OpenTube OpenTube

Why the Future of PATH is Disappointing (and what you can do about it)

Joint Transit Association

Joint Transit Association

22,824 views

Letter Writing Campaign
https://hudcostreets.org/panynj

Thanks to Hudcostreets and Bike Hoboken for this interview!

Sources
https://www.panynj.gov/path/en/about/...

https://jcitytimes.com/transit-advoca...

https://www.panynj.gov/port-authority...

https://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/03/ny...

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/02/ny...

https://catskillarchive.com/rrextra/t...

https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/...

https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/...

https://pix11.com/news/local-news/new...

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/pat...

https://abc7ny.com/post/path-service-...

https://www.nydailynews.com/2025/05/0...

https://www.northjersey.com/story/new...

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science...

Reddit: hudson_and_manhattan_schedule_from_1925

https://www.transit.dot.gov/sites/fta...

https://njbiz.com/long-term-fix-still...

All Videos and Pictures
https://pastebin.com/nfCYTmHD

Note: All photos and videos of the PATH system in this video came from the Port Authority or Wikipedia Commons. The single exception is a photo from the Oculus at around 7:20, which was taken by me.

20 Comments

@jointransitassociation-avatar
@jointransitassociation Creator 1 year ago Pinned
Have you wrote a letter for better PATH frequencies? If not, please take 2 minutes here: https://hudcostreets.org/panynj.
@BrakeCoach-avatar
@BrakeCoach 1 year ago (edited)
The NYC metro area needs more cross-hudson rapid transit, not just the Port Authority!
@A_QueensLink_Fan-avatar
@A_QueensLink_Fan 1 year ago (edited)
I really do hope the PATH improves. I would love to take it more often, but currently I don't have much reason to. I hate that New Jersey is prioritizing highway widenings in this day and age, it's so backwards. Good luck to all PATH riders! I'll definitely help as much as I can as well!
@rlwelch-avatar
@rlwelch 1 year ago
A Subway that runs every 20 minutes is a uniquely American phenomenon.

In Canada it is literally unthinkable to imagine waiting 10 minutes for the TTC subway, Montreal Metro or Vancouver Skytrain
@ceddycedchin-avatar
@ceddycedchin 1 year ago (edited)
PATH was an blunder of epic proportions. It should have been part of either NJ Transit, the LIRR or the subway system, with a 2nd major rail hub in lower Manhattan and a tunnel to developing Downtown Brooklyn (Atlantic Terminal). The lack of coordination between NYC/NJ/Amtrak created the world's most inefficient & ineffective rail system. It should be so much better. Mergers are needed to bring some sense to it all.
@gerrylee1687-avatar
@gerrylee1687 1 year ago
If they have more path trains running on weekends when I work events in Newark, it will be good
@obifox6356-avatar
@obifox6356 1 year ago
Great video with a significant point: importance of train frequency.
It always has been hard to gain political support in NJ for travel to NYC.
@TranscendentAzure89-avatar
@TranscendentAzure89 1 year ago
Now I’d love to see you and JTA as a whole tackle videos on pros and cons of absorbing path lines into MTA and what service patterns and extensions through the five boroughs and Jersey you’d put on that unified map.
@stevenroshni1228-avatar
@stevenroshni1228 1 year ago
12:49 particularly disappointed that PATH isn't doing their part to get New Jersey and WTC to Hoboken for the NJ Transit shuttle to Metlife for the game this weekend. 5/13/25
At the game on Wednesday people were already lining up 4 hours early and America Dream Mall across the walkway had some promotion.
@r179fan7-avatar
@r179fan7 1 year ago
Rode the PATH yesterday from Christopher Street to 34th Street, outside of Rush Hour, had to wait 15 minutes for a slow-ass train to arrive, and now I see why people would rather ride the MTA, even if it's more dangerous.

I really hope PATH can improve, or if the MTA can incorporate PATH into their system.
@void2258-avatar
@void2258 1 year ago (edited)
Music is so loud I can't hear you talking. Had to turn on the CCs just to figure out what is being said.
@Santigomauwu-avatar
@Santigomauwu 1 year ago
0:41 hi!, I recommend you to lower a bit more the background music, because it eclipses your voice!

I recommend you to lower it to -25 to -30 db on your editing software, its a good rule of thumb
@BMTEnjoyer160-avatar
@BMTEnjoyer160 1 month ago
The PATH has been getting improved quite well this year.
@DBSGEEK7-avatar
@DBSGEEK7 1 year ago
Why hasnt the idea of path leaving the PA and joining up with the MTA? Or more advocacy should take places for all the agencies to come together for tri-state regional rail agency, aka TSRRA
@tns22x-avatar
@tns22x 1 year ago
Ironically the entire Hoboken/33rd st lines is having an unplanned closure for the whole weekend at the time this video dropped
@Nexis4Jersey-avatar
@Nexis4Jersey 1 year ago
I would like to see them do the 1960s plan for PATH expansion which had the PATH extended to Newark Airport , Midtown Elizabeth out to Cranford and the North Shore of SI.   Another Branch would split off from just West of Kearny JCT to service DT Harrison , North Newark under Bloomfield Ave up to Montclair.
@ptiger96-avatar
@ptiger96 1 year ago
Not well known is that PATH on weekends used to follow the daytime pattern of four lines, with no detours.  This was suspended in 2006 to accommodate work on the WTC station.  Many years later, it has never been restored and PATH officials will often pretend it never even existed.  It's infuriating.
@maestromecanico597-avatar
@maestromecanico597 1 year ago
Very nicely done. Good and accurate coverage, and I don't normally say that about YouTube videos. PATH has always been a transit wonder hidden in plain sight. But, for the most part, it hasn't changed since the days of the H&M; longer platforms/trains. Any kind of joint service with the TA is a nonstarter for the aforementioned regulatory reasons and the city's transit unions will fight to the death to protect their turf. Nevertheless, the "cleanest" potential would be for PATH to annex the 7 train and extend under the river to Secaucus Transfer and thence connect to Harrison, Newark and ultimately the airport. PATH and the 7 are both built to IRT standards. The TA will have to be given something in return. Maybe the long-delayed 2nd Ave subway? Just some ramblings from a retired railroader in Florida.
@strikerforcevfg4407-avatar
@strikerforcevfg4407 1 year ago (edited)
I really do hope the PATH system improves on its current state. It’s such a good way to get where you need to go to, from NJ to NY and vice versa. And something like that should be worth considering and investing into.

Also, props to you for putting this entire video my guy! Let’s hope PATH evolves into something amazing.
@de-fault_de-fault-avatar
@de-fault_de-fault 1 year ago
The combined JSQ-Hoboken-33 route used to run late nights only on weekdays and start at like 9 on weekends, which was bad enough.  It became an all weekend thing while they were building the current WTC station because not running HOB/WTC allowed them to only use one platform at WTC. They actually went back to running the normal four routes on weekends for a little while but at some point the combined service came back and has not gone away. It really is horrible.
Why the Future of the LIRR is Disappointing thumbnail 18:51

Why the Future of the LIRR is Disappointing

Iq-G9xKrdlg-channel-avatar-Joint Transit Association

Joint Transit Association

36,000 views • 1 yr ago
"Andy Burnham Is Away With The Fairies" – Andrew Neil thumbnail 1:17:24

"Andy Burnham Is Away With The Fairies" – Andrew Neil

eAi7ZqygrCU-channel-avatar-Triggernometry and The Andrew Neil Report

Triggernometry and The Andrew Neil Report

528,000 views • 2 days ago
The Lifesaving Fix New York Won't Install thumbnail 20:48

The Lifesaving Fix New York Won't Install

aYOupT26p2Q-channel-avatar-Double Take

Double Take

2,200,000 views • 2 wk ago
America's First *Real* Transcontinental Railroad might Happen thumbnail 13:18

America's First *Real* Transcontinental Railroad might Happen

zRLsG6oA2HE-channel-avatar-Alan Fisher

Alan Fisher

74,000 views • 1 day ago
The Amsterdam Metro was more controversial than you think  thumbnail 13:46

The Amsterdam Metro was more controversial than you think

sbYLuml_gGM-channel-avatar-Trains Are Awesome

Trains Are Awesome

28,000 views • 23 hr ago
Why Queens still has a Subway Problem thumbnail 28:56

Why Queens still has a Subway Problem

voc1qIS3pFU-channel-avatar-Joint Transit Association

Joint Transit Association

61,000 views • 8 mo ago
The Century Old Idea that Can Revolutionize NYC Commuter Rail thumbnail 29:07

The Century Old Idea that Can Revolutionize NYC Commuter Rail

l0xR6V-GIzc-channel-avatar-Joint Transit Association

Joint Transit Association

40,000 views • 10 mo ago
Where are the fastest escalators in the world? thumbnail 16:03

Where are the fastest escalators in the world?

UWJot1Q2LgY-channel-avatar-Luke O’Sullivan and Joe Dan Hirst

Luke O’Sullivan and Joe Dan Hirst

705,000 views • 2 wk ago
Every Station on the Cotswold Line in One Day! thumbnail 22:51

Every Station on the Cotswold Line in One Day!

n6aJ9ziTnEc-channel-avatar-Nick Badley

Nick Badley

3,500 views • 4 hr ago
Trapped underground: The bizarre truth about London's Waterloo & City tube line thumbnail 8:17

Trapped underground: The bizarre truth about London's Waterloo & City tube line

paXobXlhroc-channel-avatar-Video125 train videos

Video125 train videos

39,000 views • 1 day ago
The Greatest Subway System in the World? | New York City Subway thumbnail 23:43

The Greatest Subway System in the World? | New York City Subway

Q5pfKsBfzCI-channel-avatar-RMTransit

RMTransit

654,000 views • 3 yr ago
How Britain's Most Embarrassing Project Became Its Most Successful thumbnail 12:03

How Britain's Most Embarrassing Project Became Its Most Successful

S3orYaDWIMs-channel-avatar-Terra

Terra

55,000 views • 20 hr ago
Abbey Road (No, Not That One) thumbnail 13:09

Abbey Road (No, Not That One)

pLw0xwXnByY-channel-avatar-Jago Hazzard

Jago Hazzard

46,000 views • 1 day ago
We Crossed Massachusetts by Local Transit! (in one day) thumbnail 51:00

We Crossed Massachusetts by Local Transit! (in one day)

ArJECqSk0qg-channel-avatar-Miles in Transit

Miles in Transit

179,000 views • 2 wk ago
A Plan to Transform New York’s Railways thumbnail 15:29

A Plan to Transform New York’s Railways

s0558KGC2-w-channel-avatar-RMTransit

RMTransit

132,000 views • 2 yr ago
How SEPTA Almost Died in 2025 thumbnail 17:40

How SEPTA Almost Died in 2025

6cycEz4_KVQ-channel-avatar-Classy Whale

Classy Whale

9,700 views • 8 mo ago
Why Light Rail isn’t the Solution for New York thumbnail 19:07

Why Light Rail isn’t the Solution for New York

yLQHKggYb6c-channel-avatar-RMTransit

RMTransit

213,000 views • 2 yr ago
Let's Ride: PATH (Transit Explainer) thumbnail 18:05

Let's Ride: PATH (Transit Explainer)

ogaBvXQ63hY-channel-avatar-Dan Hominem

Dan Hominem

4,000 views • 7 mo ago
Why the Bronx Has Not Expanded its Subway System Since 1941 thumbnail 25:26

Why the Bronx Has Not Expanded its Subway System Since 1941

JCGFK0cXgH4-channel-avatar-Joint Transit Association

Joint Transit Association

58,000 views • 3 mo ago
The Most Urgent Infrastructure Project in the United States thumbnail 21:10

The Most Urgent Infrastructure Project in the United States

p-yrysCjz7M-channel-avatar-Railways Explained

Railways Explained

19,000 views • 2 mo ago

Why the Future of PATH is Disappointing (and what you can do about it)

Joint Transit Association

Joint Transit Association

22,824 views

Letter Writing Campaign
https://hudcostreets.org/panynj

Thanks to Hudcostreets and Bike Hoboken for this interview!

Sources
https://www.panynj.gov/path/en/about/...

https://jcitytimes.com/transit-advoca...

https://www.panynj.gov/port-authority...

https://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/03/ny...

https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/02/ny...

https://catskillarchive.com/rrextra/t...

https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/...

https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/...

https://pix11.com/news/local-news/new...

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/pat...

https://abc7ny.com/post/path-service-...

https://www.nydailynews.com/2025/05/0...

https://www.northjersey.com/story/new...

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science...

Reddit: hudson_and_manhattan_schedule_from_1925

https://www.transit.dot.gov/sites/fta...

https://njbiz.com/long-term-fix-still...

All Videos and Pictures
https://pastebin.com/nfCYTmHD

Note: All photos and videos of the PATH system in this video came from the Port Authority or Wikipedia Commons. The single exception is a photo from the Oculus at around 7:20, which was taken by me.