Tbh this makes sense- a girl who hopelessly stalks a person bc she was deprived of attention… and Adrien, who is very kind and humble, makes sense because he lives the best life and is popular.
What about a theory where it's fully reverse like adriens family owns a little sewing shop whilst marinettes family owns a big food/pastery corporation. And adrien became Mr bug and mari lady noire
You are forgetting a very important thing here. Like Adrien, she would b be a senti monster and be obedient towards her father. I think she would be like Adrien if she was created from the peacock miraculous plus Gabriel would have the rings to control her.
Man i finally see some good developments this almost got me to tear up it truly is peak and honestly i would like to see a part 2 of this one and what if chat noir was the one chosen as a guardian and i don't even ask for you to do it too quickly take it slowly and make the story better