's justification for genocide is really appalling in the least.

Adams chances of having a chance to speak: 3 percent
Adams chances of being interrupted: 200 percent

summary of video: Neil presents facts, boyo gets mind f-ed, Adam backs neils facts with more facts and then boyo summarizes

This is the most important red pill.

Adam Green - one of our first 'original guys' on yt... and one of the last of the first wave of ' yt dissenters' to be de-platformed. don't give up Uberboyo

Adam is very patient in online conversations.

I appreciate Adam Green for not interrupting. The other two need to learn to wait their turn.

“The wise have always said the same things, and fools, who are the majority, have always done the opposite”--Schopenhauer.

Good morning, internet strangers.

On the other hand, what if gnosticism is just old abandoned Egyptian and Syriac  mystery religions painted over with a thin veneer of Christianity to give it a new legitimacy.

I want to see this conversation happening everywhere.

What caused me to not want to be a Christian any longer was telling me, an Italian by blood, that I'm no different than a sub-Saharan African or Indian—we just look different, that's all. The Pope says I have to welcome empirically, obviously disparate (behaviourally, intellectually & morally, etc.) people from all over the world to my majority European country or I'm not a true Christian—it's the gospel of Jesus. So be it: I'm not a Christian anymore!

Yo Uber, you are extremely skilled at taking a historical event that to us seems kind of foreign due to its being so far in the past, and applying modern frames of reference to it. It really helps us to understand. Just wanted to give you your props on that and thank you for offering it. The whole thing about these different ancient scriptures being like sub reddits, lol thats an amazing analogy. And comparing a hypothetical Irish vs. British, to the historical Jewish vs. Roman, is also very helpful. Good stuff man.

Yeah not here to say much but frankly an amazing collaboration

The Goyshiak is in the house too!

Posting this on a Sunday Steph, diabolical!

"The evil British wanted to steal our potatoes."😂