i think you guys are committing too hard on the 'kpop hater' part. while i understand everyone has opinions and critique, i think nit-picking on almost everything is too much because it distracts you from fully appreciating the songs.
few things i want to mention:
I strongly disagree with not needing 2 vocalist. very stupid critism and it was where I stopped taking anything you guys said seriously. Both vocalist are SO talented, their range is insane. their harmonies are so beautiful as well. again if you guys stopped trying to nit-pick, you would fully appreciate the need of BOTH vocalists.

The boys write, compose and arrange all their songs which is badass. their lyrics are insanely poetic, yall should read the lyrics too. it just adds so much more depth and appreciation while you're listening.

ALL of them contribute to their music. not just Giuk. they all play more than one instrument. they all know how to write some really good lyrics. each member also composes their own instrumentals and they then arrange them together. so to say Giuk is the only redeeming thing is quite insulting to be honest. they all contribute equally and they're all just as talented.

This one is more of an opinion but Star is actually one of my favourite mvs aesthetically wise. It’s one of their most beautiful mvs in my opinion. its nothing over the top but its still simply beautiful. again if you had read the lyrics, you'll probably appreciate the mvs more same goes with rain to be.

I probably have more to say but i stopped watching after rain to be. i hope you guys do more appreciating and less nit-picking if yall were to  ever further explore onewe.

im sorry but why even bother having a whole channel reacting to kpop groups if you have an issue with the fact that more than just one member singing??so weird

Yikes the hater on the left was so hard to watch and listen to. You can tell he was not interested in any of this from start to end. No need to like kpop/kbands but don't discredit their talents because you are so closed minded to a new genres that is not your own. We respect your opinion but try to let loose and actually try to appreciate the song, message they are trying to express. Not everything has to be in your face, hard hitting, etc.. Thank you to the guy on the right for being more respectful.

wow the dude on the left is just constantly putting down the other members "giuk is the only creative force in the group" "he's the one redeeming part" like what??? . It's okay if you don't like the song but being rude to the members is not even "criticism", just hate. You're living up to your video title.

Onewe is a lot for people to get. I absolutely love them. For their simplicity. They have such a different sound than any other kpop group. Fun fact: the keyboard player has a twin brother in the group Oneus!

For people who haven't watched this yet, they're ACTUALLY serious about the "kpop hater" part. Just be ready for some hate disguised as criticism and extremely biased opinions.

honestly i disagree with you on the multiple vocalists thing, personally i always liked it even outside of kpop because i get bored of hearing the same persons voice for an entire song, even if i love their voice. i like hearing a switch up and i like the multiple members for that reason. idk it just feels more dynamic to me. sure personalities are good too but i like how it sounds

ONEWE BEST BAND! AURORA BEST SONG EVER AND YONGHOON BEST VOCALIST EVER!!!

was so excited to watch an hour long onewe reaction video but to be honest I am disappointed
didn't expect 2 haters, thought it was hater/fan reaction as the thumbnail suggests lol
also it felt to me like the hater that pretends to be a fan (on the right) is just seeking approval or smth from his friend on the left, the actual hater, so that's why he aagrees on a lot of things he says, sometimes tries to be harsher than the hater etc
giuk is indeed very talented and one of the driving forces of the group but so are the other ones
star - yonghoon is one of the main creators (the other one is their company's producer)
beautiful ashes - yonghoon, giuk
aurora, rain to be, parting- kanghyun
at first I tried my best to be understanding of ur position, but u nitpick way too much
thought it was just me - nope, other commenters think so too
"multiple vocalists is a business choice, dude just play the keyboard" - onewe are self formed, the roles were assigned to them by themselves from the start, before they joined rbw company
sometimes u talked about cohesiveness, then u demand the standard guitar this keyboard this - they choose when it's time for a simple guitar chord progression or a simple solo and when the more complex thing fits the song
also the same goes about "checking the boxes" - they do what fits, for example sometimes giuk doesn't rap cuz it wouldn't fit

If I can give you one advice, the "hater" needs to tone down his hatred, no one is going to stick with this channel if you keep this unpleasant and unnecessary attitude. Even his expression while watching the MVs make it clear he has a biased opinion from the start that he doesnt want to let go of. It seems like he's not able to understand that people have different tastes and not everything is about him. You ate totally allowed to dislike something, but there is no need to be disrespectful to it or any of the members. The guy on the right is a lot more respectful and easy to listen to, even when he doesn't like the song.

I'm really into onewe these days

If you want more Yonghoon vocals then check out their songs A Book In Memory and Reminisce About All(their debut song) cuz he sings the majority of the time in those 2 songs.. And if you want more variety then the 5 songs yall listened to then check out their songs Veronica, End Of Spring, Gravity and Montage.

Thanks for giving Onewe a listen. In my opinion, it was unfortunate that all of these songs were very similar. I would have liked you to hear 04, Montage, Gravity or End of Spring for some contrast.

I love Onewe and I always will. Yonghoon is my fav vocalists

The whole "I dont get it" is bacause you are not Korean, you are thinking from and American perspective. The Korean fans will go ape shit if their favorite member doesn't get enough lines and screen time. So for title tracks they try and please all the fans the B sides is where all groups have their best music. Also bands are not very popular in Korea so they try and put popular ideas from popular songs to br seen more.

I'm preparing myself to hear hate to my beloved parting ... I'll see if I can watch this to the end lol

Onewe is from the same company as Mamamoo

I’m sure someone probably already recommended ONEWE’s idol brother group — ONEUS but I just thought this was a nice little tidbit about both groups because I was lowkey gagged when I found this out: Dongmyeong has a twin brother, Xion, who is a member of ONEUS. He’s the eldest twin. Just thought I’d share that since it’s always nice seeing siblings sometimes under the same label or even in the same group!

I’m not a huge fan of ONEWE or anything but I always thought they had a ton of potential that hasn’t been tapped into yet. Great video as always even if I disagree about Rain To Be which is honestly, one of my favorites of theirs alongside Gravity. Much love ❤

I appreciate the honesty, even though I don't agree with the commentary. I think the main problem with this video is that this band has a ton of songs, all with different assets, solos, singing styles, since all of them are involved in the composition process, and you're only listening to 4, so you need to have in mind that these 4 songs don't define the band, you talk as if you know the band from only listening to these, and I don't think it's fair. Also, I think you can dislike something and still be very respectful about it, the "hater" guy just seems bitter about everything, he's clearly not open to anything that's different from what he likes, it's just really unpleasant to listen to him, why make reactions to anything if you are clearly not open to understanding it???

ONEWE is amazing to listen to.  Such talent.