Thanks very much for starting a campaign game! I've been trying to figure out how a campaign works and your play through was a helpful beginning. I'll definitely be watching your next play through.  As you experienced in this game, all but one of my wins have been races to the end and I would have lost if I'd had to count traumas again! I have a couple comments that I hope are helpful. They're not meant as criticism.  (And many kudos to you for playing under the pressure of knowing that others will be watching!)

At 8:03 you commented that you would need to discard 3 cards. Perhaps I heard wrong, or maybe you meant discard down to 3 cards? As you noted later, you're allowed to have 3 cards in your hand at the end of Sunset. Because the Food Shortage card went into your skill set, you would have only needed to discard 1 card. But sailing was a good thing.

At 13:40, 30:08 and 50:30 you should have gained a Morale card due to having an Encounter. At 56:40 you should have gained 2 Morale cards for the Encounter. These would have helped your steadily draining Morale deck a lot.

At 42:45 there were 5 skulls, not 4, but you still would have been fine because if your Ignore skill.

At 49:56 you could have sailed directly upward for 2 navigation points, then to the right onto an island encounter for 3 navigation points. That would have enabled you to spend fewer overall navigation points and get rid of the Old Witch one turn sooner.

Thanks again for the play through!