OpenTube

Officer in Charge Describes Serving the Restraining Order on Kelsey Fitzsimmons

Justice Is A Process!!!!

7,635 views

Three officers went to a fellow officer's home to serve a restraining order and take her baby. One of them shot her.

Lt. Sean Daly is the man who planned every detail of that afternoon. Twenty-year veteran of the North Andover Police Department. He handpicked the officers, briefed the team, and led them into Kelsey

Fitzsimmons's home on June 30, 2025. Fitzsimmons was a patrol officer on maternity leave, four months postpartum, home with her infant son. Daly hired her. He trained her for six months. And on this day, he was there to serve her a restraining order obtained by her fiance, seize her firearms, and hand her baby to the man who filed against her.

Watch what happens when defense attorney Tim Bradl gets his turn. He forces Daly to confront his own prior statement about where the gun was found. He reveals what Justin Aylaian told officers at the station before they ever walked through that door. And he ends with one question about who the department sent a mental health officer for after the shooting. It wasn't Kelsey.

---

WATCH WITH JUSTICE

0:00 to 2:12 - Judge sets the ground rules on witness sequestration. No watching the livestream, no rebroadcasts. He wants testimony from memory, not from screens.

2:12 to 9:09 - Daly walks through the planning. How Justin showed up at the station, how Daly selected Noonan and Houston, how they staged near the house without being seen.

9:09 to 16:43 - Inside the home. Fitzsimmons answers the door holding her baby. She's calm. She cooperates. She hands Noonan her baby and a bottle. Pay attention to what that says about her state of mind toward the man she allegedly tried to kill minutes later.

16:43 to 23:56 - Everything changes. Daly hears Noonan shout from upstairs. Two gunshots. He runs up the stairs and finds Fitzsimmons on the floor with a gunshot wound. Listen to what she says.

24:19 to 49:47 - Legal battles. The defense objects to hearsay. The prosecution tries to get Noonan's post-shooting statement in as an excited utterance. The judge's ruling here matters.

1:11:08 to 1:42:17 - Cross-examination. This is where the testimony turns. Bradl confronts Daly on the gun's location, reveals Justin's inflammatory statement about the baby, and exposes every procedural gap in the department's response.

---

COMPLETE CASE COVERAGE
justiceisaprocess.com

SUBSCRIBE for daily trial coverage and hit the notification bell so you never miss testimony.

JOIN to unlock the Case Notebook powered by NotebookLM, where you can chat with the evidence, ask questions about the testimony, and go deeper than any comment section allows.

CASE BACKGROUND REPORT:
https://www.justiceisaprocess.com/ma-...
Complete case overview including charges, timeline, key players, constitutional issues, and legal analysis for Commonwealth v. Fitzsimmons.

PLAYLISTS AND RESOURCES

Website: https://www.justiceisaprocess.com/ma-...
Full Trial Live Broadcasts: LIVE BROADCAST: MA v. Kelsey Fitzsimmons
No Breaks Edition: NO BREAKS EDITION: MA v. Kelsey Fitzsimmons
Trial Analysis Podcast: PODCAST: MA v. Kelsey Fitzsimmons
Key Moments and Testimony: KEY MOMENTS AND TESTIMONY: MA v. Kelsey Fi...
Subscribe for Daily Coverage: @justiceisaprocess

FAIR USE AND EDUCATIONAL PURPOSE

This content is produced under Fair Use (17 U.S.C. 107) for news reporting, criticism, and educational purposes. We provide transformative commentary on public court proceedings, advancing public understanding of the judicial process through timestamps, analysis, and educational context.

#JusticeIsAProcess #FitzsimmonsTrial #KelseyFitzsimmons

20 Comments

@JusticeIsAProcess Creator 6 months ago Pinned

Kelsey Fitzsimmons handed her baby to Officer Noonan. She gave him the bottle. He fed her child. Minutes later, he shot her. Today the officer in charge of the whole operation took the stand, and what the defense pulled out of him on cross-examination is the kind of testimony that changes how you see everything that happened in that house.

💭 If she trusted Noonan enough to hand him her baby, do you believe she pointed a gun at him minutes later?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMMv_7h0gZY

Timestamps for every key moment are in the description. Full case coverage at justiceisaprocess.com

@HP-ru6rf 6 months ago

In all due fairness to the defendant, she was 4 months postpartum. Her baby was born 5 weeks early. She was already back at work. She had to work due to her financial situation. I cannot even fathom all that she was dealing with, especially after given birth early. Then she was completely blindsided at her home. My heart goes out to her.

@sojourner47 6 months ago

It’s 2026 but the cops don’t use body cameras. How convenient for dirty cops.

@LindaClif 6 months ago

And why would they allow the father there considering theres a protectikn order

@sojourner47 6 months ago

Officer in charge knows nothing. What an ignorant guy Can’t answer a simple question.

@lewisgamer9850 6 months ago

The lieutenant is such a liar!!!! Everytime he lies he uses his hands to talk. Body language is everything guys

@SewSheGoes 6 months ago

I’m thinking Noonan freaked out and fired at her. Then fired again to silence her, because his mistake would be questioned.

@davidbenderman3134 6 months ago

He ran like the coward he is . If my son was where i heard gun fire coming from. I would have ran to my son.

@SewSheGoes 6 months ago

So you put a person on trial who never fired a shot? And where’s the officer who injured the defendant?! Bet he has an interesting story about it.

@OurNextChapterSmiths 6 months ago

No one seemed to be in a hurry getting her to Hosp.

@FLo-jc7ig 6 months ago

FACT: Everytime a witness starts talking with their "hands", you absolutely know they are "lying"!!! EVERYTIME!!!

@ANDY-G321 6 months ago

It seems the prosecutor’s only line of attack on the defense was that, given Officer Pat Noonan’s vast experience, he couldn’t possibly make such a mistake. But in my lifetime, I’ve seen officers with twice his experience commit far worse errors than accidentally shooting a fellow officer. To me, this looks like an officer who overreacted, couldn’t manage the situation—an apparent suicide attempt—and, in that panic, drew his gun and shot her. Now, he’s in denial, trying to protect himself....I hope she gets millions on her nasty lawsuit....

@tinamarlow506 6 months ago

Hopefully the judge sees through the defense and justice will be served

@ReptilesGeniales 5 months ago

How can the supervisor know nothing at all?!

@eddiepaid6108 5 months ago (edited)

Its crazy how easy it is to get a court order and ruin someone life. I wouldn't want to live in that town 😂😂

@Jewels1960 6 months ago (edited)

Just started this trial & honestly I know nothing about it. So far I think she’s innocent. Talk about ganging up on a new mother, it’s BS

@wendiburrows2272 6 months ago

This guy is clueless. Supposed to have 20 years experience and has literally no idea of procedure. I believe Kelsey at this point. Why did they need 3 officers to serve a restraining order?

@davidbenderman3134 6 months ago

And this my friends are exactly why cop's don't want to wear body cameras. So they can lie and cover up any wrong doing by themselves or other cops involved. If no video is there they can just make up what they want. To fit what lies they tell. Remember this is exactly why most police departments still doesn't have body cameras.