This is the kind of in-depth book review I have been waiting for. Things like sequencing, pairing, and other editing choices are often most discussed (rightly so as well because they are what generally makes or breaks a book), but having all the technical knowledge explained by someone who is a book publisher helps lift the veil for those of us who are very distant from that world and understand it. I can't thank you enough for doing what you are doing!

It's rare to see a review as thorough a this, it really brings to light some of the complexities of producing a photo book. Thanks for the insightful analysis, I look forward to seeing more videos like this.

I really appreciate this. I previously didn’t have the understanding or words to explain why I did or didn’t vibe with a photo book. I see how important sequencing your photos can be.

I could watch book reviews, this in depth, all day. I’ve always enjoyed your IG. very happy I now have this content to enjoy as well.

Thank you for such insightful review. I learn something about sequencing and designs. I discovered Todd Hido's work a few decades ago and love his work since. This latest book doesn't live up to his previous work, especially House Hunting which put him on the map. Being a well received artist such as Todd, you are expected to produce something at a timely manner even though you weren't quite ready. Fortunately, he has paid his dues, anything he put forth thereafter will be noticed.

This was great. I love this book, I feel like it gets better with more viewings.
I interpreted the smaller images as sprinklings of nostalgia of memories lost - or soon to be lost; contrasted with the bleak landscapes of the world this felt representative of the book title.
Very keen to see more book reviews!

Fantastic review Noah. It's given me a different perspective on how photobooks should be organized and how different choices can impact the viewer in interesting ways. I can see this YouTube channel quickly becoming my new favorite. See you in the next one.

This was awesome! Really enjoyed your thoughts on the book.

great review insightful thank you you seem to emphasize the need for differences (contrasts) but disparage similarity, which can be used as a narrative device (time, space, continuity, progress) you did not note the inclusion of hanging tires from a tree after a bleak landscape, a sequence that confuses me also the presence of a horse again shows some “stoppage” (domesticity, with the absence of other horses which pack might symbolize “wildness”) finally for me is the question whether the photos individually, and as wholes (sections, the entire book), “live up to” (how or how not, and in what ways) the book’s dramatic title i learned much from your presentation and comments on production etc look forward to seeing tons of these vids from you!

Love book reviews like this. I’ve got this book but great to find additional details and insight that I didn’t know

Thank you for this thoughtful review! Not only did I enjoy the book preview but I learned so much about photo book making in general. I print my projects using MILK photobooks - editions 1 of 1 - only for myself. But I like to make the books as if they are for readers. Great advice about the interaction between pictures, the design elements like margins and covers and end papers, and the entire concept of flow. Please - keep going. I’m so grateful for the inspiration!

Excellent review. I'm a huge fan of Todd Hido.

Great Review and first full video.

Awesome review, thank you! A lot of fun to watch and listen

Ahh, this is an excellent review! As a huge lover and collector of photobooks, I hope there are many more reviews on the way! Subscribed 😁🤟🏼

Great visual ananlysis and insights

Excellent review! I really like the insights on the photo sequencing and pairing, as well as observations about the physical qualities of the book. Looking forward to more book reviews, thanks.

This was excellent. The details on printing methods, layout choices, materials, and how this book fits in with Hido's other work add so much to this review. I own a copy of this book, and feel that dimensionally it's too big. Looking forward to more these videos!

would love to see you review In Between Worlds, Harry Gruyaert

I really enjoyed your professional review. I self-publish on Blurb amateur photo books of family adventures. Next time, I will review your reviews to refresh my understanding of how photos are meant to "talk" to each other. Thought-provoking and helpful. I subscribed. Thanks.