God that was hard to watch

I like watching these normally, but this was a hard watch 😢

Jeez. If you’re a baseball fan you have looked at the all time leaderboards several times in your life. This was painful

Brewers fan here.  Uecker would regularly talk about how bad of a player he was, and he finished with a career 146 hits.  I am awarding you the worst guess of the year so far!

Saying Chris Davis before Eddie Murray might have been the biggest rage bait of 2026 already lol

Not even a Brewers fan and yelled Paul Molitor about a dozen times.

Tony Gwynn stole over 300 bases in his career. It was only at the end of his career that he gained weight and became slow.

saying carlton fisk at third base would get you stabbed in boston

The hint for Lou Brock.... he had the all time steals record that Rickey broke.

Gwynn was fast early in his career.  A base stealer

How do we have guys on YouTube that know less than so many average fans

12:49 “Who was arguably the best player on the ‘86 World Series Sox”
Me “I know he means Boggs but in reality it was Clemens”

I do not call myself an expert, nor do I have my own YouTube channel, but I breezed through this list, this was painful.

Gwynn was a serious stolen base threat early in his career.  He definitely had speed then.

This was brutal, but It was a blast!! more of these please

Stan Musial had 3,630 hits and retired after the 1963 season. Why isn't he on this post-1950 list?

Brutal

Can’t allow Gwynn slander in here. He absolutely was known for having speed for the first half of his career. Dude stole 30+ bases four times, with a high of 56. He also used that speed to be a premier defender in right (5 gold gloves)

It makes it more interesting having someone who knows little about baseball trying to guess the players

Winfield as a Yankee and not a Padre is weird.