the main character really played his role in an amazing way.

It's not a movie, it's a white paper on Afghanistan. Great actor

Ya Allah i will never complain to you ever again. Forgive me if i have done it in my past. This movie broke my heart into a million pieces. I have been to Kabul, i have walked in those streets. My Muslim brothers living through hell in our neighborhood. I am in my thirties and i cried so much that my sleeves are still wet. If any Afghan is reading my comment, i want you to know that i love you and pray for things to get better. Ameen

Loosing 3 sons would be more than most could bare. Such a dedicated father.

When movies in the rest of the world other than Afghanistan are increasingly becoming frivolous dealing with lighter aspects of life, it is heartening to see Afghan movies are serious and deal with life and death questions involving faith, politics and human values. The movie and its protagonist, Yakub, have been handled with great feeling and depth by the director, photographer and the principal actor. Salaam to all of them and one only hopes the sad and besieged land of Afghanistan find satisfactory answers to the questions to the long-term benefit and peace of Afghanistan and its people.

Afghan actors have so much of talent. Its impossible to see it as a movie. Its as if  one is seeing live events.

this movie is about the pain a father feels when he is about to lose his last son.

Afghanistan has a long history of wars, Afghanistan has longer history of peace, culture and tolerance, a fantastic movie that shows Afghanistan at the crossroads. May there be peace and happiness in Afghanistan.

I am from Bangladesh. It's not just a film, it's a portrayal of Afghanistan. Thanks to the brilliant actors.

I am an Indian. I saw this movie , it is a masterpiece.  Indian cinema  can learn from this, because we  are making stupid movies today .great acting ,screenplay and cinematography ,thanks afghan cinema.

😭😭😭😭😭😭 ohhh my country when will you drink the juice of peace.

Jannat is so dear to these young Muslim, they don't see the harm they cause their parents and the families of those deceased. What kind of selfishness fills them!

سال ۲۰۲۶ کسی هنوز میبینه؟

The ending really crushed me. The way he was so protective over the apples, clinging to the hope that they'd somehow lead him to his son, was heartbreaking. When he finally realized he’d never see him again, that hope shattered. His desperation to give the apples away after that felt like a desperate attempt to hold onto some sense of purpose or gratitude. The emotional shift from holding onto hope to the painful acceptance of loss was devastating and really stayed with me.

Wow this movie is made so real. It should win an oscar award and the the actors should be paid good for their work.

I just watched it and I don't know how do I feel about it, a sad human story.

What a great meaningful movie, I am Iranian and watched this movie which made me proud of my dear Afghan brothers & sisters......BRAVO BRAVO

Heart wrenching movie...the actor who played the role of Yuqub, did complete justice to his character...could really feel him

yaqub is desperate in finding his son, so sad

By far one of the best movies I've ever seen. Actor who played Yaqub is simply unbelievable.