OpenTube

AI vs Oscar Winning Actor (Same Scene)

Tristan Spohn

1,227,559 views

Join The Acting Lab & discover your typecast + regular feedback from me ⤵️
https://www.skool.com/the-acting-lab

Scene taken from "Meet Joe Black" 1998 starring Brad Pitt and Claire Forlani.

AI scene created using VEO 3.

Show our actors some love!

Kaden (Beginner) - Instagram: kadenjolley

Isabell (Intermediate) - Instagram: bellbit

Mateo (Intermediate) - Instagram: mateo.c.rosas

Madeleine (Pro) - Instagram: madeleinemfuruofficial

Claire Forlani (Brad Pitt Scene Partner) - Instagram: therealclaireforlani

Brad Pitt (Oscar Winner) - Instagram: bradpittofflcial

Business enquires - jamiebarclaybusiness@gmail.com

With AI getting closer and closer to real life, we've all been wondering...

..Is AI eventually going to replace actors?

So in this video I broke down the performances of AI, a beginner actor, intermediate, pro and finally an Oscar Winning Actor take on the exact same scene, to see the differences in the performances.

After watching this, let's hope we understand, what makes acting, believable.

All the actors in this video are students of my online acting school, the acting lab, if you'd like to join and get regular feedback from me, join here - https://www.skool.com/the-acting-lab

20 Comments

@TristanSpohnAKASpiderman Creator 1 year ago Pinned

Join The Acting Lab & discover your typecast + regular feedback from me ⤵
https://www.skool.com/the-acting-lab

@kadenjolley117 1 year ago

In my defense, my scene partner was a door handle

@BEC-l2f 10 months ago

The no experience guy was actually pretty good! :D

@sashangovender5327 1 year ago

the beginner with the door handle was already miles ahead of the AI.

@selene_no 9 months ago (edited)

5:40 the AI's are so awkward its hillarious

@davuvnik 1 year ago

All these tiny details showed me why some scenes really stick with you for years not knowing exactly why, but you just know they're good.

@mickael486 1 year ago

we should point out that the quality of lighting and especially the audio has a HUGE impact on being convincing. HUGE.

@kronikguyan 1 year ago

Also the movie actors are moving a lot and doing something which I think making the scene more dynamic

@A_Random_Guy_In_The_Comments 9 months ago

the part where he gets abruptly ran over after all that buildup was the most unintentionally funny thing i've ever seen in a movie

@sagevj 1 year ago

I've also noticed this weird thing in AI videos in this one AI ad that keeps playing where often their resting face is a full toothy smile. They train off posed photos so they don't really have an rbf resting face, or even a resting smile, just a full picture-day smile in resting beats

@Pro-Binge_Watcher 1 year ago

Why does it feel like the Ai actors never met eye to eye

@liamduggan5818 1 year ago

So basically AI is now at Lifetime movie level acting.

@schmo2109 8 months ago (edited)

This is the type of scene where the actors HAVE to be together to work it out. Speaking as someone who knows nothing about

@Kevin-mi2xj 1 year ago

Intermediate actors look like the training videos you have to watch at work.

@MacXpert74 1 year ago

One big difference between the original scene and the versions of the other human actors that can’t be ignored is that the original actors played together physically in the same space. Obviously it’s much easier to have a believable looking interaction if you can directly play off the responses from the other actor instead of responding to someone on a screen.

@Emobunneh 1 year ago

3:08 to be fair some do look everywhere except the person we are talking to irl 😅

@MissLBDub 8 months ago

AI will never have the urge to want to procreate physically, and that is the je ne sais quoi of it all

@kennethwisseman 11 months ago (edited)

Brad Pitt's smile actually was what made it seem real to me. Facial movements showing emotions without words tend to seem more natural than the blank stare of the A.I. just watch one of Clint Eastwood's westerns, he hardly says a thing but acts with his eyes for the most part.