Somehow the Tudor looks nicer to me.

The Pelagos 39 is a nice watch, no doubt. But what I love so much about the classic, non-ceramic, no-date Subs, is that they are so unagitated, so simple, so obvious. There is nothing fancy,  everything has a purpose. The design is here for 70 years and the roots are even older. It is an art-deco masterpiece, an industrial design icon. The first watch in my life where I want nothing to be different. The Submariner is the big kahuna of sports watches and will always be.

No one appreciating the crispness of the video?? That was crisp and bright as hell! Thank you!

The sapphire glass on the Pelagos is far nicer, at times you simply think the glass is not there.

Just got the Pelagos two weeks ago from my AD.  Can't take it off!

Tudor looks more modern. The Rolex has the classic 1970s look. Rolex has the stronger name. Tudor has a better price value.

I like the Tudor a lot more.

pelagos 39 is more handsome

I’ve got the 124060 no date Sub and just bought the Pelagos 39. Similar watches in many ways, but different enough to make owning both worthwhile

Two amazing watches. Love the older subs. A great comparison. Thank you.

Have always wanted a 14060, but just wasnt wanting to spend quite that much for one, especially with the prices now. So recently settled on the Pelagos 39. Absolutely amazing watch and definitely has me wondering if I ever will pursue a no date sub now. Great comparison and video. Thanks.

Tudor is just so good

I got it yesterday , initially thinking of the Black Bay 58 and 54, even the 925, but once the Pelagos 39 was on my wrist … game over! I tried the BB58 and 925, nice watches but they didn’t do it for me. The Pelagos 39 may not weigh much but still feels substantial, while being appropriately sized and thin enough. It is a stunning watch that you need to see and try.

Own both and the P39 is easily my most worn.

This guy says the word champers more than any human has ever said it

Both great, but the pelagos seems to have the edge, if not quite the brand kudos.

Rolex is antic super car while P39 is brand new. I bought P39 because i had 5.000 USD limit for myself and its titanium. I buy watches for wearing not collecting. It was easier to wear since its lighter. Its my everyday watch

So pelagos 39mm is 39,7 and sub 40mm is 39,1. Makes sense like everything else in the watch community...

I love the pelagos 39 alot but it scratches so easyyyy

Pelagos is so much more legible, and cleaner