Great theory! Also, I didn’t realize that Jacks last name was Skellington. I thought it was Skeleton. 🤦‍♀️

I wish they did more stop motion with different stories, the haunted mansion holiday is fantastic

Thanks YouTube, now I'm down a rabbit hole

“Hm I wonder who this sailor may be i would like to meet them while they’re alive. Wait… we both have Jack S in our names, we love hand gestures, could it be..? Probably not!”

My favorite character is Zero. Great theory! I like the pirate one the most.

My theory is that Jack died in a fire in a pumpkin patch.

I believe he was an intimidating pirate and I believe since he is known for England and French it would explain why boogie boogie couldn't beat him before he probably became a pirate it would also make sense if he was a Soldier or a Knight

OU! That connection with James and the Giant Peach is a really interesting theory. Great video! I had forgotten about James and the Giant Peach until you mentioned in your Easter Egg video.

Now I know this is going to sound really bad but I have never actually seen Nightmare Before Christmas, but I think it looks really cool. I need to get on that. Perhaps I'll watch it this weekend or next weekend.

I hope you are having a great day!

A very well thought out theory. Very plausible, and i wouldn't mind if it were the official theory. Great work as always! Jack is my favourite character from the film.

I remember when I saw James and the Giant Peach in theaters. When I saw Jack Skellington it blew my 7year old mind!

He was indeed Jack Sparrow before death.

This truly boggles me to know there is connections that aren’t explained but honestly If Jack Skellington had the choice to choose between the seven holidays in the American tradition there must be an explanation to why maybe at he first came in a boat as a pirate when he was from England in the corpse bride when he Was alive and as was James coming from England himself to go to New York so jacks motive had always been to want to steal something Has he tried to steal Christmas However it would only make sense that it had been in the past because In James timeline New York had already been constructed so The multi versus had been touched together in some particular point, it’s cool to know other people caught that instance in the movie as well!! Your video is great!✨ thanks for giving the opportunity for Disney lovers to share with you

I would love a cg spin-off of the nightmare before Christmas

Tim burton was a generational genius

Once I saw that part in James and the giant peach I thought the pirate skeleton was Jack and I thought to myself.. why doesn't he talk? I figured if the skeleton talked we would be able to tell if it's Jack or not

my theory is he's Jack O' Lantern.  the trickster of Halloween cursed with undeath after tricking the devil

I do like both the headless horseman idea and the pirate idea. I’m thinking that Jack Skellington is the Headless Horseman. They both can take off their head, both are dead spirits, both are infamous for being the most scariest of monsters, the song in the Disney film of Ichabod and Mr. Toad says stuff about “When the spooks have a midnight jamboree” and how the headless horseman “is a fright on Halloween night”, and we see Jack’s first appearance as wearing a pumpkin as a head and riding a wooden horse which looks very similar to the headless horseman. Or that he could be a pirate because the pirate captain in James and The Giant Peach is literally just Jack as a pirate, I mean it’s clear as day. I would say he could have been a pirate and the Headless horseman at the same time or he could have been a pirate and the headless horseman was his uncle or father or grandfather or whatever. Or vice versa

I remember in James and the Giant Peach he was the pirate in the sunken ship when the centipede went to go get the compass

Or he could be jack from titanic lol jk oof...very great theory and vid thx,also my favorite character from nightmare before christnas is probably the boogie man XD.

This is the best theorie I’ve heard yet!!