The Socialite Who Threw the Party That Ended an Era and Was Never Seen in Society Again

Old Money Allure

Old Money Allure

58,861 views

This in-depth documentary explores how Gayfryd Steinberg — a telephone clerk's daughter from Vancouver who arrived in New York fleeing a scandal-plagued Louisiana marriage where the IRS had physically entered her home — married the billionaire corporate raider Saul Steinberg, installed herself in a thirty-four-room triplex at 740 Park Avenue decorated with Old Masters worth hundreds of millions, conquered New York society in under five years, threw the most notorious birthday party of the nineteen eighties with live nudes recreating Flemish paintings on the lawn of their Long Island estate — and then watched the entire empire collapse, sold the art at Sotheby's for a fraction of its value, and spent twenty years in silence caring for a husband who could no longer recognize the world she had built for him.

-------------------

Gain FREE access to secret full-length documentaries on wealthy families "too scandalous for YouTube" by joining our newsletter: https://www.substack.com/@oldmoneyluxury

-------------------

The person who would become the self-styled queen of New York's most glittering social circle was born in nineteen fifty in Vancouver, British Columbia, the daughter of Ross McNabb, a telephone company clerk, and his wife Margaret.

The circumstances were deeply ordinary, a modest, middle-class Canadian upbringing with no particular social ambition attached to it by the family.

Vanity Fair, in its celebrated nineteen eighty-six profile, described her origins as humble Canadian beginnings, and the magazine relished the contrast with where she had arrived by then.

The contrast was, in fact, the entire point of the Gayfryd Steinberg story, because the distance between a telephone clerk's household in Vancouver and a thirty-four-room triplex on Park Avenue is not merely geographical or financial.

It is a distance measured in the number of identities a person is willing to shed and the number of social worlds a person is willing to learn from scratch, and Gayfryd McNabb would shed and learn more than most people attempt in several lifetimes.

At twenty, Gayfryd dropped out of the University of British Columbia to marry a metallurgy engineer, with whom she relocated first and most dramatically to South Africa.

It was a bold, even reckless decision for someone her age, and it suggests the patterns that would define her later life: a willingness to make sharp pivots, an appetite for reinvention, and an instinct for aligning herself with men who operated at a certain scale.

South Africa in the early nineteen seventies was a country in the grip of apartheid, a place where the social hierarchies were enforced by law rather than merely by custom, and where an outsider, particularly a young Canadian woman married to an engineer, occupied a specific and constrained position in the social order.

What Gayfryd learned there, if she learned anything applicable to her later career, was that social systems have rules, that the rules can be studied, and that a person who understands the rules can operate within them with a precision that people who were born inside the system rarely bother to develop, because they have never needed to.

The South African chapter ended, and by the mid-nineteen seventies the couple had relocated to New Orleans.

The marriage to the metallurgy engineer ended in nineteen seventy-six.

What followed almost immediately places Gayfryd squarely in the tradition of women who were brilliant social operators but cursed by their early choice of partners.

Within a month of her divorce, she married a man named Norman L. Johnson, a Louisiana businessman connected to the insurance industry, possessed of a fortune substantial enough to afford one of the grandest residences in New Orleans: a mansion on St. Charles Avenue, the storied boulevard of Southern old money, at number six thousand one hundred forty-five.

The Johnson house was not merely large.

Court records would later describe it in unmistakable terms as a fine home, appropriately called a mansion, complete with multiple chandeliers valued as high as seventy-five thousand dollars each.

New Orleans society is one of the oldest and most self-enclosed in America, a world of old Creole families and carnival krewes and inherited positions that is, if anything, more rigid in its hierarchies than the New York society Gayfryd would later conquer.

To occupy a mansion on St. Charles Avenue was to make a statement about where you believed you belonged.

To fill it with artworks considered valuable enough to be seized and placed in storage at the New Orleans Museum of Art was to signal a level of ambition that the city's old guard watched with the particular attention it reserved for newcomers who moved too fast.

The financial disaster at the heart of the Johnson marriage was of a spectacular kind, and Gayfryd's response to it would reveal, for the first time, exactly what she was made of.