I Checked 12 Peanut Butter Brands Sold in Canada, Only 4 Passed
Peanut butter sounds simple, but do the ingredients inside Canada’s most popular jars match the promise on the front?
In this Aisle Verdict Canada investigation, Liam compares 12 peanut butter brands and varieties sold across Canada. We examine their ingredient lists, added sweeteners, added oils, sodium, protein, label clarity and price per 100 grams.
Products examined include Kraft Smooth, Kraft Only Peanuts, Jif Creamy, Skippy Creamy, No Name, Great Value, Compliments, President’s Choice, MaraNatha, Adams 100% Natural, Kirkland Signature Organic and Nuts to You.
Only four products passed every part of our strict editorial label test. One famous Canadian favourite missed the mark, while a quieter product delivered one of the strongest overall results.
In this video:
• What popular peanut butter jars actually contain
• Natural versus conventional peanut butter
• Added sugar, oils and sodium explained
• The difference between shelf price and unit value
• Why oil separation is not necessarily a defect
• The best options for simplicity, familiarity and bulk value
• Liam’s 10-second peanut butter label check
A failed verdict does not mean that a product is unsafe, fake or illegal. It means the product did not satisfy every category of our independent editorial test. Product formulations, prices and availability can change. Always verify the current Canadian package and consult a qualified professional if you require personalized dietary advice.
Subscribe to Aisle Verdict Canada and tell us which Canadian city you are watching from.
Check the label. Know the verdict.
#PeanutButter #CanadianGroceries #AisleVerdictCanada

Chapters
Adjust these timestamps after the final voiceover edit.
00:00 Not Just Peanuts?
01:25 How Our Label Test Works
02:35 Kraft Smooth
03:55 Jif Creamy
05:15 Skippy Creamy
06:35 No Name
07:55 Great Value
09:15 Compliments
10:35 President’s Choice
11:55 MaraNatha
13:20 Kraft Only Peanuts
14:45 Adams 100% Natural
16:10 Kirkland Signature Organic
17:40 Nuts to You
19:15 The Natural Peanut Butter Trade-Off
21:00 Liam’s 10-Second Label Check
22:45 The Final Verdict