Man, the visceral creepiness of that intro, not even the serial killer stuff, but just being a woman trying to get somewhere alone in a city at night. Complete with gross comments and creepy guy.

Hands-down scariest part of this game...? That someone would be barefoot in that bathroom.😲😩

“Who enjoys life that much?”

I feel that.

Killer: commits gruesome murder
John: he's naked !

I’m more interested in the creepy guy on the bus. He just seems so set apart from all the other characters that it feels like he will be a villain in a future game.

The 180⁰ from laughing at porn to being caught coming out of the XXX section by PeePaw is so funny.
John's soft gasp while saying "peepªw" :0 18:07

The sequel is gonna be called Blooddry

The call girl is hilarious. It's my favorite part of the game hands down.

studette

The references to Skifreak, Tonight It Follows (at PeePaw’s) and Babysitter Bloodbath (in the Urban Legends comic) make me wish for a Puppet Combo Cinematic Universe.

"Smells like a society built on waste."

John: "okay joker..."
I died at this lol

The voice acting was pretty good in this,  I loved the game.

I like how slashers are revealed to be only human yet have super human strength and durability. Tragic backstory = can lift a guy off his feet one-handed and cut through bone and muscle like it is a literal piece of cake.

John should host a "red is scary" game jam

There is something about puppet combo games that i cant get enough of. Even though its pixelated, they manage to create SUCH an amazing atmosphere, i find myself rewatching playthroughs all the time.

I just love the sheer number of "This is definitely the killer" characters at you in the begining. Quick, guess the killer!

I watched 8BitRyan and ManlyBadassHero both play this and John is the ONLY one that sang the number and I'm unbelievably relieved someone finally did

I really enjoy how run down and dirty the environment feels in this game. Reminds me a lot of the city in Night Ripper.

Sara lamenting how boring Liam is with sex was really unexpected lol. Though it makes me like her even more.

Imagine just dying and someone says "eh nothing of value was lost"

I found that bus interaction at 9:19 to be the creepiest part of the game for me. something about the timing, his request to sit beside, and the dialogue gave me a visceral "gtfo" reaction

There is something extremely familiar about this game; Some game John has played years ago with a near identical start involving a woman, ranting about her idiot man and worrying he won't prove up to being a father, carrying out mundane chores in a ratty apartment. The sense of Deja-vu is honestly more creepy than the story itself.