The horse coming to save you is neat. I love my horsey

"We didn't start nothin'."
"Yes you did."
"Well, I don't remember."

6:07 Arthur saying "get me home" sounds like Superman telling Krypto to take him home in the movie trailer.

A forgotten detail about Strauss is that despite appearing as a snake with no honor, at no point did he become disloyal to the gang. Even after being captured, and presumably tortured by the Pinkertons, he died never having said a word.

I loved that conversation with Reverend Swanson at the train station, but the conversation with the sister is irreplaceable. That was such a powerful scene and the first time this game made me cry. “I’m afraid” was delivered so beautifully, and it showed the humanity in Arthur that we rarely get to see throughout the game. He’s always quick witted, sarcastic, and a smart ass, but that was a minute of vulnerability. A man feeling death creep up on him, knowing he’s impervious to stop it, and realizing that regardless of how tough he is, mortality is still a terrifying thing that every man, woman, and child has to encounter in their lives

Kicking Strauss out is one of my favorite parts of the game because of the "You and me we ain't decent, but those folk they was" is one of the best lines in the game for Arthurs character progression.

i figured you got arrested with lenny if you get caught but "IM AN AMERICAAAAAAN" simply cannot be skipped, imma keep doint that one lol

Some of these cutscenes are things that 90%+ of the playerbase will never see. Props to Rockstar for still adding them. Always loved the insane detail in this game.

9:51 the “Sorry…” makes me feel so sad for Arthur, then the Guttural “OI” makes me happy again :)

i thought hitting the barrel was something that the game made you do, since i did it the first time i played

Very first playthrough I kept hoseas big black shire he gives Arthur…. His last whinny made me cry so damn hard😭 I loved that horse…

Also, if you meet Trelawny for the "Fine Night of Debauchery" mission with a nice suit already on, Trelawny acknowledges it but says you need something better still. I just found that out this past weekend after all these years.

bro i used my Tennessee walker since the very first mission in the oDriscoll house and whenever that cutscene happened i just broke man

21:38
John: I'm * title card plays *

There’s also different dialogue for Strauss if you have high or low honour same with the helping Sadie mission when she kills that fat guy

5:27 i love this stammering Arthur

16:40 used my black arabian horse from the start of chapter 4 up until the very end. I can tell you this cutscene BROKE ME. More emotional than the final scene for me.

12:40 You knew that if Arthur was a bad person, he would dream of a wolf instead of a deer.

20:58 John wearing that hat makes this scene so damn funny.

5:23 Arthur: nooooooo no gift