I haven't seen much information on how the Brompton v. Chedech copyright infringement case actually ended so I did a deep dive into what happened.
This is a link to the original court documents in French, and my English translation: https://drive.google.com/drive/folder...
I did the translation through Word’s built in translator then ChatGPT for any parts that didn’t make much sense. It’s not a professional translation. Also, I omitted the footnotes in the translation for formatting reasons but I did try to keep the structure similar. I did the translation for my own understanding so please excuse the poor formatting. I've kept the highlighting to show what I thought was interesting.
Timestamps:
00:00 - Intro
00:39 - My qualifications or lack thereof
01:10 - Brompton v. Chedech Overview
02:21 - CJEU - Can you copyright a functional design?
05:26 - Belgian court makes the decision
06:32 - Brompton v Chedech: Electric Boogaloo
07:12 - Unfair Commercial Practice Argument
09:36 - Legal Conclusion
11:15 - Ethical/Moral Considerations
Instagram: /velocityprintworks
Email: Ed@Velocityprintworks.com
I haven't seen much information on how the Brompton v. Chedech copyright infringement case actually ended so I did a deep dive into what happened.
This is a link to the original court documents in French, and my English translation: https://drive.google.com/drive/folder...
I did the translation through Word’s built in translator then ChatGPT for any parts that didn’t make much sense. It’s not a professional translation. Also, I omitted the footnotes in the translation for formatting reasons but I did try to keep the structure similar. I did the translation for my own understanding so please excuse the poor formatting. I've kept the highlighting to show what I thought was interesting.
Timestamps:
00:00 - Intro
00:39 - My qualifications or lack thereof
01:10 - Brompton v. Chedech Overview
02:21 - CJEU - Can you copyright a functional design?
05:26 - Belgian court makes the decision
06:32 - Brompton v Chedech: Electric Boogaloo
07:12 - Unfair Commercial Practice Argument
09:36 - Legal Conclusion
11:15 - Ethical/Moral Considerations
Instagram: /velocityprintworks
Email: Ed@Velocityprintworks.com
I am Oscar, who started Chedech in 2013.
It was not easy to make the Chedech bicycle sturdy.
The straight-frame design struggled to resist the twisting forces applied to the entire frame.
To solve this issue, we built the inside of the frame with a dual-structure design.
And we did not copy any part from Brompton.
Created new hinges, adopting 18 inches wheels, and used all parts made by Carbon.
However, we survived and are launching a new model this year.
I hope to enter the EU market this year.
Thank you again for the nice review.