New York vs. St. Johns County, FL: The REAL Cost of Moving South (2026)

Cathleen Cornish - REALTOR®️

Cathleen Cornish - REALTOR®️

457 views

📲 Thinking about relocating to St. Johns County? I help families move from states like New York every single day — reach out anytime:
🌐 movingwithcat.com
📧 cat@movingwithcat.com

Thinking about relocating from New York to Florida? 🌴 In this video, I'm giving you the real, honest comparison between New York and St. Johns County, FL — no sugarcoating, just what you actually need to know before you make the move.

I cover:
🏫 Schools — what the A-rating does and doesn't tell you
💰 Cost of living — insurance, taxes, and the CDD fees no one explains
🏡 Real estate — what your money actually buys here vs. NYC
🌊 Lifestyle — the pace-of-life shift most New Yorkers don't expect

I'm Cathleen Cornish, a St. Johns County native and local real estate agent who's helped families relocate here from New York and beyond. My goal with every video is to give you the real picture — the wins AND the trade-offs — so you can make a confident, informed decision about your move.

⏱️ TIMESTAMPS
00:36 Intro
01:15 Pace of Life & Culture Shift
03:10 Real Estate: NYC vs. St. Johns County
06:01 Cost of Living: Taxes & Insurance
09:21 Schools, Amenities & Community