If Energy Can't Be Created... Where Does it Come From?
Science Mysteries
99 views
Energy is everywhere. It powers stars, drives chemical reactions, moves planets, produces light, and fuels every process we experience. Yet one of the most fundamental rules in physics says that energy cannot simply appear from nowhere or disappear into nothing. If energy cannot be created, then where did the energy in the universe come from in the first place?
The answer becomes surprisingly complicated once we move beyond everyday physics. In ordinary physical systems, energy is transferred and transformed between different forms: chemical energy can become heat, gravitational potential energy can become motion, and mass can be converted into energy through Einstein's famous relation between mass and energy. The first law of thermodynamics provides the framework for tracking these transformations and states that the change in a system's internal energy is related to the heat transferred into it and the work done by or on it.
But asking where energy "comes from" may hide a deeper question. Energy is not necessarily a substance or a physical fluid that has to be created somewhere. In modern physics, it is a measurable quantity associated with the state and evolution of a physical system. Conservation of energy is deeply connected to the symmetries of physical laws. Through Noether's theorem, invariance under shifts in time is related to the conservation of energy.
Then the question reaches cosmology. The universe itself is expanding, spacetime is dynamic, and general relativity does not always allow us to define a single globally conserved energy for the entire expanding universe in the same straightforward way we do for an isolated laboratory system. This makes the popular question "Where did all the energy of the universe come from?" much more subtle than simply adding up the energy contained in every galaxy, star, and particle.
There is also the relationship between matter and energy. Stars shine because nuclear reactions convert small amounts of mass into other forms of energy. Particle-antiparticle interactions can transform matter into radiation, while sufficiently energetic processes can produce particles. What looks like completely different forms of physical reality can therefore be different manifestations of the same underlying accounting system.
In this documentary, we explore what energy actually means, why physicists say energy cannot be created or destroyed, how energy changes from one form to another, why mass itself can be converted into energy, what Noether's theorem reveals about conservation laws, and why the question becomes much stranger when we apply it to the entire expanding universe.
🔬 In this video:
⚡ What energy actually is in modern physics
🌌 Why energy cannot simply appear or disappear
🔄 How energy transforms between different forms
🧠 Why conservation of energy is connected to symmetry
⚛️ How mass and energy are related
☀️ Where the energy produced by stars comes from
🌠 Why the origin of the universe creates a deeper energy question
⏳ Why energy conservation becomes more subtle in an expanding universe
🔭 What physics can—and cannot—tell us about the ultimate origin of energy
Scientific references:
• Emmy Noether, “Invariante Variationsprobleme,” Nachrichten von der Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen (1918)
• Albert Einstein, “Does the Inertia of a Body Depend Upon Its Energy-Content?” Annalen der Physik (1905)
• Samuel J. Ling, William Moebs & Jeff Sanny, University Physics Volume 2 — First Law of Thermodynamics, OpenStax
• Sean M. Carroll, Spacetime and Geometry: An Introduction to General Relativity, Cambridge University Press
• Steven Weinberg, Cosmology, Oxford University Press
• Edward A. Milne, “A Newtonian Expanding Universe,” Quarterly Journal of Mathematics (1934)
Science Mysteries explores the strange questions hidden inside physics, astronomy, quantum mechanics, cosmology, and the fundamental laws that govern reality.
#ScienceMysteries #Physics #Energy #Cosmology
2 Comments
If Energy Can't Be Created... Where Does it Come From?
Science Mysteries
99 views
Energy is everywhere. It powers stars, drives chemical reactions, moves planets, produces light, and fuels every process we experience. Yet one of the most fundamental rules in physics says that energy cannot simply appear from nowhere or disappear into nothing. If energy cannot be created, then where did the energy in the universe come from in the first place?
The answer becomes surprisingly complicated once we move beyond everyday physics. In ordinary physical systems, energy is transferred and transformed between different forms: chemical energy can become heat, gravitational potential energy can become motion, and mass can be converted into energy through Einstein's famous relation between mass and energy. The first law of thermodynamics provides the framework for tracking these transformations and states that the change in a system's internal energy is related to the heat transferred into it and the work done by or on it.
But asking where energy "comes from" may hide a deeper question. Energy is not necessarily a substance or a physical fluid that has to be created somewhere. In modern physics, it is a measurable quantity associated with the state and evolution of a physical system. Conservation of energy is deeply connected to the symmetries of physical laws. Through Noether's theorem, invariance under shifts in time is related to the conservation of energy.
Then the question reaches cosmology. The universe itself is expanding, spacetime is dynamic, and general relativity does not always allow us to define a single globally conserved energy for the entire expanding universe in the same straightforward way we do for an isolated laboratory system. This makes the popular question "Where did all the energy of the universe come from?" much more subtle than simply adding up the energy contained in every galaxy, star, and particle.
There is also the relationship between matter and energy. Stars shine because nuclear reactions convert small amounts of mass into other forms of energy. Particle-antiparticle interactions can transform matter into radiation, while sufficiently energetic processes can produce particles. What looks like completely different forms of physical reality can therefore be different manifestations of the same underlying accounting system.
In this documentary, we explore what energy actually means, why physicists say energy cannot be created or destroyed, how energy changes from one form to another, why mass itself can be converted into energy, what Noether's theorem reveals about conservation laws, and why the question becomes much stranger when we apply it to the entire expanding universe.
🔬 In this video:
⚡ What energy actually is in modern physics
🌌 Why energy cannot simply appear or disappear
🔄 How energy transforms between different forms
🧠 Why conservation of energy is connected to symmetry
⚛️ How mass and energy are related
☀️ Where the energy produced by stars comes from
🌠 Why the origin of the universe creates a deeper energy question
⏳ Why energy conservation becomes more subtle in an expanding universe
🔭 What physics can—and cannot—tell us about the ultimate origin of energy
Scientific references:
• Emmy Noether, “Invariante Variationsprobleme,” Nachrichten von der Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen (1918)
• Albert Einstein, “Does the Inertia of a Body Depend Upon Its Energy-Content?” Annalen der Physik (1905)
• Samuel J. Ling, William Moebs & Jeff Sanny, University Physics Volume 2 — First Law of Thermodynamics, OpenStax
• Sean M. Carroll, Spacetime and Geometry: An Introduction to General Relativity, Cambridge University Press
• Steven Weinberg, Cosmology, Oxford University Press
• Edward A. Milne, “A Newtonian Expanding Universe,” Quarterly Journal of Mathematics (1934)
Science Mysteries explores the strange questions hidden inside physics, astronomy, quantum mechanics, cosmology, and the fundamental laws that govern reality.
#ScienceMysteries #Physics #Energy #Cosmology
“One of the strangest questions in modern physics is could the vacuum itself contain energy.” That tells us that modern physics is still in the dark ages. Physics has not acknowledged the vacuum except to give it a name and deny its role. Physics permits quantum fields and energy states associated with particles while it still denies Universe as a whole when it denies the participation of its largest part.
It is ironic that the world of objects began examination with the observations of the macro scale and over centuries that led to the micro and quantum world. The unfathomable mystery of the vacuum of Space is only examined from what is generated from quantum mechanics. For physics, the Vacuum of Space is the macro-mystery as the world of objects was the micro-mystery. We need Faraday back to do experiments on the macro-vacuum to help find the laws defining it. Now speculation on alterations about what is observed rules and observations can be ignored.
The start of Universe is when the world of objects did not exist, but it did all begin when it seems only the Energy of Space was available and in command. The initial energy was a necessary imbalance. The world of Universe only receives energy from outside itself if Universe existence is denied beyond the world of objects. The vacuum of Space is observed to go beyond the limits of three dimensions and time. Dirac, Dyson, and Schrödinger have shown that Universe works with complex numbers, not real numbers.
The physical system denies non-physical existence. Both sides are only energy. Gravity also resides within the void of Space, but physics does not know it.