to answer multiple comments: yes, any and all of you are allowed to use this for ocs or fanfictions EDIT: or roleplays thats fine too

“I’ve been pregnant for several years”

“You should probably stop”

I would’ve guessed Firestar’s impact as a leader when he started out as a kittypet would permanently rid the bias the clan cats have over outsiders. Sadly, Bramblestar seemed to have hit the reset button on foreign cat acceptance outside a brief relationship with one in his Super Edition.

So just take all of Tigerstar 1.0’s ideas and remove the racism?

It’s stupid that StarClan wants them to be separate when Squirrelflight’s Hope showed us that StarClan is peaceful because they don’t separate themselves

At first I was UNSURE!! and AGAINST!! the idea of all the clans morphing into one MEGA clan but honestly, I love your interpretation of it!! I'd definitely accept this version of clan smushing 100%

Tigerstar: we should combine the clans
Me: no that's evil
Moonkitti: we should combine the clans
Me: that I perfectly logical and I agree

edit: ok I get it, it's the differences between presentation. you can stop commenting this to me now

The thing that always annoyed me in the books was how the clans would go into other clans territory when they were starving or lacking certain resources as a "last resort" as if the territories were the only places they could go and traveling into unclaimed land just past the border was more dangerous than potentially starting a war.

Firestar only joined because he didn’t want to lose his balls.

I want them to celebrate things. Like, literally all human cultures ever have celebrations and since warriors are humanized they should have celebrations. I know this is weird and doesn't really effect the story but they don't have fun and their lives just seem bleak.

I can already imagine how this would create more interesting plots. Imagine a murder mystery arc, where a messenger is found dead on the border between two clans. The series would be about trying to figure out who killed them, and why? Why would you want to cut off clan communication? Much more interesting than “omg they’re hunting on my lawn again!!1!1!”

''In the end, Tigerstar was right''


agreed

Lesson learned: StarClan sucks, Tigerstar was (half) right

“You make me uncomfortable, therefore, yOu ArE nOw A mEdIcInE cAt “
0:23

One of the things I like about Wings Of Fire is that the tribes are actually different, Icewings have the ranking and the trial, the old RainWing tribe had the queen system and the anonymous eggs, etc, and just overall the culture and feeling seems different from one another

"Despite being of a human level intelligence, the cats somehow don't have the level of thought required to separate religion from morality."

That's probably the most realistic thing I've ever heard about Warrior Cats. Humans can't seem to get it right either.

Please can we stop making Tigerstar clones I want them gone

If Messengers needed to be on call all the time, there's no reason why they couldn't take on small jobs in camp as well. Helping the medicine cats sort herbs, repairing and creating dens, and entertaining kits are all things they could do while still being available in camp to run to the next Clan at a moment's notice.

It's funny that Starclan basically begs the clans to stay as clans when they all have one collective unit. Why would they want these cats who are very capable of coexisting as shown in the great journey arc to stay apart? Saying "well the friends you made will be yr friend when you get to Starclan :)" doesn't cut it because by the time they DO die they will probably not even like each other anymore

honestly the warrior clans are basically just devolved ethnostates
1. Extreme Inbreeding
2. Irrational disdain towards other, near identical groups
3. Extreme xenophobia and cultural imperialism