Why Nobody Wants to Live in Nantucket, Massachusetts Anymore
Paul McAllister
120,068 views
Tristram Coffin bought Nantucket in 1659 for thirty pounds and two beaver hats. By the 1840s, it was the whaling capital of the world — nearly ten thousand people, three newspapers, and mansions lining Main Street built with whale-oil money. Then a spark in a hat shop stovepipe burned a third of the town to the ground, the California Gold Rush emptied the island of its young men, and petroleum killed the industry overnight. Within a generation, Nantucket went from the forty-second largest city in America to a ghost of itself.
What happened next is stranger than the rise or the fall. For nearly a century, nobody came. The population dropped below three thousand. The wharves rotted. The captain's houses sat empty, slowly weathering gray. And because no one had the money to tear anything down, the entire town was preserved — more than eight hundred pre-Civil War buildings, perfectly intact, frozen in time by poverty.
Then, in the 1960s, an heir to the S&H Green Stamps fortune named Walter Beinecke Jr. looked at those crumbling buildings and saw a product. He bought eighty percent of the downtown, restored the waterfront, and deliberately remade Nantucket into an exclusive resort — "trading up" the island, as he put it, from day-trippers to the wealthy. It worked. It worked so well that today the median home costs $3.7 million, firefighters can't afford to live there, and ninety percent of year-round residents are priced out of homeownership on the island they keep running.
This is the story of what happens when a place is saved by neglect, then destroyed by attention.
Sources:
Nathaniel Philbrick, "In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship Essex" (Penguin, 2001) and "Away Off Shore: Nantucket Island and Its People, 1602–1890" (Mill Hill Press, 1994)
John D. Warner Jr. and Maxwell King, "Walter Beinecke and the Reimagining of Nantucket" (Globe Pequot, 2023)
Nantucket Historical Association Research Library — history topics on whaling, the Great Fire of 1846, and preservation (nha.org)
Housing Nantucket / EBP Consulting, "2024 Nantucket Housing Needs Assessment" (housingnantucket.org)
Massachusetts General Court, Chapter 301 of the Acts of 2002; Commonwealth of Massachusetts Housing Snapshot: Nantucket (mass.gov)
"Development: Trading Up Nantucket," Time magazine, 1968
20 Comments
Why Nobody Wants to Live in Nantucket, Massachusetts Anymore
Paul McAllister
120,068 views
Tristram Coffin bought Nantucket in 1659 for thirty pounds and two beaver hats. By the 1840s, it was the whaling capital of the world — nearly ten thousand people, three newspapers, and mansions lining Main Street built with whale-oil money. Then a spark in a hat shop stovepipe burned a third of the town to the ground, the California Gold Rush emptied the island of its young men, and petroleum killed the industry overnight. Within a generation, Nantucket went from the forty-second largest city in America to a ghost of itself.
What happened next is stranger than the rise or the fall. For nearly a century, nobody came. The population dropped below three thousand. The wharves rotted. The captain's houses sat empty, slowly weathering gray. And because no one had the money to tear anything down, the entire town was preserved — more than eight hundred pre-Civil War buildings, perfectly intact, frozen in time by poverty.
Then, in the 1960s, an heir to the S&H Green Stamps fortune named Walter Beinecke Jr. looked at those crumbling buildings and saw a product. He bought eighty percent of the downtown, restored the waterfront, and deliberately remade Nantucket into an exclusive resort — "trading up" the island, as he put it, from day-trippers to the wealthy. It worked. It worked so well that today the median home costs $3.7 million, firefighters can't afford to live there, and ninety percent of year-round residents are priced out of homeownership on the island they keep running.
This is the story of what happens when a place is saved by neglect, then destroyed by attention.
Sources:
Nathaniel Philbrick, "In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship Essex" (Penguin, 2001) and "Away Off Shore: Nantucket Island and Its People, 1602–1890" (Mill Hill Press, 1994)
John D. Warner Jr. and Maxwell King, "Walter Beinecke and the Reimagining of Nantucket" (Globe Pequot, 2023)
Nantucket Historical Association Research Library — history topics on whaling, the Great Fire of 1846, and preservation (nha.org)
Housing Nantucket / EBP Consulting, "2024 Nantucket Housing Needs Assessment" (housingnantucket.org)
Massachusetts General Court, Chapter 301 of the Acts of 2002; Commonwealth of Massachusetts Housing Snapshot: Nantucket (mass.gov)
"Development: Trading Up Nantucket," Time magazine, 1968