OpenTube

Brewing Legend Exposes the Truth About Craft Beer

Doug Piper

55,332 views

Dr. Charlie Bamforth on Beer’s Four Essentials: Water, Malt, Hops, Yeast—and the Power of Balance
At Sierra Nevada’s Asheville brewery in Mills River, North Carolina, Doug Piper meets up again with renowned brewing scientist Dr. Charlie Bamforth, whose 40-year career spans research at Bass in the UK and teaching at UC Davis. Bamforth argues that amid flashy trends and gimmicky brewing, great beer still depends on mastering the essentials—malt, hops, yeast, and water—while prioritizing balance, consistency, and respect for the customer and fellow brewers. He recounts Bass’s rigorous quality standards for beers like Carling and cask Bass, explains how water must be controlled for a consistent ionic profile and free of off-tastes, calls malt the “soul” of beer, warns against hop character overwhelming a thin base, and emphasizes yeast health and fermentation consistency. The episode closes as Bamforth marks his final chapter with Sierra Nevada. This Charlie Bamforth interview a great discussion that captures not only Sierra Nevada's brewing's techniques, but craft brewing industry secrets.

This Charlie Bamforth interview discusses "beer balance" with deep dives into "IBU versus Balance".

Chapters:
00:00 Meet the Sultan of Suds
01:12 Bass Brewing and Quality
04:32 No Gimmicks Just Tradition
04:47 Rice in Budweiser Gimmicky?
05:06 Water Makes Consistency
05:25 What Makes Bass Ale Iconic?
08:34 Malt the Soul of Beer
10:58 Balance Defines Great Beer
11:41 Greatest Beers Share This
17:08 Hops Character Not Hype
18:09 What's Lost When Bitterness is the Star?
21:42 Pellet vs Whole Cone Hops
22:31 Yeast the Real Brewer
24:47 Respect and Craft Values
30:38 Final Toast and Farewell

20 Comments

@DougPipersr Creator 2 months ago (edited) Pinned

New - https://youtu.be/CzvT3UtBEXE - 51-min Masterclass version (20-min new content)

@tutucox 4 months ago

here in my country every craft beer taste like double hop. i like to drink the germans , because i find then diverse and full of flavour

@MarkCerson 3 months ago

Totally agree with so much in this interview-here in Canada we know we have a world wide reputation for great beers in a range from heavy stouts to hoppy IPA'S, but a good beer to one person is not drinkable by another, and neither is wrong, just different. What I really enjoyed in this interview is that a brewery, no matter the size should have a goal of consistently making the same beer, that is the mark of a great craft brewery. Beers are becoming more regional, the way it used to be. We should want to taste every kind of beer available but know we can come home to our favourite is key too.

@rudolfecker7691 4 months ago

And then Coors took over Bass... Originally, the whole Bass workforce cleaned the brewery from top to bottom every Friday. Coors said it was only necessary to clean the brewery once a month. Within a couple of months Bass Red label draught couldn't be made at their Burton Brewery and they had to license the manufacturer to a rival, Marstons in Burton. I know all this to be true as I lived in the Burton area at the time.

@garlicchefkengarlicchefken416 3 months ago

As a college freshman, I hated beer. The smell, the taste, the headache.
But that's because all I knew was Budweiser or Miller.
Then I discovered Samuel Smith's Nut brown ale & oatmeal stout.
I was hooked, bought 'The Joy of Homebrewing'.
and started Homebrewing like crazy.
10 years later, I'm brewing commercialy on a 15 Bbl Peter Austin Brewing System.
This is a great video.

@notoverlyacerbic9574 4 months ago

The interview that I didn’t know I needed..
What a great talk that was..
Balance is what many of the huge massive craft beers are missing..
Last night I was enjoying a Guinness Foreign Extra Stout ,which is pretty close to perfect if you ask me and I was thinking about what makes it so good.. In a word,balance.. It is somehow huge and also restrained..

@SophisticatedBob 4 months ago

I've been to that brewery many times. A few tours, the restaurant, a few music shows. Great place, great beer.

@DougPipersr Creator 3 months ago (edited)

If you want to know how these industry truths translate to what’s actually in your glass, check out Charlie's breakdown of the 10 things that separate average beer from great beer here: https://youtu.be/wQrdbiUDnJI and share in the comments aspects beyond balance that make for great beer!

@MrModamanReviews 4 months ago

My wife and I visited Sierra Nevada's Mills River, NC location a couple of years ago. Beautiful beer garden.

@pv4669 4 months ago

Always love hearing from the Pope of Foam. I really appreciate the discussion on "balanced beers." Thanks Doug

@batistofeles 4 months ago

Good to see you again, great interview. Allways great to hear Mr.Bamforth.

@kendokaca 3 months ago

As a kid, I remember, “Hey Mabel, Black Label”. And while in the Navy, we used to buy Black Label by the case in 11 ounce bottles for $3 at the base exchange.

@jublaim 4 months ago

Thumbs up from Sweden! I visited a nearby small craft beer brewery pop-up pub the other day. Was pleasently surprised by their tasty unfiltered beers. Lager, IPA (and session), english IPA and belgian pale, all balanced and with a good malt base.

@citythink 3 months ago (edited)

Bass was the best ale in the world. For years it was the beer I’d enjoy at Christmas time in Canada (twas a little pricey) … It’s tragic that it’s gone; had the worlds oldest trademark too.

I’m in London Ontario too, and always great to hear my town’s Labatt’s brewery get a mention.

@gregorpastwa1366 4 months ago

Finally you are back with a great video

@johnashcroft8355 3 months ago

Age 17 I spent a week on a student industry program at Bass as Burton. I saw the Bass draft Union system and downed a few samples. Great times!

@johnr7120 4 months ago

Alas, Bass cask ale and Marston’s Pedigree no longer taste as they did in the 1980s due to changes in ownership, production methods, ingredient sourcing, yeast and water sourcing. For example, the sulphur note is absent now and both beers taste nothing like they used to. Many people still drink Bass but have no idea that it is only Bass beer in name - tragic.

@BrettJohnson-q7s 3 months ago

I love to hear a thoroughly competent fellow hold forth on (almost) any topic. This fellow is a wizard. Given his accent, I was a little disappointed to not hear some mention of Newcastle, though.

@blaiseutube 4 months ago

I just visited bariloche Argentina and the regular supermarket beer was amazing.

@paullanham1014 4 months ago

🇬🇧 best pint I can remember drinking was a Bass from a wooden keg behind the bar of the penruddock in Dinton, had many many beers since then but none that stick in the memory like that one